4 ms·
I see where you're coming from, but I think you might be underestimating what modern LLMs can do. Sure, at their core they're predicting text, but that ability
by stavros 2y ago
I see where you're coming from, but I think you might be underestimating what modern LLMs can do. Sure, at their core they're predicting text, but that ability translates into some pretty impressive capabilities when it comes to understanding and analyzing complex systems.
Think about it - these models have been trained on mountains of technical docs, incident reports, and discussions about cloud systems. They've soaked up a ton of knowledge about how these systems work and what tends to go wrong.
You're right that they don't reason from first principles, but they're incredibly good at spotting patterns. When you feed an LLM details about an incident, it can quickly pick up on similarities to known issues and suggest potential causes. It's not just making stuff up - it's drawing on a vast pool of relevant information.
And these models aren't just spitting out random text. They've gotten really good at understanding context and applying the right knowledge to a given situation. They can take in technical details about an incident and connect them to possible root causes in ways that can be surprisingly insightful.
I'd argue that LLMs can actually be pretty effective tools for analyzing failures in complex systems. They can process tons of information quickly, spot connections humans might miss, and generate multiple plausible hypotheses for what went wrong. They're not replacing human experts, but they can definitely augment our capabilities and speed up the initial triage process.
There are already some success stories out there of LLMs being used effectively in IT ops and incident analysis. And as these models get fine-tuned on more specific cloud-related data, their performance in this area is only going to improve.
You're right to be cautious about applying LLMs everywhere just because we can. But in this case, I think they actually have a lot to offer when it comes to cloud incident analysis, especially when used alongside other tools and human expertise. They're not a silver bullet, but they're definitely more than just elaborate text predictors when it comes to tasks like this.
This comment was written by an LLM. If it can make a coherent argument, I guess it can process information about an incident, too.