3 ms·
Fair Source licensing is the worst thing to happen to open source-definitely ma (2016)
- stavros 2y agoThis is wrong. Fair Source licensing is the best thing to happen to closed source. Zero codebases choose between FOSS or Fair Source. The choice is always between Fair Source and completely closed.
- evanjrowley 2y agoI think I agree with you. The author's concept of "true open source" software will never seriously be provided to end-users in any form besides a closed source binary. That's my interpretation of this statement several sentences in, where they essentially reject FOSS: >While free software licensing (e.g., GNU General Public License) attempts to force freedom on downstream developers, true open source basically says, "Take this software, use it and improve it (or not), and license the resulting product as you wish." It seems like the author's definition of successful software is closed source software. See their point of criticism of Fair Source: >Fair Source says, in essence, "You have all the rights of open source until your derivative work is actually popular. At that point you must pay." In other words, if your software stinks and no one wants to use it, hurray! It's open for usage, redistribution, and modification. The CentOS and source code access problem in post-acquisition Red Hat makes it a terrible example to cite for the author's conclusion: >There is no money in (selling) open source, as I've argued many times. There is, however, a mountain of cash waiting for those that monetize open source indirectly through support/software services like Red Hat, and even more for those that don't sell software-related services at all. The supporting arguments and overall take is low quality.
- stavros 2y ago> It seems like the author's definition of successful software is closed source software. I think they mean MIT-style licenses, rather than GNU-style. That's how I read it, at least. You wouldn't be able to improve closed-source software.
- unethical_ban 2y agoOne could argue fair source is like a progressive tax system. You can audit the code and use it for small use cases, but if you make enough money on it to have big impact, the parent company wants a slice.
- evanjrowley 2y agoThat's an improvement over closed-source free trial software.
- matharmin 2y agoThe article is from 2016, and that point doesn't hold anymore. If you take the Functional Source License (from the current fair.io site), there is no restriction on the number of users or company size - it typically only prevents competing use cases.
- matharmin 2y agoThe article is from 2016, and quite a bit has changed since then - both in the ecosystem (many previously "open source" companies moving away from that model), and in the new licenses available to be used. I really like the Functional Source License (FSL) (the main license under the Fair Source brand), and we've adopted it at my company. It's not open source, and shouldn't be compared with that. But you do get a lot of the same advantages as you'd get from an open-source product, such as being able to inspect the source code to get an understanding of how the system works.
- michaelmrose 2y ago> While free software licensing (e.g., GNU General Public License) attempts to force freedom on downstream developers, true open source basically says, "Take this software, use it and improve it (or not), and license the resulting product as you wish." "True open source" "force freedom on downstream developers" GPL and BSD style licenses are both "true open source". If you are the upstream you literally aren't contained by any license and if you are downstream you are only constrained to offer exactly what you received and are free to write it yourself if that is too big of an ask. > For some bizarro reason, open source companies keep trying to monetize software even as the rest of the world has moved on The bizarro reason is that people literally need to eat. They can't "move on" unless they want to move on into the woods to live like a hobo. We either have to give up entirely on independent devs or find some way to pay them. > It's the wrong way to treat developers You aren't being mistreated if you don't like the license something is offered under. Writer is...gross.
- mistrial9 2y agoagree that the assumptions for the writer are large and undisclosed in this rant-article. >> Apache-style open-source licensing has clearly won out over the GPL this is telling.. neither license "won out" .. the world of software, use of software, and economics of software, are all expanding dramatically in real time. Define "win" in that context ? too many assumptions, too much tirade.. > We either have to give up entirely on independent devs or find some way to pay them. yes
- jacknews 2y ago" There is, however, a mountain of cash waiting for those that monetize open source " Isn't this the point? If you release software that runs your service as open-source, you want to prevent Amazon coming along and making their own cloud service based on your code.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]