Except this is not pointing in the right direction. It's demonstrably wrong. He then criticizes the author of the table, calling that person wrong. If I were h

Except this is not pointing in the right direction. It's demonstrably wrong. He then criticizes the author of the table, calling that person wrong. If I were hiring a consultant claiming math analysis skills and they posted such a fundamental mistake, I'd honestly move on to someone else. I've read Cook's post a long time, and he doesn't often make such logic errors. I suspect he'll retract his claims once he realizes his errors.