5 ms·
This distinction gets lost in these discussions all of the time. A company that makes an effort to comply with laws is in a completely different category than a
by Aurornis 2y ago
This distinction gets lost in these discussions all of the time. A company that makes an effort to comply with laws is in a completely different category than a company that makes the fact that they’ll look the other way one of their core selling points.
Years ago there was a case where someone built a business out of making hidden compartments in cars. He did an amazing job of making James Bond style hidden compartments that perfectly blended into the interior. He was later arrested because drug dealers used his hidden compartment business to help their drug trade.
There was an uproar about the fact that he wasn’t doing the drug crimes himself. He was only making hidden compartments which could be used for anything. How was he supposed to know that the hidden compartments were being used for illegal activities rather than keeping people’s valuables safe during a break-in?
Yet when the details of the case came out, IIRC, it was clear that he was leaning into the illegal trades and marketing his services to those people. He lost his plausible deniability after even a cursory look at how he was operating.
I don’t know what, if any, parts of that case apply to Pavel Durov. I do like to share it as an example of how intent matters and how one can become complicit in other crimes by operating in a manner where one of your selling points is that you’ll help anyone out even when their intent is to break the law. It’s also why smart corporate criminals will shut down and walk away when it becomes too obvious that they’re losing plausible deniability in a criminal enterprise.
- kyleee 2y agoIs it illegal to offer legal services to undesirables and/or criminals?
- alephnerd 2y agoYes. If you are directly aiding and abetting without any plausible attempt to minimize bad actors from using your services then absolutely. For example, CP absolutely exists on platforms like FB or IG, but Meta will absolutely try to moderate it away to the best of their ability and cooperate with law enforcement when it is brought to their attention. And like I have mentioned a couple times before, Telegram was only allowed to exist because the UAE allowed them to, and both the UAE and Russia gained ownership stakes in Telegram by 2021. Also, messaging apps can only legally operate in the UAE if they provide decryption keys to the UAE govt because all instant messaging apps are treated as VoIP under their Telco regulation laws. There have been plenty of cases where anti-Russian govt content was moderated away during the 2021 protests - https://www.wired.com/story/the-kremlin-has-entered-the-chat/ https://www.wired.com/story/the-kremlin-has-entered-the-chat...
- peoplefromibiza 2y ago> If you are directly aiding and abetting without any plausible attempt to minimize bad actors from using your service isn't this the definition of "criminal lawyer"?
- alephnerd 2y agoIf you are a criminal lawyer who is providing defense, that is acceptable because everyone is entitled to to a fair trial and defense. If you are a criminal lawyer who is directly abetting in criminal behavior (eg. a Saul Goodman type) you absolutely will lose your Bar License and open yourself up to criminal penalties. If you are a criminal lawyer who is in a situation where your client wants you to abet their criminal behavior, then you are expected to drop the client and potentially notify law enforcement.
- throwaway48476 2y agoThere was a recent gang related case in Georgia where several defense lawyers were charged for being a little too involved.
- MertsA 2y agoAre you talking about Brian Steel? He was held in contempt because he refused to name his source that informed him of some misconduct by the judge (ex parte communication with a witness). That's hardly relevant here, the client wasn't involved at all as far as anyone knows. https://www.reddit.com/r/Lawyertalk/comments/1dd32ji/brian_steele_young_thugs_lawyer_held_in_criminal/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Lawyertalk/comments/1dd32ji/brian_s...
- themaninthedark 2y agoIt was records and communication that the lawyer made on behalf of his client. More interesting is why the judge and prosecutors have not been referred to the bar for their illegal actions.
- moqmar 2y agoIn most jurisdictions yes AFAIK, if those services directly help an illegal activity, and you knew about the illegal activity.
- whatnotests2 2y agoOk, like selling gasoline to the getaway car driver?
- forrestthewoods 2y ago> and you knew about the illegal behavior Your analogy is terrible and doesn’t make sense. If you provide a service that is used for illegal behavior AND you know it’s being used that way AND you explicitly market your services to users behaving illegally AND the majority of your product is used for illegal deeds THEN you’re gonna have a bad time. If one out of ten thousand people use your product for illegal deeds you’re fine. If it’s 9 out of 10 you probably aren’t.
- coliveira 2y ago> If one out of ten thousand people use your product for illegal deeds you’re fine. This logic clearly makes the prison of someone like the owner of Telegram difficult to justify, since 99.999% of messages in telegram are completely legal.
- forrestthewoods 2y agoIf 10,000 people out of 10 million are doing illegal things and you know about it or you are going out of your way to turn a blind eye then you’re gonna have a bad time. This really isn’t that complicated.
- coliveira 2y agoBut how would you know about this illegal activity, if the product can be used by anyone? Only if you were eavesdropping on your users...
- ajross 2y agoIf you know your services are going to be used to commit a crime, then yes, that makes you an accessory and basically all jurisdictions (I know basically nothing about French criminal law) can prosecute you for that. Crime is, y'know, illegal.
- ipaddr 2y agoShouldn't gmail be closing as they know a percentage will be used for crime?
- coliveira 2y agoThe answer to this charade is that to "prove" that you're not doing anything wrong you need to secretly provide all data from anyone that the government doesn't like. Otherwise you go to jail.
- nomdep 2y agoI'm appalled that you would argue in good faith that a tool for communicating in secret can be reasonably described as a service used to commit a crime. Why aren't all gun manufacturers in jail then? They must know a percentage of their products are going to be used to commit crimes. A much larger percentage than those using Telegram to commit one.
- amanaplanacanal 2y agoThe difference is knowing some percentage will be used to commit crimes, and knowing a specific individual is going to use it to commit a crime.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- coliveira 2y agoEven worse, in the US they clearly go out of their way to lobby for no control of gun sales. They should be indicted as facilitating crime.
- Muromec 2y agoTry to deposit 10k to your bank account and then, when they call you and ask the obvious question, answer that you sold some meth or robbed someone. They will totally be fine with this answer, as they are just a platform for providing money services and well, you can always just pay for everything in cash.
- akira2501 2y agoIf you deposit more than 10k the IRS simply gets automatically notified. No one calls you to ask where you got the money. The IRS actually expects you to report income earned from illegal activities, they _explicitly_ state this in Publication 17.
- dawnerd 2y agoAnd even then you don’t have to tell them it’s illegal. Just what you earned. Frankly they don’t care where it came from as long as you report and pay.
- thaumasiotes 2y agoNo, you have to specify where it came from. You don't have to say what crime you committed, but you'd list the income under "income from illegal activities".
- dawnerd 2y agoIt’s very loose. You can just say cash and that’s fine.
- thaumasiotes 2y ago> You can just say cash and that’s fine. Cash isn't income. It's an asset. You don't even report assets. You report income, and you have to specify where it came from.
- cbsmith 2y agoAiding and abetting. It's a crime.
- peoplefromibiza 2y ago> operating in a manner where one of your selling points is that you’ll help anyone out even when their intent is to break the law is it what happened here? in my view Durov is the owner renting his apartment and not caring what people do inside it, which is not illegal, someone could go as fare as say that it is morally reprensible, but it's not illegal in any way. It would be different if Durov knew but did not report it. Which, again, doesn't seem what happened here and it must be proven in a court anyway, I believe everyone in our western legal systems still has the right to the presumption of innocence. Telegram not spying on its users is the same thing as Mullvad not spying on its users and not saving the logs. I consider it a feature not a bug, for sure not complicity in any crime whatsoever.
- hiq 2y ago> the owner renting his apartment and not caring what people do inside it, which is not illegal Problem is if you know what these people do inside it and you don't do anything about it.
- peoplefromibiza 2y agoWhich is something that should be proven in court. Problem is if the police arrests the owner of the apartment but not those doing something illegal inside it. Out of metaphor: Durov has been arrested because he's Russian and the west is retaliating as hard as they can. Under the same assumptions Durov has been arrested for, Elon Musk and Jack Dorsey should be in jail too. [1] [1] https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/sep/04/twitter-saudi-arabia-human-rights-abuses https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/sep/04/twitter-saudi-...
- fallingknife 2y agoWhat do you mean "look the other way?" Does the phone company "look the other way" when they don't listen in to your calls? Does the post office "look the other way" when they don't read your mail? That guy who built the hidden compartments should absolutely not have gone to jail. The government needs to be put in check. This has gotten ridiculous.
- marcinzm 2y agoIf the police tell them illegal activity is happening and give them a warrant to wiretap and they are capable of doing so but refuse then yeah they’re looking the other way. That’s not even getting into things like PRISM.
- nmfisher 2y agoThe phone and post company definitively do not just look the other way. They all have procedures in place to cooperate with law enforcement requests.