4 ms·
This is semi-offtopic, but "trust but verify" is an oxymoron. Trusting something means I don't have to verify whether it's correct (I trust that it is), so the
by stavros 2y ago
This is semi-offtopic, but "trust but verify" is an oxymoron. Trusting something means I don't have to verify whether it's correct (I trust that it is), so the saying, in the end, is "don't verify but verify".
- cromka 2y agoA better phrase would be “Use it but verify”, simply.
- stavros 2y agoYes, which boils down to "verify".
- EGreg 2y agoI always wondered about that
- bilal9684 2y ago[flagged]
- cj 2y agoIt's possible to trust (or have faith) in my car being able to drive another 50k miles without breaking down. But if I bring it to a mechanic to have the car inspected just in case, does that mean I never had trust/faith in the car to begin with? "I trust my coworkers write good code, but I verify with code reviews" -- doing code reviews doesn't mean you don't trust your coworker. Yet another way to look at it: people can say things they believe to be true but are actually false (which isn't lying). When that happens, you can successfully trust someone in the sense that they're not lying to you, but the absence of a lie doesn't guarantee a truth, so verifying what you trust to be true doesn't invalidate your trust.
- stavros 2y agoWe're getting into the definition of trust, but to me trust means exactly "I don't need to verify". If I say I trust you to write correct code, I don't mean "I'm sure your mistakes won't be intentional", I mean "I'm sure you won't have mistakes". If I need to check your code for mistakes, I don't trust you to write correct code. I don't know anyone who will hear "I trust you to write correct code, now let me make sure it's correct" and think "yes, this sentence makes sense".
- cj 2y ago“I trust that you believe your code is correct, now let’s double check”. Or maybe the proverb needs to be rewritten as “feign trust and verify”
- rpdillon 2y ago> to me trust means exactly "I don't need to verify". If you use the slightly weaker definition that trust means you have confidence in someone, then the adage makes sense.
- stavros 2y agoThe issue here is that the only value of the adage is in the sleight of hand it lets you perform. If someone asks "don't you trust me?" (ie "do you have to verify what I do/say?"), you can say "trust, but verify!", and kind of make it sound like you do trust them, but also you don't really. The adage doesn't work under any definition of trust other than the one it's conflicting with itself about.
- jrflowers 2y agoYep. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trust,_but_verify https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trust,_but_verify
- soulofmischief 2y ago> He said "President Reagan's old adage about 'trust but verify' ... is in need of an update. And we have committed here to a standard that says 'verify and verify'."
- Diti 2y agoFrench armed forces have a better version of this saying. “Trust does not exclude control.” They’re still going to check for explosives under cars that want to park in French embassies.
- RandomThoughts3 2y agoIt’s interesting to notice that etymologically speaking the French and English words have completely different roots and therefore evokes slightly different ideas which are lost in translation. Trust shares its root with truth. It’s directly related to believing in the veracity of something. Confiance comes from the Latin confidere which means depositing something to someone while having faith they are going to take good care of it. The accent is on the faith in the relationship, not the truthfulness. The tension between trust and control doesn’t really exist in French. You can have faith but still check.
- mathgeek 2y ago> Trust shares its root with truth. It’s directly related to believing in the veracity of something. Would you mind sharing your reference on that? All the etymology sites I rely on seem to place the root in words that end up at "solid" or "comfort".
- RandomThoughts3 2y agoDefinitely and that’s not incompatible with what I’m saying. You are indeed looking far back to the Proto-Indo-European where words are very different and sometimes a bit of guesses. If you look at the whole tree, you will see that both trust, truth and true share common Germanic roots (that’s pretty obvious by looking at them) which is indeed linked with words meaning “solid” and then “promise, contract”. What’s interesting is that the root is shared between “truth” and “trust” while in French it’s not (vérité from veritas vs confiance from confere).
- hoistbypetard 2y agoI think a better translation of "control" in that saying is "checking" or "testing". "Control" in present-day English is a false cognate there.
- survirtual 2y agoIs it an oxymoron to generate an asymmetrical cryptographic signature, send it to someone, and that someone verify the signature with the public key? Why not just "trust" them instead? You have a contact and you know them, can't you trust them? This is what "trust but verify" means. It means audit everything you can. Do not really on trust alone. An entire civilization can be built with this methodology. It would be a much better one than the one we have now.
- stavros 2y ago> Is it an oxymoron to generate an asymmetrical cryptographic signature, send it to someone, and that someone verify the signature with the public key? Of course not. I verify because I don't trust them. > Why not just "trust" them instead? You have a contact and you know them, can't you trust them? No, the risk of trust is too high against the cost of spending a second verifying. > This is what "trust but verify" means. It means audit everything you can. Do not really on trust alone. Your comment just showed an example of something I don't trust and asked "why not trust instead"? The question even undermines your very point, because "why not trust them instead?" assumes (correctly) that I don't trust them, so I need to verify.
- survirtual 2y agoIt was sarcasm. "Why not trust them instead?" Clearly, you wouldn't and you can't. It takes moments to verify a signature, so just do it.
- TeMPOraL 2y ago> An entire civilization can be built with this methodology. It would be a much better one than the one we have now. No, it wouldn't. Trust is an optimization that enables civilization. The extreme end of "verify" is the philosophy behind cryptocurrencies: never trust, always verify. It's interesting because it provides an exchange rate between trust and kilowatt hours you have to burn to not rely on it.
- survirtual 2y ago
- IWeldMelons 2y agoThis is not quite true. "Trust" is to give a permission for someone to act on achieving some result. "Verify" means assess the achieved result, and correct aposteriori the probability with which said person is able to achieve the abocementioned result. This is the way Bayesian reasoning works. Trust has degrees. What you have brought is "unconditional trust". Very rarely works.
- stavros 2y ago> "Trust" is to give a permission for someone to act on achieving some result. This would make the sentence "I asked him to wash the dishes properly, but I don't trust him", as your definition expands this to "I asked him to wash the dishes properly, but I didn't give him permission to achieve this result". If you say "I asked someone to do X but I don't trust them", it means you aren't confident they'll do it properly, thus you have to verify. If you say "I asked him to do X and I trust him, so I don't need to check up on him", it's unlikely to leave people puzzled. It's surprising to me to see this many comments arguing against the common usage of trust, just because of a self-conflicting phrase.
- neom 2y agoWhy could I not say "I trusted him to do the dishes properly, after he was done, I verified, it's a good thing I trusted him to do the dishes properly, my supervision would have been unwarranted and my trust was warranted?" I trusted someone to do their task correctly, after the task was done, I verified my trust was warranted.
- stavros 2y agoWhat would be different if you didn't trust them to do it correctly?
- neom 2y agoInstead of sitting in my office doing my work, then, spending a few minutes to verify once they're done, I'd sit in the kitchen next to them checking it as they went, being both distracted AND probably spending more time. I'd much rather trust but verify.
- msabalau 2y agoPragmatically, the statement was made famous in English by a conservative US president, addressing the nation, including his supporters, who trusted him, but not the Soviets with whom he was negotiating. Saying, in effect: "you trust in me, I'm choosing to trust that it makes sense to make agreement with the USSR, and we are going to verify it, just as we would with any serious business, as is proverbially commonsensical" is a perfectly intelligible. There is nothing cunning about clinging to a single, superficial, context free reading of language. Human speech and writting is not code, ambiguity and containing a range of possible meanings is part of its power and value.
- stavros 2y agoSo "trust me, but verify others"? Where have you seen this adage used in this sense? It's not even used like that in the original Russian, where Reagan lifted it from.
- AmericanChopper 2y agoI think that’s a rather peculiar interpretation. I always thought it was pretty obvious that Reagan was just saying that he didn’t trust the soviets, and found a polite excuse not to in the form of the Russian proverb.
- jgalt212 2y ago> Trust, but verify (Russian: доверяй, но проверяй, romanized: doveryay, no proveryay, IPA: [dəvʲɪˈrʲæj no prəvʲɪˈrʲæj]) is a Russian proverb, which rhymes in Russian. The phrase became internationally known in English after Suzanne Massie, a scholar of Russian history, taught it to Ronald Reagan, then president of the United States, who used it on several occasions in the context of nuclear disarmament discussions with the Soviet Union.
- SoftTalker 2y agoThat's only one possible meaning of the word "trust," i.e. a firm belief. Trust can also mean leaving something in the care of another, and it can also mean relying on something in the future, neither of these precludes a need to verify. Edit: jgalt212 says in another reply that it's also the English translation of a Russian idiom. Assuming that's true, that would make a lot of sense in this context, since the phrase was popularized by Reagan talking about nuclear arms agreements with the USSR. It would be just like him to turn a Russian phrase around on them. It's somewhat humorous, but also conveys "I know how you think, don't try to fool me."
- enoch_r 2y agoIt basically means "trust, but not too much."
- rendaw 2y agoMy theory that it's a sophism to mollify people who are offended by not being trusted, or to mollify people who think not trusting is rude. I'd just assume see it not used though.
- newaccount74 2y agoIt's a more friendly way of saying "trust noone".
- krunck 2y agoOr another way of understanding it: trust (now), but verify (later). It's a Russian proverb BTW: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trust%2C_but_verify https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trust%2C_but_verify