4 ms·
I said immigration creates disorder. Your points about America prove rather than rebut my point. America is rich, but it’s not orderly. Everything from individ
by rayiner 2y ago
I said immigration creates disorder. Your points about America prove rather than rebut my point. America is rich, but it’s not orderly. Everything from individual social interactions to the operation of every level of government is characterized by disorder resulting from heterogeneity.
Japan is considering more immigration to deal with its population problems, but the juice isn’t worth the squeeze.
- tptacek 2y agoUh, if you say so. I'm sorry about your neighbors. Mine are pretty great.
- rayiner 2y agoMy neighbors are great. I have an Italian neighbor. He’s great too. But for two generations, American democracy was upended as Italians voting as an ethnic bloc fueled corrupt machine politics. New York and New Jersey never recovered. Your neighbors might be great as individuals as well. That’s irrelevant to my point. Chicago might be the poster child of a city that could’ve been orderly and well run. Except for the last century it’s been riven by ethnic conflict and immigration-fueled machine politics that has sapped the government’s ability to actually serve its people. Contrast New England. A large number of people from New England retire in the Annapolis area because of the sailing and warmer weather. The cultural difference is undeniable. Many have said to me that, growing up, they learned food was for surviving, not enjoying. They cut donuts in half at events so people aren’t tempted to eat too much, and regularly run out of food (because better to run out of food than to waste it). As a Bangladeshi, I find them totally unrelatable and frankly kind of scary in how little they seem to care about having grandchildren. But it’s impossible to deny that the little New England towns they created are extremely orderly places.