3 ms·
getting raw materials from space onto the surface of earth intact is such an easy problem that dumb rocks do it literally every day entirely by accident. you j
by kragen 2y ago
getting raw materials from space onto the surface of earth intact is such an easy problem that dumb rocks do it literally every day entirely by accident. you just need a low enough sectional density that it loses most of its kinetic energy to the atmosphere rather than exploding when it hits the ground (i.e., not much higher than 1kg/cm²), a high enough sectional density that it doesn't burn up entirely given whatever materials are on the front side of it, a shape that's aerodynamically stable in the supersonic regime, aerodynamics and structural integrity such that what doesn't ablate lands in one piece rather than exploding into a fireball, and good enough targeting that it lands on land in friendly territory rather than at the bottom of the ocean
i mean i'm not an expert in the area, but i think this is a well-understood set of problems. passive reentry vehicles have been used for decades for spy satellite film canisters, v-2 ballistic missiles, scud ballistic missiles, icbms, mirvs, and space capsules like those used in the vostok, apollo, and mercury programs. it gets easier in this case because you don't care if it breaks when it hits the ground, so you don't need parachutes or retrorockets; you just don't want it to vaporize
specifically, a hunk of mass at rest at the von kármán line of 100 km has 981 kilojoules per kilogram of gravitational potential energy with respect to the ground. one degree of temperature is roughly one kilojoule per kilogram, so that's roughly 981 degrees of heating if it falls to the ground from that height with no further air resistance—not enough to melt steel, nickel, gold, platinum, or even mafic rocks. and it's still 981 kilojules per kilogram whether it's a kilogram of platinum or a thousand tons of platinum. but it gets better! that heating is shared between the reentry vehicle and a somewhat larger mass of whatever it hits, roughly in inverse proportion to their stiffness. and of course there is atmospheric resistance, even without a parachute—quite a significant amount of it at the comparatively low sectional densities you need to lose most of your escape velocity from hitting the atmosphere. so, typically, when meteorites land, they aren't even hot. the arguments above explain why in most cases they can't be hot unless they hit so hard as to blow open a crater
980 kilojoules per kilogram is 1400 meters per second, about mach 4, so you really don't want it to hit you. but it won't even melt, and newton's penetration depth approximation assures you it won't penetrate very far into the ground, like, less than a meter
so basically you're worried about a nonproblem