2 ms·
You sound like review 2: speaks from authority and gives criticism with little substance. > You're already familiar with most of them In what way? Their pre
by godelski 2y ago
You sound like review 2: speaks from authority and gives criticism with little substance.
> You're already familiar with most of them
In what way? Their prestige? If I went about outsourcing my opinions of people to others I'd hold many criminals and objectional people in high regard while also looking down at many great men. Even if this works 80% of the time you trust *but verify*. Have some actual confidence in yourself. Stop outsourcing your intellectualism.
> I've served on several program committees
Then maybe stop complaining and start critiquing.
You speak with an air of authority and that we should trust you but give no actual reason why. Use your experience and expertise to educate us. Don't just say I'm wrong, say why I'm wrong. Convince me you're right not through ethos, but logos. This is what everyone hates about review 2. Don't become him.
I believe you've also missed the substance of what I originally suggested. You're so caught up in the standard way you injected it into my comment without even noticing. You forgot the point all of this. It to climb the ladder of academia, get grants, and all that. It is about advancing science and moving humanity forward. The way to measure this isn't meaningful at our disposal. You can't measure this by citations or indices, by publications or venues. Again, they can be a signal (I'm not saying to throw out the baby with the bath water), but I don't believe you're naive enough to not be aware of how frequent progress is made by those who fail on those measures, how frequent it comes from a dark horse. This should be enough to suggest that there's more to it than what we usually consider. Academia has always been about challenging the status quo, even if it is just to verify. The problem with academia is it's created to give refuge to those who want to spend their lives dreaming but has become so structured you can only dream a certain way. I get why. It's hard to differentiate useless pipe dreams from those that push us forward. But in creating the structure to prevent people from taking a free ride you created the monster you tried to stop. Only now it has more power.
So don't just wave your hands dismissing, elaborate. Be academic not arrogant.
- JohnKemeny 2y ago>> You're already familiar with most of them > In what way? Their prestige? In the sense that I've read most of their papers, I've even reviewed several of them. I've literally just handed in a report for an expert committee to hire a new faculty member, and I had read papers from all applicants that were relevant and reviewed for more than half of them. >> I've served on several program committees > Then maybe stop complaining and start critiquing. I'm not complaining about anything. I just tried to lay out my point of view. And yes, I'm aware of the painful measures that citations and impact factors are, but, like any other HN reader, I'm aware of Goodhart's law. My point is that we're (I'm) not using citations or publication points to rank researchers. We know them.
- godelski 2y ago> In the sense that I've read most of their papers, I've even reviewed several of them. Which means you.... Read the papers... So what was the point of your comments