5 ms·
"If Linus would get off his high horse about closed source drivers" ... then he would be Microsoft and Apple, and not an Open Source operating system developer
by muhfuhkuh 14y ago
"If Linus would get off his high horse about closed source drivers"
... then he would be Microsoft and Apple, and not an Open Source operating system developer, maintainer, producer, and evangelist. All his years of working openly and freely will be squandered and his life's work beholden to closed-source, closed spec device manufacturers.
- TylerE 14y agoBut his stance actually makes us much MORE beholden to the 3rd parties. If every minor kernel version didn't require the vendors to recompiled drivers, and quite possible change code because Linus changed the ABI again, that would result in more hardware working better for more people. Live the open source dream if it makes you feel good. I live in a world where if it doesn't work, I couldn't care less about it. Pragmatism > Dogma
- ajross 14y agoI don't think reality bears this out. Now that Broadcom has come to their senses, NVIDIA is pretty much the only major consumer device vendor in the PC space with binary blob drivers. Everyone else has, ultimately, folded in the face of pressure from the dogmatists. I think Linus is pretty much winning, and the fact that NVIDIA is feeling pressure here is a good thing. Do you have any examples of situations where this is making us "MORE" beholden to third parties? I honestly don't see many (though in the SoC space, the PVR drivers are a very similar situation).
- TylerE 14y agoWhat about ATI?
- jlgreco 14y agoDidn't AMD release a ton of documentation for their GPUs specifically so that the open source radeon drivers could become a realistic option when using their GPUs? Nobody I know with an AMD GPU uses the propriety fglrx drivers.
- TylerE 14y agoOpen source 3D drivers will have a hard time EVER being useable for anything beyond glgears... everything in that space is going to be really patent encumbered.
- jlgreco 14y agoFrankly, if you are looking to play games than you are wasting your time with any of the available GPU/driver combinations on Linux. If that's not what you are after, then I don't know what more than working KMS and enough "umph" to run a compositing window manager you could need.
- tadfisher 14y ago> working KMS Something that NVIDIA refuses to support :)
- ajuc 14y agoFortunately most of the world don't care about software patents :)
- LeonidasXIV 14y agoBroadcom OTOH still has crappy ARM SoCs that require binary blobs. Just like most ARM GPUs that run on Linux.
- LeonidasXIV 14y agoPragmatism is running Windows. Or Mac OS X. There's people that prefer it this way on Linux.
- TylerE 14y agoWhich is what I mostly do these days.