6 ms·
It's remarkably straight-talking for a press release, actually. Money quote is this one: "While we understand that some people would prefer us to provide detai
by ajross 14y ago
It's remarkably straight-talking for a press release, actually. Money quote is this one: "While we understand that some people would prefer us to provide detailed documentation on all of our GPU internals, or be more active in Linux kernel community development discussions, we have made a decision to support Linux on our GPUs by leveraging NVIDIA common code, rather than the Linux common infrastructure.".
Basically, they recognize that they don't support DRI2/KMS, or libva, or hybrid graphics. And they don't care. They think their stuff works better for them and the customers they care about. And they don't expect this to change.
I guess I can respect that, even if I disagree.
(Then they go into PR mode in the final point, arguing that NVIDIA has contributed lots and lots of Linux patches for the Tegra SoCs, which is obviously true but irrelevant to the controversy.)
- loxs 14y agoYup, totally the kind of bullshit Linus gave the finger to... I can imagine how much of this "PR" stuff one like Linus gets to deal with...
- tadfisher 14y agoWhich is ridiculous, considering they cherry-picked RandR of all the technologies in the "Linux common infrastructure" to support with their latest driver release. I suppose I should be grateful that my projector can work without opening up NVIDIA Settings and tweaking about, but it certainly flies in the face of this statement and belies their true motivations: they'll implement the bare-minimum Linux-only feature support that will keep their business/edu customers from fleeing to AMD, and that's about it.
- mhurron 14y agoRandR is a Xorg extension, it's not a Linux kernel thing. To continue to provide graphics options for their customers that use OS's with recent Xorg installs (they make a FreeBSD driver available too) they had to support RandR. This is right in line with 'we support our customers/users' not whatever the Linux kernel guys feel like doing today.
- ajross 14y agoThat's spun and unfair. Booting with a working framebuffer isn't something that tickles only the "kernel guys" interest. Running the GPU on your hybrid laptop likewise. You realize that, with just a handful of exceptions, the NVIDIA part on most Optimus laptops simply doesn't work under linux, right? And that NVIDIA hasn't so much as lifted a finger to fix this? So sure, if "customers/users" includes the only handful of 3D content shops out there running linux toolchains, and not the millions of people buying NVIDIA-enabled laptops, I guess it makes sense. But for everyone else it kinda sucks.
- TylerE 14y ago> Booting with a working framebuffer isn't something that tickles only the "kernel guys" interest Is it? If my computer boots up directly to X anyway, why do I care about a framebuffer beyond the standard vesa stuff? PS: If Linus would get off his high horse about closed source drivers, and commit to have at least a somewhat stable ABI, that would do more for hardware support on linux than 1000 years of ranting and moaning, which if anything, will only alienate the hardware makers even more.
- muhfuhkuh 14y ago"If Linus would get off his high horse about closed source drivers" ... then he would be Microsoft and Apple, and not an Open Source operating system developer, maintainer, producer, and evangelist. All his years of working openly and freely will be squandered and his life's work beholden to closed-source, closed spec device manufacturers.
- TylerE 14y agoBut his stance actually makes us much MORE beholden to the 3rd parties. If every minor kernel version didn't require the vendors to recompiled drivers, and quite possible change code because Linus changed the ABI again, that would result in more hardware working better for more people. Live the open source dream if it makes you feel good. I live in a world where if it doesn't work, I couldn't care less about it. Pragmatism > Dogma
- SoftwareMaven 14y agoIt is relevant to the controversy if you are being called "the worst company to work with in the Linux community" by the chief Linux guy.
- ajross 14y agoOnly insofar as that quote lives out of context. Linus was quite clearly responding to a question about graphics drivers.
- marshray 14y agoQuite clearly he's talking about Nvidia as a company, not about the properties of one particular subsystem. The statement stands well enough on its own.
- freshhawk 14y agoBasically: "We only care about keeping a checkbox next to 'linux support' in our feature grid. We don't care about how shitty the experience is for linux users" It is refreshingly blunt, i'll give them that.
- keypusher 14y agoI'll take nVidia over ATI for a Linux box anyday, the driver difference is night and day.
- JoshTriplett 14y agoIf you mean the ATI proprietary drivers, I can believe that nVidia's suck slightly less. However, the majority of Radeon cards have full 2D/3D support in Open Source drivers (and those drivers actually have developers from ATI working on them), whereas the reverse-engineered nouveau driver supports a smaller subset of nVidia cards with much lower 3D support (and no support from nVidia whatsoever). So, I'd still take ATI over nVidia due to ATI's much better Open Source drivers with some development done by ATI, though I'd take Intel over ATI for having entirely Open Source drivers with much more direct development from Intel.
- cfn 14y agoI guess different people had different experiences. My nVidia cards have worked just fine on Linux but my HD7750 ATI card does not work properly (random screen flashes and poor rendering) on Ubuntu no matter which driver I try.
- JshWright 14y ago> the majority of Radeon cards have full 2D/3D support in Open Source drivers (and those drivers actually have developers from ATI working on them) And yet, the performance is still an order of magnitude worse than the proprietary driver (last time I bothered to compare them, anyway).
- Symmetry 14y ago
- runjake 14y ago> It's remarkably straight-talking for a press release It was? They didn't even address the huge issue that it was Linus, the guy who created Linux, exacting the criticism.