3 ms·
My understanding is that a higher standard of discourse is expected on HN than linking to an XKCD comic and expecting it to make a philosophical argument for yo
by zahlman 2y ago
My understanding is that a higher standard of discourse is expected on HN than linking to an XKCD comic and expecting it to make a philosophical argument for you.
Regardless, there are at least five problems with the assertion that this argument is "relevant":
1. The things Mr. Peters said bear at most a superficial resemblance to the CoC WG's characterization.
2. Several of the stated supposed offenses imply a standard for conduct that is not supported by the text of the Code of Conduct.
3. Several of the stated supposed offenses imply a standard for conduct that is grossly unreasonable, bearing no resemblance to what is actually required to maintain civil discourse.
4. Nobody in the discussion raised any prior argument regarding freedom of speech.
5. Regardless of that, Mr. Munroe is simply incorrect, and presents an ignorant, US-centric view. The concept of "freedom of speech" has nothing to do with the First Amendment to the US Constitution, and indeed nothing to do with any specific law of any specific country at any point in history. It is a philosophical principle, which the Founders saw fit to enshrine in that constitution due to belief in that philosophy. (This is the point I raise every time I see this comic, which generally adds nothing of value and is only used to snark.)