3 ms·
"Recent tech trends have followed a pattern of being huge society-disrupting systems that people don't actually want." "While planned obsolescence means this a
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 2y ago
"Recent tech trends have followed a pattern of being huge society-disrupting systems that people don't actually want."
"While planned obsolescence means this applies to consumer products in general, the recent major tech fad hypes - cryptocurrency, "the metaverse", artificial intelligence... - all seem to be comically expensive boondoggles that only really benefit the salesmen."
But acccording to sentence #1, some people do want these things, e.g., salespeople, investors, etc. But as sentence #2 implies, this is not a majority of people. Over the years, when people complain on HN about software and the web, other commenters, presumably software/web developers, respond that these complainers do not matter because they are only a minority: the majority of people do not complain. Failure to complain apparently means the silent majority "wants" what they get.
What rule can we derive from this developer "reasoning/argument". Sometimes it makes sense to cater to a minority, other times it doesn't?
"If you're not familiar, data centers are dedicated facilities for running servers. Data centers are "the cloud": instead of running your own servers, you can rent computer power from experts who are very good at keeping computers from turning off."
"The problem we immediately run into if we try to think about the proportional cost of AI is that there is no consensus on whether it's ultimately useful."
I think it is safe to say that only a minority of people are speculating that "AI" is useful. The majority are silent. Does that mean the majority want it.
We know what salespeople, investors and developers will say.
"As I mentioned earlier, the AI boom feels a lot like the blockchain cryptocurrency push of a few years ago. Like cryptocurrency, AI is a tech fad, it requires data centers, it consumes more energy than a webserver... the comparison is extremely natural."
If these things were truly useful, then it stands to reason the majority of people would be asking for them. Instead we see indifference. To developers, this indifference equates to "Yes, we want it".
A fundamental problem with paying atteniton to the speculation of developers and other pundits who advocate expensive, unnecessary uses of computers, e.g., "AI", besides the obvious conflict of interest, is that these folks do not have a good track record of being honest. To start MicroSoft in the 1970s Bill Gates had to lie that he had software that did not yet exist. This "vapourware" tactic might seem quaint but this culture of dishonesty now involves much higher stakes.
Developers are still faking demos. Putting Elizabeth Holmes in prison has not stopped the Silicon Valley culture of fraud.