>It wasn't intended as a refutation but a qualification I don't know what animates you in the conversation, but for me it is question of whether immigration of

>It wasn't intended as a refutation but a qualification I don't know what animates you in the conversation, but for me it is question of whether immigration of people with very different cultural backgrounds into a country has harmful effect that in the long term might cancel out the positive economic effects. You have not explained (and I have failed to guess) how your "was also a story of immigration" sheds any light on that question.