2 ms·
The author is mistaken in the details. 12 5ths are stacked in order to get back to the start note (7 octaves higher). They're called "5ths" because they're the
by zahlman 2y ago
The author is mistaken in the details. 12 5ths are stacked in order to get back to the start note (7 octaves higher). They're called "5ths" because they're the fifth scale degree, i.e. 4 diatonic scale (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diatonic_scale https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diatonic_scale) notes above the start point (because they start counting at 1), which is an interval of 3 tones and a semitone. With the notes "equally spaced" (according to the logarithm of frequency, because we perceive intervals according to pitch ratio), the semitone becomes equal to exactly half the tone (despite the name, that isn't guaranteed for other tuning systems!) - thus, the interval that we play on an "equal tempered" piano as a "perfect fifth" is 700 "cents" i.e. a frequency ratio of 2^(7/12).
Meanwhile, per music theory going all the way back to the ancient Greeks, this interval ought to be exactly 3/2, which is slightly larger. Contra what was written in the article, these intervals are thus tuned flat from that Pythagorean ideal. The difference is about 2 cents (where a cent is defined as a frequency ratio of 2^(1/1200), effectively). Most people wouldn't be able to hear the difference (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Just-noticeable_difference#Music_production_applications https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Just-noticeable_difference#Mus...).
Which is to say: yes, 129.746... might not seem that close to 128, but 1.498... is close enough to 1.5 that it lets us have music that sounds right (if sterile, according to some) in every key.
Other intervals possible in this tuning arrangement (i.e, powers of 2^(1/12)) can approximate other reasonably-consonant intervals with varying accuracy.