53 ms·
I thought that was debunked, that in "blind" tests experts nearly always selected modern, high end violins over the Stradivarius's (Stradivarii?).
by apercu 2y ago
I thought that was debunked, that in "blind" tests experts nearly always selected modern, high end violins over the Stradivarius's (Stradivarii?).
- thaumasiotes 2y agoThat won't stop people from telling the story. Wine is the same way.
- HappMacDonald 2y agoI disagree. In a blind test I can absolutely tell which application is running natively on Windows.
- thaumasiotes 2y agoWine, the beverage.
- RandomThoughts3 2y agoI think you missed the joke. But to get back on topic I’m not sure I get how wine is the same. Wine is a product with large taste variations between the different regions and vine varieties. Plus depending of the year you will again have variations in the grapes which can be more or less balanced during the fabrication. Some producers are known to have produced particularly great wine some specific years which lead to say bottles being very expensive but most of it is very much fact based. The only dubious thing I see in wine is that the way aging changes the taste of a bottle is not an improvement indefinitely. At some point the wine just gets worst and the search for very old bottle is mostly posturing.
- detourdog 2y agoThat is sort of what I meant. The idea that ancient violins hold an unattainable mystique. That is now just an investment vehicle. I violated HN guidelines by being too flippant in my answer.
- bluGill 2y agoWhich Stradivarius? He made many, some better than others. Also, which modern violin - there are many makers who make theirs sound different, and of course each violin from the same maker will have their own sound.
- detourdog 2y agoThat is really the point. The fact of who made the violin is much easier to conceptualize and communicate than any of it’s acoustic properties.
- analog31 2y agoYes, and that's common knowledge among most musicians nowadays. Sure, it's hard to be a musician -- amateur or professional -- and not also be an enthusiast. And I don't think very many violinists would turn down a chance to try a Strad, or at least hold it and look at it. There's still an open question about whether the new fiddles are better, or that the old ones are deteriorating, or both. Disclosure: Working double bassist. And don't get me started about bows. ;-)
- gizajob 2y agoFrench bows or German bows? Just so we know what not to get you started on.
- analog31 2y agoI play French. I played cello as a kid, and when I started bass lessons in college, my teacher played German but told me there was no reason for me to switch. Most teachers have a preference but can teach either one. I've seen great bassists play both. There's a slight preference towards German for adult beginners because the learning curve isn't as steep.