4 ms·
Well, that wasn't what I expected from a post on asmartbear. Trite quibbling over minor semantic distinctions? For an early stage startup, spending even two s
by mindcrime 14y ago
Well, that wasn't what I expected from a post on asmartbear. Trite quibbling over minor semantic distinctions? For an early stage startup, spending even two seconds worrying about the exact definition of "profitable" and whether or not your definition is suitable to someone else, is two seconds one could have spent writing code or doing something productive.
Pretty much a useless article, as far as I can tell.
- hythloday 14y agoI don't think the word "profitable" is the interesting part of the article--rather it's looking for inflection points in the time/utility function of your startup. It's making the point that the interesting point is not when the final figure in some parboiled accounting books is positive, but when you have enough confidence in it to use it as your primary source of income. I'd urge you to re-read it and not fall into the trap of believing he's making an argument on semantics. There's a useful point there.
- mindcrime 14y agoFair enough, maybe it's just that the headline is misleading. No doubt, that inflection point does matter... But I wish he'd been clearer in saying that that's what he's talking about. But even if we acknowledge that that inflection point is important, what conclusion is he asking us to draw from it? Does acknowledging or not acknowledging this point make much difference to any strategic or tactical decision a hypothetical startup founder is going to make? I mean, if the OP had made a point about "this is how you know when to go raise outside money" or "this is how you know it's time to shut down the "profitable" startup," then I'd have found this valuable.
- damoncali 14y agoI think you missed the good stuff. It's a great post about what positive traction looks like wrapped up in a pointless, link-baity, semantic argument.
- tptacek 14y agoWow do I ever think you (and even 'damoncali below) are wrong about this. This is the opposite of a "useless post". This is a post about how lying to yourself about the definition of "profitable" can cost you tens of thousands of dollars. The idea Cohen is expressing is so extraordinarily simple it would almost be banal, if it didn't target such a widely held misconception: You cannot factor out opportunity costs when accounting for your business. When a new founder with a business throwing off $1500/mo after line-item costs like hosting claims to be "profitable", what they are effectively saying is that their own time is worth $0/mo. In reality, that founder is almost definitely losing at least $11,000 per month --- by taking a SWAG at what any person capable of booting up a product to reliable $1500/mo can earn as an employee or freelance consultant, that SWAG being almost certainly so lowballed as to be insulting. To my mind, not being able to tell the difference between "profitable to the tune of $1500/mo" and "losing 5 figures a month" is an alarming difference that is very much worth calling out.
- scyscy 14y agoBoth of you are WASTING YOUR TIME. Now keep worshiping "ycombinator" like they are God--meanwhile, someone stops this comment from showing. I don't care. Internet commenting is a waste of time. Hug your children or something, JEEEZ.
- mindcrime 14y agoWow do I ever think you (and even 'damoncali below) are wrong about this. This is the opposite of a "useless post". This is a post about how lying to yourself about the definition of "profitable" can cost you tens of thousands of dollars. Is it really? I mean, that makes sense if the only point of being an entrepreneur is to make money, and you're totally fine with working a $DAYJOB as an employee. But, for some of us, it's about more than the money, and fighting to make the startup succeed is totally "worth it" even if "it" is tens, or hundreds of thousands of dollars that we might otherwise have earned as an employee. You cannot factor out opportunity costs when accounting for your business. Indeed.
- tptacek 14y agoIf you're happy, you're happy. That's great. But if your company is bringing in $1500/mo after line-item expenses and before wages, you are making less than minimum wage; you are not profitable. Happy? Sure. Profitable? No.