5 ms·
> Nuclear plants are not carbon free. Getting the uranium, transporting the nuclear waste, transporting the people who run the plant costs a lot of carbon emiss
by ars 14y ago
> Nuclear plants are not carbon free. Getting the uranium, transporting the nuclear waste, transporting the people who run the plant costs a lot of carbon emissions.
But shutting them down when you already paid all the costs is clearly stupid.
And he didn't say carbon free. He said "increase carbon emissions" (he probably meant carbon dioxide emissions), and it clearly will increase them.
- maigret 14y agoShutting down was driven by fear, not by cost.
- onli 14y agoHe said carbon free. I cited that sentence. Also a working nuclear "you already paid for"-plant costs money and produces carbon emissions.
- ars 14y agoOnce you build the plant, any emissions from running it are absolutely minuscule. Gasoline maybe from the employees driving to work, maybe a bit from maintenance.
- onli 14y agoDrilling for the uranium is a whole chunk, according to http://www.nature.com/climate/2008/0810/full/climate.2008.99.html http://www.nature.com/climate/2008/0810/full/climate.2008.99.... But sure, less than coal (but still, more than wind). edit: added link.
- ars 14y agoNo wind uses more. You need to mine for the raw materials used to build the wind turbine. For the equivalent amount of energy wind turbines use hundreds of times as much raw materials as nuclear - even including building the nuclear power plant, not just the uranium.
- onli 14y agoDo you have a citation for that? The only source for that I found is http://www.world-nuclear.org/education/comparativeco2.html http://www.world-nuclear.org/education/comparativeco2.html, which is most probably biased. Most other sources seem to rank wind better - but not sun (maybe you are mixing those two up?).
- ars 14y agohttp://www.vattenfall.co.uk/en/kentish-flats.htm http://www.vattenfall.co.uk/en/kentish-flats.htm 500 tons of materials for 1MW (actual) wind turbine. That would imply a 1GW reactor should be less than 500,000 metric tons in order to use less materials, and while I can't find figures for the weight of a nuclear reactor, they certainly are not that large! A proposed thorium reactor: http://www.thorium.tv/en/thorium_reactor/thorium_reactor_1.php http://www.thorium.tv/en/thorium_reactor/thorium_reactor_1.p... 500 tons, for 100MW - meaning 100 times as much material is used for a wind turbine compared to thorium. Uranium uses larger buildings, but still much less than wind.
- sophacles 14y agoThis is an overly simplistic argument: 1) are the raw materials the same raw materials? (Iron is easier to get than tungsten for instance). Are the materials used in either type of generation actually hard to find or in danger of becoming scarce? 2) How much extra energy is spent on processing the raw materials to the finished product? The vast majority of weight in a turbine is the tower, which is relatively simple to build compared to the thousands of miles of piping welded together in a nuke plant. Even if weight of resources/watt of generation was a good measure, you are not factoring the weight of a) fuel to create energy consumed in manufacture, and b) weight of wasted resources in the refining and manufacture processes. 3) How reusable is the material base? How much of a nuke plant can be used to create the next plant? Presumably a wind down can have it's turbine or airfoils replaced independently of the tower structure itself, reducing tco. (and total resource consumption). 4) Your analysis is not including weight of energy production fuel put in, nor the weight of all resources needed for dealing with post energy production waste (not insignificant in nuclear waste storage).