4 ms·
Would be nice to mention the whole effort, not only Turing. Like the fact that Poles were reading Enigma encrypted messages before the WW2, and send all informa
by ajuc 14y ago
Would be nice to mention the whole effort, not only Turing. Like the fact that Poles were reading Enigma encrypted messages before the WW2, and send all information they aquired to France and Great Brittain.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cryptanalysis_of_the_Enigma#Polish_breakthrough http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cryptanalysis_of_the_Enigma#Pol...
I mean - Turing was brilliant, but why everybody only tell the story from the middle ?
- m0nty 14y agoI have always felt that Tommy Flowers' incredible contribution (i.e. building the first electronic, programmable computer) is all-too-frequently overlooked. I suppose it just makes a better story to talk about a lone genius rather than a group of collaborators.
- monk_the_dog 14y agoI recently learned about Tommy Flowers and Colossus from this book: http://www.amazon.com/Colossus-secrets-Bletchley-code-breaking-computers/dp/0199578141/ref=sr_1_5 http://www.amazon.com/Colossus-secrets-Bletchley-code-breaki... The British kept Colossus secret for a too long and Flowers did not get enough credit (and von Neumann seems to get too much). BTW, I do recommend the above book. But we warned that it's a collection of essays by different authors so it can be uneven reading.
- m0nty 14y agoThanks, I'll take a look at the book. Sometimes essays are fine because you can cherry-pick the good ones.
- nicholassmith 14y agoWell it does say he was a 'key player', not the only person involved. Plus as it's a retrospective on Turing's contributions I think they're allowed to focus on a sole character. (But several other excellent Turing stories have mentioned the other players involved, Ars had an excellent article about it if I remember rightly).
- adventureful 14y agoIt does note this: "Turing helped adapt a device originally developed by Poland to create the bombe" - under the device caption And as someone else said, this is about celebrating Turing's 100th birthday.
- wildmXranat 14y agoIndeed, and without taking away anything form Turing, it was Rejewski, Różycki and Zygalski code-breakers working at the request of the Polish army that broke the Enigma codes. I believe they summoned numerous cryptologists, three of which were these guys.
- madaxe 14y agoIt'd also be nice if they mentioned that the government orchestrated his death by castrating him for the sinful, heinous crime of... being gay.
- pwaring 14y agoIt would also be good to extend the mentions beyond just codebreakers, including the Royal Navy personnel who boarded damaged U-boats in order to retrieve code books and other equipment, not knowing if the vessel would sink at any minute.
- jt2190 14y agoI once went to a birthday party. When the cake came out and everyone was singing "happy birthday", I said, in a loud, authoritative voice: "You know who really deserves a party is..." Needless to say I wasn't invited the following year. ;-) [The above story is totally fictitious, in order to make a point.]
- rmc 14y agoI mean - Turing was brilliant, but why everybody only tell the story from the middle ? Turing was English. (also the allies of the UK & USA were occupying Poland.)
- excuse-me 14y agoAlso Bill Tutte made a much greater mathematical contribution to cryptography and broke the rather more complex Tunny code - between the guy with the bad moustache and his generals.
- sixothree 14y agoCode Breakers of Blechley Park is a pretty nice one hour BBC documentary on the subject. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JF48sl15OCg http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JF48sl15OCg