4 ms·
Understand that Kim Jong Un doesn't want to be Putin when he grows up. Instead, it is Putin who envies Kim. He wants to live a life of lucre and luxury while
by CamperBob2 2y ago
Understand that Kim Jong Un doesn't want to be Putin when he grows up. Instead, it is Putin who envies Kim. He wants to live a life of lucre and luxury while the rest of the world is more-or-less forced to prop up his failed state for humanitarian and political reasons.
As stupid as this sounds, no other explanation for Putin's behavior makes any more sense. Come up with a better one? I'm all ears... but there's a lot you'll need to explain.
- layer8 2y agoPutin wants Russia to be great again (the image of Russia he grew up with), and to undo the historic “injustice” of the fall of the USSR and Lenin’s “mistake” of ceding territory to Ukraine.
- CamperBob2 2y agoPeople want a lot of things they can't have. Putin knows what's possible and what isn't, and that isn't.
- layer8 2y agoI’m not sure that Putin knows what is and isn’t possible.
- rsynnott 2y agoThat’s the public line, of course, but likely not his actual reasoning. Putin wants to stay in charge, because once he’s not in charge, his life expectancy is measured in hours.
- layer8 2y agoHe didn’t have to attack the Crimea and Ukraine to stay in charge. And his rhetorics regarding Russia go back more than twenty years.
- aguaviva 2y agoI think the parent's (@layer8's) snippet provides a pretty accurate and succinct statement of Putin's true (internal) position, actually (most of it anyway -- there was also his hope that the SMO would help keep Ukraine and Belarus out of Western influence, and forever grateful for the Motherland's tender affections and embraces; and likely strengthen Russia's long-term position in the oil and gas markets, as a sweet little bonus on top). Even more basically, it was all about enhanced "stature" vis-a-vis the West, which he presumed Russia would naturally and rightly win as a result of the brilliant technical operation he had planned. As opposed to the external narratives -- about NATO expansion, denazification, and the supposed need to "protect" the Russian-speaking population, and all that garbage (that unfortunately a certain contingent on HN seems all too eager and happy to believe, pretty much exactly at face value). At the start of the invasion, anyway. By now things have changed dramatically of course, and his true position is probably a lot closer to your description.
- hollerith 2y ago>Once he’s not in charge, his life expectancy is measured in hours. No it is not. Every Soviet or Russian leader since 1917 died peacefully in his bed, and a handful of those (Gorby and Yeltsin certainly) lost power well before they died.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- aguaviva 2y agoEvery Soviet or Russian leader since 1917 died peacefully in his bed, Beria was executed. Stalin did apparently expire in his own bed a few days after collapsing on his floor. But given that he was suspiciously denied treatment for 18+ hours, the circumstances cannot quite be called "peaceful". Khrushschev died of a heart attack at Moscow Central Clinic Hospital. Andropov and Chernenko spent their last months mostly at that same hospital. Andropov "dropped off" there, and Chernenko likely did as well. Yeltsin spent his last 12 days at an unspecified hospital. And yet somehow you "know" that they all died peacefully and in their own beds. Putin's own circumstances will likely be significantly more precarious than the post-Stalin/Beria batch. The reason the latter were able to enjoy relatively peaceful exits (if not in their own bed at home) rests in the fact that the Soviet system at least had a working semblance of respect for the law; and everyone knew that the transition process was firmly in the hands of the Politburo and the KGB. The country's position in the world at large was quite stable, and it faced no external threats. Meanwhile under Putin, rule of law as such been entirely hollowed out; his supporting factions are more diverse suspicious of one another; and thanks to his actions, the country now faces significant external threats, which he doesn't seem to be doing a good or even adequate of managing. Pretty much anything could happen in his last days, under these circumstances.
- hollerith 2y ago"In a bed", then. I.e., his life was not shortened deliberately by other people. And Beria was never leader of Russia or the Soviet Union: he was head of the spy service, a position held since 2008 by Alexander Bortnikov. You've heard about Beria, but probably haven't heard about Bortnikov because Bortnikov has been much much less violent and hasn't made a habit of raping Russian women in plain view on the streets of Moscow like Beria did. And I disagree with your assertion that the Putin regime is more autocratic than the other Russian / Soviet regimes since the death of Stalin. Opposition leader Navalny for example held that Crimea should be part of Russia; ditto Yeltsin. (And Russia's holdings in Donetsk, Zaphorizia and Kherson oblasts can be seen as necessary to make it viable to hold Crimea over the long term: the so-called land bridge.) If Putin dies suddenly, Russian politics probably goes on mostly the way it has been going: i.e., very slowly becoming more liberal and more committed to the rule of law, with some setbacks. (I do not deny that Yeltsin was more liberal than Putin.) Arguably the US's finest diplomat was George Kennan, who predicted before Putin became leader of Russia that NATO's policy of expanding eastward would eventually cause Moscow to react with military force, which Kennan correctly predicted would be misinterpreted by the West as a re-awakening of Russian imperialist ambitions. Kissenger was also against NATO expansion as were many other Western diplomats and international-relations experts.
- hakfoo 2y agoThe explanation might be simpler. He still needs to play, in some way, to a domestic audience. The fall of the USSR was objectively bad for a large part of the Russian population. Their economy and quality-of-life metrics have never really returned to pre-1991 levels. Their geopolitical relevance has been degraded, and Western institutions have nibbled away at their sphere of influence. They've lost millions of square kilometres of territorial holdings that date to Imperial times. He needs to perform some action to prove he's delivering something, and a stilted "you bait us long enough and we'll bite back" response might well fit, especially if they're already on a "the West is encroaching on our motherland" narrative. I still believe that if the Ukraine had made some token concession-- for example, offering a binding secession referrendum in the Donbass, that would have given Putin the bacon he needed to bring home without an actual war.
- CamperBob2 2y agoI still believe that if the Ukraine had made some token concession-- for example, offering a binding secession referrendum in the Donbass, that would have given Putin the bacon he needed to bring home without an actual war. The de-facto capture of Crimea wasn't enough, but the Donbass would've been. Got it.
- klibertp 2y agoDon't compare Crimea and Donbas. There's literally nothing in common there, save for Putin being the one to decide.
- rsynnott 2y agoI think you’re possibly overthinking it. Being a dictator doesn’t normally come with a particularly enviable pension plan; once you fall out of the saddle, at best you’re going into exile, but often they just kill you. So Putin needs to stay in the saddle, forever. And thus, this sort of thing.
- CamperBob2 2y agoNo, that's exactly what I said. His goal is to stay in the saddle for the rest of his natural life, propped up by Western charity and Chinese interests just like the Kim dynasty has been. That's the whole idea. For someone in Putin's position, a projection of genuine strength is actually less sustainable. As a nuclear-armed loser, he's a threat to global stability. Since he evidently can't be removed or ignored, he must be indulged, which is why he has gone out of his way to project weakness at every level since the start of the invasion. Losing the Black Sea fleet to a country with no navy, complaining about NATO encroachment while taking actions guaranteed to increase it, making a big show out of (temporarily) forgiving a usurper, releasing weird-as-hell photos in which he cowers at the end of a table the size of a bowling lane, along with videos in which he's quivering with a nervous tic that mysteriously doesn't seem to be getting worse... the examples are as numerous as they are nonsensical, and as irrational as they are irrefutable. Either I'm terrible at making my point, or many people vehemently disagree while being unable to offer a better explanation.