5 ms·
This is the closet thing to a wonder drug for the 21st century. You can see the transformation ...people who used to be obese seeing the fat melt off, when noth
by paulpauper 2y ago
This is the closet thing to a wonder drug for the 21st century. You can see the transformation ...people who used to be obese seeing the fat melt off, when nothing else seemed to work.
- tyrefd 2y agoThe wonder here is effective brain manipulation rather than fat melting. These drugs are chemically induced intermittent fasting. I’m okay with people saying “these drugs force people into healthy eating habits” but the weight loss itself is merely a symptom of the healthy eating habits that would be healthier on the body when done with discipline rather than chemically altering your digestion.
- raincom 2y agoHumans are biochemical machines. Hormones (chemicals) regulate many systems in humans. So, you want people to eat less and work out more, when hormones, or biochemical subsystems, are messed up?
- tyrefd 2y agoI wholly respect the difficulty, and I respect this may be some people’s best or only solution to what ails them. I have, and do, suffer from lack of discipline in facets of my own life. I just want to be honest about these drugs.
- djur 2y agoAnecdotally, the people I know who have been taking GLP-1 agonists have not been following eating patterns consistent with "intermittent fasting". They're just eating less (especially snacking).
- tyrefd 2y agoIF is a catchall for eating less rather than any specific the strict scheduling that influencers peddle.
- teqsun 2y agoI see it as a replacement for invasive surgical methods like lap-band surgery.
- ctoth 2y ago> when done with discipline I suppose that the drug also cures people with Parkinson's [0] through ... Discipline, right? 0: GLP-1 Receptor Agonists: A New Treatment in Parkinson’s Disease https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC11011817/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC11011817/
- tyrefd 2y ago“Disciple” is just a word I chose, rather than a judgment or criticism. Is there a better word that I can use in the future to ensure that my message is one of support free from misinformation? I feel your link and the other studies showing it helps people with various other addictions is evidence against the drug being a “fat melter”.
- Modified3019 2y agoWhen it comes to words like discipline or willpower, they are typically a signal that the poster is about to: 1. Ignore the continual and catastrophic failure of the idea that we can will ourselves out of an increasing crisis 2. Pat themselves on the back for their smug victim blaming Hence the negative reaction. I don’t have an alternative word for you to use. Humans at a population level have severe limits on what they can deal with. This is why tech companies use dark patterns, because exploiting and abusing people until they can’t put up resistance works fantastically. Suggesting that the real solution to mass exploitation is just to have the discipline to not be exploited would and should receive a negative reaction. Ultimately, the solution to obesity is to make the fix as easy to obtain as the primary causes of the problem. Can’t wait for a gambling and (working) smoking vaccine.
- petesergeant 2y ago> The wonder here is effective brain manipulation rather than fat melting. Yes > These drugs are chemically induced intermittent fasting. No, they're a type of calorie restriction, as is intermittent fasting.
- tyrefd 2y agoOkay, we agree. This just seems painfully pedantic. > Intermittent fasting is any of various meal timing schedules that cycle between voluntary fasting (or reduced calorie intake) and non-fasting over a given period.[1][2] Methods of intermittent fasting include alternate-day fasting,[3] periodic fasting, such as the 5:2 diet, and daily time-restricted eating.[1][4] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intermittent_fasting https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intermittent_fasting
- djur 2y agoIntermittent fasting is different than calorie restriction. There are calorie-restricted diets where you eat small amounts constantly throughout the day (this used to be the go-to recommendation of doctors). Intermittent fasting doesn't even necessarily entail calorie restriction.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- leovander 2y agoHopefully they reduce the cost overall. As soon as people are taken off it, whether that be because they finished their trial or they get out priced, appetite shoots right back to what it was before and the weight comes back with it unless the person changed their habits.
- ryandrake 2y agoThis seems to be a great outcome if you're the drugmaker. You don't want your medicine to cure the patient, otherwise they'll stop buying it. I bet if they found an alternate drug that worked permanently after N doses, they'd bury it and never productize it.
- ahahahahah 2y agoYep! That's exactly why vaccines don't exist.
- steveBK123 2y agoLove a good conspiracy & not a biologist / chemist, but I don't thing such a drug is even possible in our current state of technology. Treatments that are "one (or N) & done" tend to be surgical procedures which physical change your body or vaccines which train your immune system (which has a sort of viral memory bank). Most other regular drug treatments are introducing chemicals into the body which your body consumes/breaks down/etc. The body is always self repairing, replacing cells, etc. As a layperson, I conceptualize altering brain chemistry via a drug is a temporary thing the way adjusting your pools chemistry is. You have to constantly replenish with new chemicals as everything is constantly breaking down and changing.
- djur 2y agoAs far as I know the pharmaceutical companies have not adopted a strategy of attempting to undermine or block surgical treatments, which you'd expect if their operating strategy was as you say.
- flakiness 2y agoLong term the patent expires and it becomes a generic. That's I think when the real transformation starts.
- standardUser 2y agoGabapentin may be a wonder drug, helping with heretofore barely-treatable conditions and the ravages of addiction. Weight lose drugs are just a shortcut for something that is possibly for the vast majority of people without any drugs. Don't get me wrong, they seem great! But a drug that can help with seizures, nerve pain, alcoholism and anxiety sounds a little more "wondery" to me.
- meany 2y agoI don’t think the data supports that it is possible for the majority of people. On traditional diets, Between 80 and 85 percent of those who lose a large amount of weight regain it. Source: https://stanfordhealthcare.org/medical-conditions/healthy-living/obesity/weight-loss-maintenance.html#:~:text=Losing%20weight%20is%20hard%20enough,amount%20of%20weight%20regain%20it https://stanfordhealthcare.org/medical-conditions/healthy-li....
- semaglp1 2y agoWell, it's possible for the majority of people, it's just that the majority of people can't keep up with the things that make it possible. It's a ton of work (and money!) to keep up with a good diet, walk thousands of steps per day, and exercise 4-5x per week. Between needing to drive to do everything and making food as addictive as possible, we've designed everything about contemporary life to work against being healthy.
- meany 2y agoNot sure how I understand how it’s possible for the majority of people if they can’t keep up with the things that make it possible.
- semaglp1 2y agoI just mean it's physically possible, it's not like we as humans are physically unable to and require a drug to do it for us. But most people aren't willing to grind through the beginning phase that is physically and emotionally difficult to get to the part where training becomes beautiful. I've had moments on psychedelics where I've just cried from gratitude that I found my practices and disciplined myself to root out the deep fears and insecurities that held me back. I didn't want to live with them anymore and wanted to see what this body is capable of in this lifetime. It's ridiculous what out bodies are capable of. It's like getting handed a lambo and instead we keep it parked in our garage all the time. But those first 6 months were extremely difficult, literally bloody from injuries, and required a commitment that every week I'd go train 5 times, no excuses. I think pretty much anyone can find 5-6 hours in a week to go train something, it's really not much time at all.
- toephu2 2y agoBut what are the long-term side effects? You don't get something for nothing. There is no such thing as a magic pill that makes you magically lose weight without any consequences.
- davikr 2y agoWhy couldn't there be? There are magic pills that lower your blood pressure without any consequence.
- GavinMcG 2y ago> You don’t get something for nothing If that were true about the human condition in the same way that it’s true for conservation of mass, we wouldn't be living longer and healthier lives than our forebears. Yet here we are. Of course we should be aware of side-effects. But there’s no law of nature that says there have to be any serious ones.
- lr4444lr 2y agowe wouldn't be living longer and healthier lives than our forebears Take out infectious disease, post-partum maternal deaths, no sanitation, and obvious lifestyle choices like smoking, and are we really living healthier lives than prior generations? I'm not so convinced.
- semaglp1 2y agoNot sure why you're getting down-voted, it's a common meme for people to think everyone just died by their 40s. It seems like if you made it to 40 you often could be living into your 70s [1] throughout much of human history. Now I'll take our modern scientific advances over not having them. Give me modern sanitation, surgery, antibiotics, and vaccines for sure. But I'm not sure I'd call the way many American elders around me are living in their 70s to be healthy lives. Many lack mobility, are obese, are on a fistful of prescription drugs daily, and have constant pain. Except for the ones that ate well and in moderation, didn't drink much, and exercised their entire lives. I just hope people take these GPL-1 drugs but also get their bodies moving (particularly strength training). [1] https://www.sapiens.org/biology/human-lifespan-history/ https://www.sapiens.org/biology/human-lifespan-history/