3 ms·
That seems weirdly restricted and circular. To illustrate: I can get drunk or fall asleep or get hit on the head, then I'm still a person, but I can't understa
by eru 2y ago
That seems weirdly restricted and circular.
To illustrate: I can get drunk or fall asleep or get hit on the head, then I'm still a person, but I can't understand. You can get a hint of that, by trying to talk to me, and figuring out that I don't make much sense.
Similarly, someone might figure out how to talk to dolphins or even aliens. If they give sufficiently sensible sensible replies, we will surely declare them to be sentient enough to 'understand'.
Another example: we've exchanged a few messages here. You seem to be smart enough to understand some things, but I don't know whether you are just an exceptionally advanced LLM (and the same goes vice versa for your opinion of me). Yet, I make the judgement that you probably 'understand'. But that's purely based on observed interactions, I did not probe whether you are 'people'.
Perhaps you (or me) are just simulating the effect of understanding? How would we be sure, if the simulation was good enough?
We agree that contemporary LLMs ain't good enough to have a good 'simulation of understanding'. But once the simulation becomes good enough, I don't think it makes a difference whether it's 'just a simulation' or the real deal.
(I don't know whether a straight-forward enlargement of contemporary LLMs will be good enough. But that's an empirical question to me, not a philosophical one.
I suspect if you go insanely large with insane amounts of training, the architecture of contemporary LLMs might be enough; just from pure brute-force scale. But I also suspect that that in practice we will first find success with more economic use of resources via more interesting techniques.)