3 ms·
You’ve got it backward. It’s not surprising that a court found the FTC lacked the power to categorically ban contractual arrangements under state contract law.
by rayiner 2y ago
You’ve got it backward. It’s not surprising that a court found the FTC lacked the power to categorically ban contractual arrangements under state contract law. The relevant principles are ones most people learn in high school government class:
federalism (employment contracts are a matter of state rather than federal law) and separation of powers (executive branch agencies enforce the law, they don’t make it).
What would require a special explanation is if the court found the opposite. It’s really appalling how many supposedly educated lawyers would arrive at the wrong answer to something a bright 10th grader could figure out from first principles.
- amanaplanacanal 2y agoNot sure I understand your argument. Are you suggesting the federal government can’t, for instance, set a minimum wage?
- rayiner 2y agoThe Supreme Court case upholding the constitutionality of the federal minimum wage as being a proper exercise of Commerce Clause power, United States v. Darby, rests on very weak reasoning: https://www.oyez.org/cases/1940-1955/312us100 https://www.oyez.org/cases/1940-1955/312us100 (“The Court held that the purpose of the FLSA was to prevent states from using substandard labor practices to their own economic advantage by interstate commerce. Congress acted with proper authority in outlawing substandard labor conditions since they have a significant impact on interstate commerce.”). Similar to Wickard v. Filburn, it gives Congress power over purely intrastate activity based on a tenuous connection to interstate commerce. But there’s probably some version of both the minimum wage and the ban on non-compete agreements that’s constitutional under the Commerce Clause. For example, if they were limited to employers that do business in multiple states or if they purported to apply when employees moved to a different state where non-competes were unenforceable. The bigger problem is the separation of powers aspect. As you seem to recognize, banning non-competes seems like banning an unfair labor practice. That something that should be the subject of Congressional legislation, like the FLSA. Congress almost certainly didn’t intend to delegate to the FTC power over employment contracts, nor could it have given the FTC such an open-ended delegation of legislative authority.
- kelnos 2y ago> federalism (employment contracts are a matter of state rather than federal law) While the US's particular brand of federalism might imply that (or might not), that specific bit need not be a feature of federalism in general. > separation of powers (executive branch agencies enforce the law, they don’t make it) Decades of legislative delegation and executive rulemaking would seem to disagree with that, no? I'm not making a value judgment on whether or not this is a good thing, just stating the facts on the ground. (SCOTUS seems to want to dismantle all that, though.) > It’s really appalling how many supposedly educated lawyers would arrive at the wrong answer to something a bright 10th grader could figure out from first principles. Or maybe reasonable people well-versed in the law can disagree in their interpretations? Not sure if you're a lawyer yourself (I'm not), but it seems to me that disagreements on legal interpretation aren't particularly uncommon, especially when it comes to disputes around separation of powers and state vs. federal powers.