5 ms·
> It calls attention to the fact that Youtube isn't just serving me videos neutrally, it knows what is being said in those videos at the exact moment it is said
by gruez 2y ago
> It calls attention to the fact that Youtube isn't just serving me videos neutrally, it knows what is being said in those videos at the exact moment it is said. It highlights how much Google analyses the content of its videos in a way that more neutral features like automatic transcripts don't and in turn how much that can teach Google about me based on the videos I watch.
How else do you think the "up next" and "recommended videos for you" feature works? Did you think they were serving up relevant videos purely out of chance? If anything a dumb rule like "highlight the subscribe button if the transcript mentions it" is much more benign then a recommendation engine that can somehow always serve you a relevant video.
- queuebert 2y agoThe simplest recommender would use videos that were commonly watched afterwards by other people.
- Minor49er 2y agoThat would be fun to exploit. Just get a few hundred accounts, have them watch a Mr. Beast video followed by a video you want to boost, and watch the numbers grow
- xboxnolifes 2y agoNot sure even a few thousand accounts would make a dent in a Mr beast video count. Recommendation would go toward the 1 million accounts who watch another Mr beast video after.
- Minor49er 2y agoTrue, though the recommendation engine on YouTube will suggest other alternatives that are not on the same channel. There would still be a positive effect
- cheeseomlit 2y agoYou don't necessarily need to analyze every word in every video for recommendations- it could be as simple as 'users who liked this video also liked these other videos'
- conductr 2y agoYou can also turn on subtitles and even have them translated, it's pretty obvious Google is doing a lot with the audio part of videos
- everforward 2y agoUp Next and recommended videos don't require understanding the content of the videos. They could, as an example, find other users that watch similar videos and pick a video you haven't seen out of the things the other users have watched. It wouldn't surprise me if they use transcripts, but neither feature strictly requires it. I think the real risk here is users extrapolating from "YouTube can automatically respond to the content of videos". The Mr Beast thing is still blowing up, could they automatically identify illegal lotteries? Could they identify things that aren't suitable for YouTube Kids but end up there anyways? So on and so forth, YouTube's moderation is basically always under fire. This seems like a risky mixed message to send. Being able to light up the Subscribe button doesn't imply the technical ability to do better moderation, but I also wouldn't want to be the guy that has to explain that and how it works to the Senate.
- xattt 2y agoIt speaks to the fact that things that are most beneficial to Google have been finetuned to exploit eyeballs and pocketbooks. If they wanted to, or if their hand was forced, they’d be able to do the things that benefit the greater good. Don’t get started with the “it’s a slippery slope” kind of shit. Short of living in some society where it’s every man for himself, kids shouldn’t be playing lotteries
- chgs 2y agoMany people in tech are big proponents of the “every man for himself” randian distopyas
- everforward 2y agoThere are significant differences in difficulty, but I do agree with the sentiment. Grepping for “like button” in a transcript is much easier and cheaper than training an LLM to check whether a lottery is legal or not. It also helps that there’s no counterparty risk with the like button. I don’t think anyone is trying to “trick” that feature, and it wouldn’t matter if they did.
- mcphage 2y ago
- mathverse 2y agoIf u are from a small country and you travel a lot it absolutely throws google off. I never get any relevant ads or videos for me :(.
- conductr 2y agoI mostly use Youtube to watch home improvement / DIY / construction related stuff. They show me ads in Spanish. I'm probably the most stereotypical American white dude in Finance that speaks only English. What's weird is I've been using Google Search/Gmail basically since they became available and have bought their products and services for other stuff over the years and they have me pretty dialed in on their marketing elsewhere. YT specifically thinks otherwise.
- slg 2y ago>How else do you think the "up next" and "recommended videos for you" feature works? Did you think they were serving up relevant videos purely out of chance? It is absolutely possible to serve recommendations in a content agnostic way based on other user behavior. That is how the Youtube's recommendations worked at least initially. It should be obvious that they didn't have this ability to analyze content when Youtube started almost 20 years ago. And even in a content aware system, there is a difference between matching up keywords and understanding what those words mean. That is why an automatic transcript feels more neutral. That just transcribes what is being said. There is no implication of any analysis on the meaning of what is being said. >If anything a dumb rule like "highlight the subscribe button if the transcript mentions it" is much more benign then a recommendation engine that can somehow always serve you a relevant video. I'm not saying this feature is scarier than the recommendation engine. I'm saying Google revealing how much they know about the content of the video makes everything they do, including their recommendation engine, a little scarier.
- 8note 2y agoaround 20 years ago mark all kinds of things would happen at different times of a video, with the tool tips, and end cards and what have you. CSS animations werent there I guess, but given a manual transcription, either by the submitter, or by a person watching, youtube definitely had the capability to do exactly this, maybe with the button being some flash animation.
- slg 2y ago>...but given a manual transcription... youtube definitely had the capability to do exactly this... I mean the "given a manual transcription" condition means the very much didn't have "the capability to do exactly this". The animation itself isn't the interesting part here.
- fragmede 2y agoGoogle owned YouTube'a ability to analyze content at scale for copyrighted music is the only reason YouTube is still around today. That the engine that does that analysis might be doing more seems like not a stretch at all. How much easier is it to detect "smash that subscribe button" that "the > 30 seconds of music is possibly a copyrighted song of all the known songs"?
- OJFord 2y agoI'm not saying I thought this was the case, but I can think of: 1) similarity to other users (people who watched this also watched) 2) similarity in words in title or description (or the generated transcript)