3 ms·
I'd go for an action log. It's almost the same thing, but notifications imply ephemeral pokes about some of the stuff that happened, mixed with engagement boost
by TeMPOraL 2y ago
I'd go for an action log. It's almost the same thing, but notifications imply ephemeral pokes about some of the stuff that happened, mixed with engagement boosting spam - there's a lot of unpredictability embedded in this concept, as the app is usually trying to guess what you may (or it thinks you should) find relevant.
An action/activity log is just a reverse-chonological log of things that happened. You could make one by recording every would-be toast and putting it on that list, complete with a timestamp, and any of the context-relevant action buttons (like "undo", or "view item", etc.). The list should be a fixed recording[0], without any way to dismiss some or all of the entries. Add some attention-grabbing indicator whenever something is added there, and you get all the benefits of toasts with none of the drawbacks: the log lets you report completion of optimistically-executed actions, provide place for context-relevant buttons, and also is accessible, can be browsed at uses' own time, improves discoverability and learning, and can be upgraded to also enable undo feature.
--
[0] - Well, appended from top, and possibly unwinded by undo. Users understand that. Can't be append-only, because mixing that with undo gives you the undo system from Emacs - very powerful but also nearly incomprehensible to most people.
- michaelmrose 2y agoThis sounds like something the browsers could standardize.
- xp84 2y agoI love this idea! And also I like how it implies dispensing with the wrong notion that I care about every so-called notification and thus that I have “unread” notifs.
- hnbad 2y agoI think the best UX for async actions with optimistic UI updates would be having an (attention-grabbing?) indicator when an action is added and then another when it completes as well as indicating the number of pending (i.e. unconfirmed) actions and a persistent indicator if any of the actions failed.