3 ms·
The DA Says He's Innocent. He Might Spend Life in Prison Anyway
- nashashmi 2y agoShaking baby syndrome, thought to be a result of child abuse and spanking, was once a common law enforcement tactic in Canada against an immigrant population that was believed to have harsh child rearing practices. This was a prejudice. Doctors were part of it. Police officers were part of it too.
- alphabettsy 2y agoIt feels like I read or see something like this nearly every month. Someone’s where even the prosecutor's office involved have come to a different conclusion, but still, there are these major roadblocks to justice. Is there any meaningful progress being made to reassess our preference for finality over justice?
- magicalhippo 2y agoHere in Norway they've created an independent commission[1] to handle these cases of grave injustice. Not perfect, they can't handle many cases at once and have perhaps been a bit too cautious (to be charitable), but certainly better than nothing. [1]: https://www.gjenopptakelse.no/en/ https://www.gjenopptakelse.no/en/
- gspencley 2y ago> Is there any meaningful progress being made to reassess our preference for finality over justice? I think the problem is that, despite a prisoner's constitutional right to habeus corpus, once you are convicted you no longer have the presumption of innocence. Add to the fact that the convicted was convicted by a jury of their peers. Therefore, to overturn the conviction, the courts not only have to recognized and acknowledge their own error, they need to overturn the jury's decision. And the system places such a high value on jury decisions that it doesn't treat overturning them lightly. This means that there is a huge uphill battle to climb. The presumption is that you are guilty, because you were convicted beyond a shadow of a reasonable doubt. You are no longer in a position of defending against a prosecutor's case where they need to prove you guilty and you have no burden of proof what-so-ever. You are now in a position where you need to prove your innocence. I'm not sure what the process is like when there is exculpatory evidence. I would hope that as long as the evidence has the slightest hint of merit that the case can be reopened. In the case of the article, however, (which I will readily admit that I didn't study in its entirety since it was pretty TL;DR, so I skimmed and skipped parts) it doesn't sound like there is new exculpatory evidence, it sounds like the DA is unconvinced by the evidence and that if the trial were to occur today, that evidence would have been given much stricter scrutiny than it was at the time. It sounds like we need better ways to rexamine cases when standards of evidence change. To offer a made-up hypothetical, imagine that polygraph tests were admissible at one point and then it was deemed they are unreliable and are no longer admissible, could people who were convicted on polygraph evidence demand an appeal on that ground? I'm not a lawyer so I don't know, but I would hope so.
- Vecr 2y agoIt's really what pardons are for. It would "only" take a cultural change for DAs to feed up and combine together each year a "master list" of routine pardons that would be "rubber stamped" at both the federal and state levels, depending on the jurisdiction the person was convicted in.
- Buttons840 2y agoThe President is more likely to pardon himself than this poor dad.
- hn_acker 2y agoMost governors of US states can grant pardons or clemency for violations of state laws [1]. I don't know whether a pardon can provide a pathway to removal of a false charge of guilt. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pardon#State_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pardon#State_law
- Vecr 2y agoWell, it should let you go. The charges are permanent, the US does not have the Internet censorship needed to make them go away even if they wanted to.
- hn_acker 2y ago> The charges are permanent, the US does not have the Internet censorship needed to make them go away even if they wanted to. I should've clarified in my previous comment that I wasn't referring to public opinion and the news cycle when I wrote "a pathway to removal of a false charge of guilt". My worry is that every time an employer or a government official does a background check on someone who was pardoned for a later-determined-to-be-wrongful conviction yet remains formally marked as guilty, the background check will bring up a misleading record that will tangibly affect the pardoned person's employment opportunities or exercise of legal rights. atmavatar gave some examples (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41303300 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41303300).
- Eddy_Viscosity2 2y agoThe justice system only cares about process, not outcomes. This is a fundamental feature of bureaucracies (particularly large ones) and it doesn't matter if its government or a corporation or union or hospital. Bureaucracy is always about soul-destroying, humanity-ignoring process layered in such a way that the people running it are each somehow simultaneously overpowered over people trying to navigate the system while at the same time powerless to prevent foreseeable harms.
- culi 2y agoThe "justice" system was optimized for stuff like this. At least in the history of the US, police started as private task forces for elite to lock up striking workers and other protestors that might be a threat to their private property. In the South they started as groups to capture runaway slaves. After the Civil War the image of the Black person was transformed from effeminate and stupid to strong scary criminal. The South fought very hard to add "except as punishment for crime" to the 14th amendment which otherwise outlawed slavery. And their campaign to criminalize Black people began immediately as an attempt to recreate slavery. That's when jails really took off and that's the context under which much of our justice system developed. It was literally optimized to throw people in prison for made up charges. Nowadays (most of us) have different expectations from our justice system but we've yet to really update the processes
- Vecr 2y agoThat's not true, modern policing started in London and was brought over. Further developments in China were also brought to the US. Before that the US did have law enforcement, but it generally was not as large scale with the hundreds or thousands of officers used now. The larger scale slave catching gangs were a dead end and didn't lead into modern law enforcement, but various dubious "projects" attempt to conflate that. For example, SWAT teams were invented in China under the advisory of British police, not in the US south.
- culi 2y agoThis is a much written about topic https://www.americanbar.org/groups/crsj/publications/human_rights_magazine_home/civil-rights-reimagining-policing/how-you-start-is-how-you-finish/ https://www.americanbar.org/groups/crsj/publications/human_r... https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2020/07/20/the-invention-of-the-police https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2020/07/20/the-invention-...
- bananapub 2y agothe US cultural acceptance of "lots of poor and/or not-well-connected people will just go to jail and in some cases be murdered by the state" is one of the weirdest things about the place, especially in opposition to the usual nonsense about freedom and liberty.
- Buttons840 2y agoThis is what corruption looks like, power for the wrong reasons. Jails will make a profit, and charge inmates for the burden of making a phone call (during a time where literally every adult carries a device that can make infinite calls for no additional cost), but somehow preventing inmates from hurting each other is beyond their power.
- alphabettsy 2y ago> but somehow preventing inmates from hurting each other is beyond their power. For many Americans, this does not seem to be a bug rather than a feature. I regularly see comments joking about or often encouraging the physical or sexual assault of inmates.
- bananapub 2y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Private_prison#United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Private_prison#United_States: > In 2018, 8.41% of prisoners in the United States were housed in private prisons > Jails will make a profit hard to imagine that's the biggest issue. it really does seem like a cultural issue where Americans don't have sympathy or empathy for "criminals".
- commodoreboxer 2y ago> Bewildered, Eaton tried to grasp what she had just read: The judge was penalizing them because everyone — the state, the defense, the witnesses — agreed that the Mazes committed no crime. This is especially upsetting. I don't understand how so many people can be so averse to new understandings and new science. The shaken baby conversation is extremely frustrating, because many of the people responsible for the past convictions that are now being shown to be based on faulty understandings still refuse to accept that it may have been wrong. Even worse, they frame it as a political issue or a culture war, rather than just more understanding and the progress of science. It's a weird, stubborn, obstinate conservatism for its own sake and it confuses me. Is it a defense mechanism or something, to protect yourself from having to confront the idea that you may have unjustly imprisoned many innocent grieving parents for life? The new science is wrong if it makes my own actions in the past wrong. The lack of impartiality and consideration from a judge is disturbing.
- y-c-o-m-b 2y agoI wonder how much of a difference it would make if these kinds of stories went prime-time. It sickens me that Chappell Roan can make the front page of the BBC about some comments she made online, but this one is tucked away in a lesser known part of the internet where the majority of the public will never see it. If you google Russell Maze, the search results are a bit anemic, it's very sad. We should be loud and very angry about this type of injustice. It can literally happen to any one of us.
- oidar 2y agoWhy is this flagged?
- kevinsync 2y agoI'm wondering the same thing, these stories need told! I literally am good friends today with a guy who was wrongly convicted of exactly the same thing, around the same time, in a different state, who served 20 years before the Innocence Project was successful in getting him exonerated. That we, as a society, allow this shit to go on is just mind-bending.
- commodoreboxer 2y agoThe US has a strong culture of treating prisons as punishment rather than rehabilitation, so the thought of wrongful convictions becomes extremely uncomfortable, as you have to deal with the idea that you are participating in a culture that punishes innocent people for things they didn't do. The people responsible for the actual convictions often become denialists (a huge number of people who have convicted people solely on this outdated science now deny all new evidence that implies some of the convictions may have been unjust) and others who want prisons to be punishment rather than rehabilitation tend to dismiss the thoughts of all the innocent people whose lives they were okay with being stolen.
- anonymousiam 2y ago[flagged]