3 ms·
Search engines have long used the defence that they're not publishers, they merely guide you to publications by other people. Replacing search with LLM changes
by pjc50 2y ago
Search engines have long used the defence that they're not publishers, they merely guide you to publications by other people. Replacing search with LLM changes that. Who's the publisher when Bing publishes the output of an LLM? I would say that it's Microsoft. And therefore Microsoft are liable when their machine libels people.
- acdha 2y agoI think this is going to be a billion dollar legal question, and that you’re right. Companies really want to cut jobs but if precedents like that Air Canada case hold that statements by chatbots are legally binding and they lose the platform defense for misinformation that’s going to really sharply limit adoption for anything public facing.
- pjc50 2y ago> Air Canada case hold that statements by chatbots are legally binding I think that's the only outcome that makes any legal sense. Corporations may be able to buy favourable verdicts, and weak US consumer protection will help them, but EU jurisdictions are not going to let you run a machine that tells lies about people, products or services.
- acdha 2y agoAgreed. I just hope that they aren’t too successful at evading responsibility here in the U.S. since moving is not easy.
- basch 2y agoif you have a calculator or a function, and you supply the input, who owns the output?
- acdha 2y agoExactly: once you choose to use it for your business, you have ownership of the results. The challenge here will be if companies try to convince judges or lawmakers that there’s something magical about LLMs which mean they shouldn’t be liable for their business decisions.
- soco 2y agoThe AI doesn't take the decisions. The AI suggests the decisions, which are then taken and implemented by the business. It's that simple.