3 ms·
It's sad to see your factual statement downvoted. There was indeed a huge backlash in the UK, amongst authors and the public, when publishers sought to edit cl
by GJim 2y ago
It's sad to see your factual statement downvoted.
There was indeed a huge backlash in the UK, amongst authors and the public, when publishers sought to edit classic children's books by Roald Dahl and Enid Blyton to make them politically correct. Children a quite capable of understanding something was written at a different time.
- aleph_minus_one 2y ago> Children a quite capable of understanding something was written at a different time. Even if some person is certain that this is not the case, the child's parents hopefully are capable of explaining this to their children. :-)
- watwut 2y agoEven if it was the case, but it is kind of massively easier to pick a book where you do not have to explain that. Sometimes you just want to read a book and children books are not all that much fun for adults anyway. You might not want to then have to go into explaining that racism was normal for the author, but we think differently jadda jadda ... it is additional completely pointless complication for what was supposed to be good night story.
- GJim 2y agoI could not disagree with you more. It is something you will need to explain to children at some point, and doing so over a light hearted story is an ideal approach. Shying away from the difficulties of bringing up a child isn't something you should be doing. Besides, the best children's books are also fun for adults! (I raise you Roald Dahl's 'Boy' and Judith Kerr's 'The Tiger Who Came to Tea')
- kwhitefoot 2y ago> the best children's books are also fun for adults! Also Kipling's Just So stories. My eldest loved me to read them to him and it was no chore at all.
- watwut 2y agoNo it is not ideal and that argument does not make sense at all. It would be explaining something mostly off main topic of the story. And I would rather explain it on something real rather then randomly. And I am not always interested in research about the original reason - how much author was or was not racist. I don't know how you define best children's book. I found most of then boring and kids taste was not the same as my taste.
- 47282847 2y agoIf you do not find it fun to read with your children and enjoy the stories equally you may want to consider picking different books or doing something else with them. They will pick up on it, and grow up to think you do not like to spend time with them - and later take that “truth” turned core belief to other relationships.
- watwut 2y agoI kind of did not liked most of them. And the ones I kind of liked were still something I would not read if I did not had to.