3 ms·
> The programmer is in the unique position that his is the only discipline and profession in which such a gigantic ratio, which totally baffles our imagination,
by zahlman 2y ago
> The programmer is in the unique position that his is the only discipline and profession in which such a gigantic ratio, which totally baffles our imagination, has to be bridged by a single technology.
I think that for example environmentalists, who coined the phrase "think locally, act globally" and contemplated an already existing world population on the order of 10^9, might beg to differ. Or, say, astronomers. Or physicists. Yes, people often have poor intuition about large numbers. No, the resulting problem isn't remotely unique to CS.
> The second radical novelty is that the automatic computer is our first large-scale digital device.
Yet small-scale digital devices such as mechanical relays - or, for that matter, light switches and push buttons - were well established by Dijkstra's time. The scale isn't relevant to that concept; experience is, and students in the 1980s had plenty of reasonable mental models for a bit of data as an abstraction (or the hardware storing it, or a boolean value in a program).
> To do so, however, is highly dangerous: the analogy is too shallow because a program is, as a mechanism, totally different from all the familiar analogue devices we grew up with.
As if students would never encounter stepwise functions in math class (or much stranger beasts for that matter)... ?
Metaphor and analogy are simply at the core of how people naturally learn. We are not machines that can be deliberately and directly programmed with an understanding of novel systems. The imperfections of the metaphors we use, are no more a problem than the leaks in the abstractions we create in our programs.
> Unfathomed misunderstanding is further revealed by the term "software maintenance", as a result of which many people continue to believe that programs —and even programming languages themselves— are subject to wear and tear.
I can only imagine what Dijkstra would think of today's "ecosystems".