4 ms·
> Preliminary analysis indicates that time at home is associated with lower levels of happiness and less meaning I wonder if this is something that needs a clo
by SoftTalker 2y ago
> Preliminary analysis indicates that time at home is associated with lower levels of happiness and less meaning
I wonder if this is something that needs a closer look. I enjoy spending time at home. I'd rather be at home than pretty much anywhere else. Even before the pandemic I felt this way. The pandemic itself was like a vacation.
- eitally 2y agoI think it depends a lot on both the individual and how the time is spent at home. For folks who have engaging hobbies and other activities that lend themselves to home-based practice, it's entirely different than those for whom time at home is basically being shut-in and reclusive with little mental & emotional stimulation.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoAnd also depends on if you have people over and a lot of human interaction in your home. Hosting a BBQ dinner party with family and friends it's obviously different than sitting alone browsing Netflix or reddit
- jaredcwhite 2y ago> time at home is basically being shut-in and reclusive with little mental & emotional stimulation Me! That's me! I can barely even get to a mere 24 hours at home without feeling stir-crazy, and more than that you might as well dump ants all over my skin. But I'm very aware of other people (including family members I know) who are perfectly fine with days spent going nowhere…perhaps rarely even leaving their room. It makes no sense to me, but clearly this issue is very personality-dependent.
- ethbr1 2y ago> engaging hobbies It's an important point. To use a nutrition metaphor, there are many new easily-available empty calories at home these days, that weren't previously available. The web. Online gaming. Social media. Streaming. Yet venturing outside into a social environment delivers a higher minimum level of nutritional value. You see other breathing humans, experience empathy and nature, and move your body. And critically... exercise being comfortable with being uncomfortable. (Aka, life) One of the quickest paths to crazy these days is becoming too comfortable in a stable, static, self-reinforcing life. You don't get any feedback that you're drifting pretty far off the median. (I mean, has anyone actually seen the Earth's curvature...?) Reality has a well-known bias towards reinforcing common sense and reminding you when you're wrong.
- bulatb 2y ago> You see other breathing humans ...who will cheerfully explain to you that you're unhappy, your hobbies are empty, your choices as wrong, and how much happier you'd be if you'd just value what they value and like what they like and stop being you and start being them.
- ethbr1 2y agohttps://m.youtube.com/watch?v=XvfImv9NseY&t=12s https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=XvfImv9NseY&t=12s Cash in your ticket or get some joy out of the game.
- bulatb 2y agoSorry for the snark. That was unproductive. My point is that if Alice has what she wants, Bob will not convince her that she doesn't by explaining that she ought to want what Bob wants, which she doesn't have or want. Especially if what Bob wants, and Alice doesn't, is for Alice to be social with Bob. "You don't live the way I want to" is an observation, not an argument for anyone to change their values or their life.
- ethbr1 2y agoAs a pretty serious introvert who may or may not have had depression during undergrad, my experience has been that the time I most need other people and social situations is exactly when I least feel like I want that. Which has made me suspicious of introversion as a local maximum that nonetheless leaves one depressed. Humans don't seem to be built to self-regulate, 24x7, forever. At some point we go off the rails, and other humans (and/or nature) are a good way to kick things back to normal. (And yeah, I'm pretty sure I'm not a secret extrovert. It can be exhausting being around strangers when I'm down, but sometimes you need to jump off the waterfall and put on that smile that becomes real)
- vladvasiliu 2y ago> my experience has been that the time I most need other people and social situations is exactly when I least feel like I want that. I'm conflicted. I think I get what you're saying, but it doesn't seem to be an argument against bulatb's point, in that both can be true. It's conceivable for me to want to feel like you don't want social interactions and pursue non-directly-social endeavors (think building something, learning an instrument, whatever) without actually being in need of social interaction. I think the point isn't that you should self-regulate 24x7, forever, but to do the social thing on your own terms, not on other people's schedule. Maybe it's a question of quantity. If you only ever do things alone at home and never go out in society, then perhaps there is an issue. It reminds me of alcoholism: wanting to have a drink and saying you're not an alcoholic doesn't mean you're one. It's a question of degree.
- MattGaiser 2y agoAnecdotally, being social when I would rather not doesn't make me as miserable as those who are alone, when they would rather not be. So I can see our relative smaller boost in happiness being outweighed by the utter misery of others.
- steve1977 2y agoThat’s interesting. I’m very introverted I think. Being social when I would rather not (which is most of the time) makes me very miserable. To the point of being depressed.
- MattGaiser 2y agoDo you end up crying day after day, using drugs, dropping out of school, etc though? As loneliness does that to people. It is not that it is mildly painful for introverts to socialize when they do not want to, but rather that loneliness can be extremely painful.
- FloorEgg 2y agoIn the most extreme acute situations I have broken down to tears purely from over-stimulation from socializing. Specifically when attending conferences for work. (I am an introvert). After a day of intense socializing I will go back to a hotel room and cry, while other people go to after parties. As far as depression, drugs, etc. I haven't been under this pressure chronically so I can't speak from personal experience. That said, I suspect that for introverts in even the most extreme chronic social pressures it would be more feasible for them to escape to some quiet place to recharge, than it would be for an extrovert who has no social connection living in isolation to find sufficient connection to recharge. In theory, it's far more practical to manifest solitude than it is to manifest a party.
- steve1977 2y agoCrying sometimes yes, also having sleep problems before social gatherings for example. Drugs no, although I did tend to numb myself during social interactions with alcohol (not drinking any alcohol anymore, but also have reduced social interactions). I‘m not saying loneliness cannot be terrible, don’t get me wrong. I guess involuntary anything can be terrible.
- steve1977 2y agoSame here. Being at home is basically my default mode. Leaving home needs a good reason.
- allenu 2y agoFor me, staying at home during the pandemic did feel like a vacation, but it doesn't feel like that anymore. I've reasoned that the difference between spending lots of time at home now vs. the pandemic is that during the pandemic the standards for socializing and doing anything were so low, it was like a weight off. With things being closed and social distancing, it was not expected of you to really do anything. You could excuse poor social habits. Now that things are back to normal, staying at home too much and not socializing as much as pre-pandemic, feels like wasted potential, and I can't chalk it up to everything being shut down and people not being able to get together.
- ryandrake 2y agoThe pandemic finally provided an acceptable excuse for not wanting to go out and do stuff. I could just stay home 24/7 and nobody would question it--it was glorious. Prior to COVID, I'd cave in and agree to go out, wallflower there for some time to be polite, and leave as soon as I knew it wouldn't offend people. Now, post-pandemic, I simply stopped caring about what other people "question." That's their problem. Thanks to WFH, I can (and do) stay at home for weeks. I've got everything I need here at home and finally feel no external pressure to go out and do social. It's also great for costs: I put 3,000 miles on my car in the last 12 months, compared to averaging 10,000 per year prior to the pandemic.
- interiorchurch 2y agoHN is full of people with a) probably decently good homes and b) a high level of self-motivation on work and hobbies. I suspect sentiment here doesn't generalize well to the population at large.
- fullshark 2y agoMy vision of the stereotypical HNer is not A at all, but a single person somewhat just out of school, renting a shoebox in a HCOL area.
- reducesuffering 2y agoI believe the stats are more like mid-30s. So been in a software career for a decade and above-average interest in technology, a majority not even in SV... ya, most HN in US probably own homes.
- crazygringo 2y agoI don't think the quality of the home factors in, but I think you make an excellent point about HN'ers being highly self-motivated in terms of personal projects. They're less likely to be spending their time at home just watching endless TV or Instagram scrolling. So I think you're right, it doesn't generalize to the larger population at all.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- wisty 2y agoHaha, just like vitamin D. Everything is associated with going outside, but where is the causality? Almost any negative event, from financial to relational setbacks to a global pandemic make people spend more time indoors and will also have other negative effects, but you can't always cure it with vitamin D.