2 ms·
My use case is my dad (or anyone's dad) backing up family photos. It's reasonable to teach my dad to write a few CDs, but it's not reasonable to teach him how t
by stavros 2y ago
My use case is my dad (or anyone's dad) backing up family photos. It's reasonable to teach my dad to write a few CDs, but it's not reasonable to teach him how to administrate his own NAS, set up RAIDZ, figure out a way to store an ECC file, etc.
For my dad, and anyone just tech-savvy enough to select a bunch of files, put a disk in the drive and click "burn", the choices are either DVD (which deteriorates) or a cloud solution. Anything else is too much, including "here's a NAS, it'll last you forever as long as you keep it plugged in".
- buran77 2y agoBut stavros, you started this thread by complaining that the solution is bad because in order to protect your data you have to create additional data to protect. This is the most basic definition of data resilience and misses a very critical point: with this in place you only have to worry half as much about each data set randomly failing (you halved the chance of simultaneous failure, all else equal). Then you moved to the (unsupported) argument that consumers don't have reliable options. Then to the (unsupported) argument that hard drives fail after 5 years. Then to the argument that some users are not tech savvy enough to use anything more complex than a CD. The last one is the only realistic yet still relatively weak complaint. It doesn't invalidate in any way the option proposed in the article. Looking at dvdisaster creating an ECC file is at most just as complicated as generating the data you're looking to protect. Using a commercial cloud storage solution is equally straight forward. A consumer friendly NAS is very easy to use while not so obvious how to fix in case of failure but that's why you're there to set it up and set a sync to the cloud(s). I hope you taught your father how to select appropriate quality media blanks, what are the optimum storage conditions, how often to check that the data is still readable, what to do when a disc becomes unreadable or very hard to read, how to replace the optical drive when it fails or there's dirt on the lens, and so on.
- onewheeltom 2y agoThere is also the archival quality BluRay M-disc media