3 ms·
I scan QR codes regularly and find them incredibly useful. Poster about something I might be interested in? Instead of typing error-prone-fully on my stupid ti
by ColinWright 14y ago
I scan QR codes regularly and find them incredibly useful. Poster about something I might be interested in? Instead of typing error-prone-fully on my stupid tiny keyboard, I point, scan, check the URL looks sane, then go to the web site. Sometimes I take a photo and deal with it later.
Please, don't take away features I like and use just because you think no one uses them.
Instead of hating on them so much, show how genuinely clever you are and figure a way to make use of the technology, otherwise you're just like a eunuch in a harem, pointing, observing, and criticizing, without actually being able to do anything.
- rprospero 14y agoI think a lot of hate comes from the fact that I've never encountered a QR code where I couldn't have typed in the URL on my stupid-tiny keyboard faster than the time it took for the QR app to scan the code. I'm curious if this means my phone has a terrible camera or if yours has a terrible keyboard. Probably both.
- ColinWright 14y agoIt's the error-pronedness - clicks are far easier. Can you always type a lengthy URL without any mistakes or having to make corrections? Plus, I can't read a poster and a phone without constantly changing whether I'm looking through glasses or not. I type pretty well, but the scan wins every time. Added in edit: I really, really don't understand the downvotes. I'm offering a point of view as to why QR codes are easier for me. Is your downvote saying that I'm wrong? Is your downvote saying that it's irrelevant? Is your downvote saying that only people who hate QR codes can be tolerated? Is your downvote saying your mind is closed to other points of view? Help me to understand!
- rprospero 14y agoIt took me 28 seconds to type in this sentence on my cell phone. I didn't use auto-correct, so it's a pretty good match for typing a url, if a little long. That time did include going back through to correct for errors. Comparatively, I've never seen a QR code scan in under a minute, either on my own phone or on one from my friends, family, and coworkers. I could see the glasses thing being a pain.
- ColinWright 14y agoRunning a timer on my desktop, I've just timed pulling my phone from my pocket and scanned a bar code, one handed. Including getting the phone out it took 19 seconds, without any possibility of getting it wrong. And yes, the glasses thing is a pain, one of the disadvantages of getting old. 8-(
- rprospero 14y ago19 seconds? I may have to give QR codes another shot.
- ColinWright 14y agoI just did it again - yes - 19 seconds. This time I was more leisurely, but already had my phone "home page" open. Click on apps, open menu, scan to bottom, up one, click. Point, focus, open. Start: Mon Jun 18 23:18:19 BST 2012 End: Mon Jun 18 23:18:38 BST 2012
- taligent 14y agoSo you saved 9 seconds. Think about how much time it takes to find the app, download the app, learn the app, remember the app and use the app. My guess is 100x longer than all of the times you will ever use QR codes put together. That right there is your problem.
- ColinWright 14y agoIt's on my phone in an obvious place, and I use it a lot. I couldn't type URLs in sub 30 seconds, so it's saving me much more tham a few seconds every time. And it's error free. So no, that's not my problem, and I'd take it kindly if people would stopp telling me I'm wrong for finding useful something they don't agree with. Do you bother to listen to your users? Or do you just tell them they're wrong?
- taligent 14y ago
- dredmorbius 14y agoTwo words: URL shorteners. That still introduces the problem of surprise, but with the space saved by not posting the QR code, you can provide context about what the URL does provide. And riddle me: why can't your phone to OCR on a legibly-presented URL any better than it can read a QR code (yes, I know, redundancy and all that, but still).
- ColinWright 14y agoYou've said it yourself - with a shortener I've got no idea where it's going, and now I also have to type a weird, meaning-free string of upper, lower and digits. And I don't have a reliable OCR app, and OCR doesn't have redundancy. So it doesn't work, it's hard to type, and I don't know where it takes me. How is that better? And at least scanning the QR code shows me the URL before opening it.
- dredmorbius 14y agoThe QR code takes up enough space that context is precluded. With a short URL, there's at least the option. Mind: marketers providing context generally doesn't happen. I suppose, client side, you've got the option of previewing the destination URL before going to it either way. Again, not that a naked URL tells you a whole lot, but at least I can see if it's a PDF, HTML doc, or EXE downloadable off the top.