8 ms·
Productivity has risen to the point that the world simply has too many people to meaningfully employ them all. If history is a guide, the correction to this sit
by SoftTalker 2y ago
Productivity has risen to the point that the world simply has too many people to meaningfully employ them all. If history is a guide, the correction to this situation will be ugly.
- fauria 2y agoWhat would that correction look like?
- Rinzler89 2y agoWar, rioting, increased crime, social unrest, etc
- deepfriedchokes 2y agoWar, probably.
- Simon_ORourke 2y agoI'm guessing whatever the poster has in mind it'll have some Godwin's Law style implications :)
- surfingdino 2y agoA revolution or a war, or both.
- undersuit 2y agoA slow unraveling of the accumulated wealth of billionaires and corporations. Catch the falling knife with your strong hand. Be even better if the rich did it voluntarily.
- logicchains 2y agoWealth destroyed this way just disappears, it's gone. As we saw after the communist revolutions in Russia and China, which led to decades of extreme poverty and tens of millions of people starving to death. There's not a single case in history where the state mass appropriating assets from the rich improved the people's standard of living; the only people whose standard of living improved was the cadres who now controlled all the nation's wealth.
- mensetmanusman 2y agoCollapse of a young population causing a 1:1 worker retiree ratio. At that point the old get pushed off bridges.
- sxp 2y agoOnly if the assumption is that people need to be employed 40 hours a week. If we reduce the preferred workweek to something closer to 20, then we have 2x the amount of jobs available.
- raincom 2y agoWherever one can get jobs, there the cost of living--mostly housing--is exorbitantly high. Whether one works 20 hours a week or 40 hours a week depends on the cost of housing.
- schmidtleonard 2y agoWe brought women into the workforce but instead of splitting the work 50/50 we split it 100/100. Now nobody has time to raise children, but hey, the stocks, bonds, and real estate got pumped (in units of median-worker-hours) and I guess that's what's important. Ugh. What to do? Policy aimed at reducing the market-induced-labor-quota so that people can raise kids again? Something that substitutes the effect of "one spouse works, one spouse stays home" but without the sexism this time? No, never! That's radical! That's lazy! (Unintelligible screeching vaguely resembling the words "pareto optimality.") We've seen the complete domination of labor by capital once before: in the aftermath of the industrial revolution. It was fixed by a giant war that wiped out the asset holders in Europe and a less cataclysmic series of events that reduced their power in America (Great Depression got FDR into office, business leaders got caught red-handed trying to coup him and forced into concessions, WWII veterans made labor delegitimization difficult). Here's hoping we can find another Roosevelt without finding out what WWIII means.
- Swizec 2y ago> Something that substitutes the effect of "one spouse works, one spouse stays home" but without the sexism this time This more or less only existed in the upper classes and for a brief few decades after ww2 when global economy was growing fast fueled by recovery. Lower classes never had this. Read some Dickens — all the women have full time jobs. Read some post-ww2 communist stuff – all women are expected to work. Even before industrialization women worked on subsistence farms right alongside their husbands. Peasant and working class women have always had jobs. I remember a discovery channel documentary about Victorian life and it had this fun line: While the doctors debated if exercise is healthy for women, the women working in their kitchens were throwing around 50L pots of water (50kg) all day like it’s nothing.
- linotype 2y agoThere’s been too much consolidation bordering on monopolies. Whenever you hear about two companies merging and laying off thousands of staff, maybe it’s time to stop letting that happen.
- Rinzler89 2y agoThis. Whenever I see mergers between already large companies in the tech sector, I'm baffled the regulators give the green light.
- dehrmann 2y agoDo you have any recent examples of this? I'm having hard time coming up with recent large mergers and acquisitions in tech. The best I've got is Broadcom buying VMware, but VMware is mid-sized and in decline.
- linotype 2y agoThe hundreds of acquisitions of startups made every year by Apple, Google and Microsoft for example.
- Rinzler89 2y agoNXP and Freescale. How is VMware mid sized? By what standards?
- goldfishgold 2y agoActivision and Microsoft. Square and Afterpay. Salesforce and Slack. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_largest_mergers_and_acquisitions#2020s https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_largest_mergers_and_ac... VMware was also an enormous deal. $61b.
- linotype 2y agoSlack was crazy. Aside from huddles I can’t think of a single feature I’ve used that they’ve added since their acquisition by Salesforce. Like what are they doing with so many people? (I know that’s a trope, but seriously…)
- JackMorgan 2y agoMost of the planet is empty, yet housing is expensive. Most of our food is produced by a few percent of the population, yet people go hungry. I don't know what the right answer is, but we live in strange economic times
- Tagbert 2y agoHousing is inexpensive in places where people don’t want to live. Not all locations are equivalent. Hunger is generally a distribution and pricing problem more than a supply problem.
- logicchains 2y agoHunger is only a distribution problem in the sense that people in certain regions don't produce enough food to feed themselves or anything of enough value to trade for food. Which is a problem with the social and economic systems of those countries, something that can't be fixed externally (unless somebody wants to e.g. invade and depose King Jong Un..)
- bobthepanda 2y agoIt is partially that and partially logistics. Food waste is significantly higher in areas where hunger is endemic because a lot of food never makes it to a market where it would be purchased due to poor transport links, lack of refrigeration, etc.
- weweweoo 2y agoHousing is inexpensive in places where there are not enough jobs. Cities were born due to industrialization moving jobs to them, not because people suddenly wanted to become urban. So, what individuals want has little to do with it.
- nine_zeros 2y agoExactly, the economics, and gains of the economic system are f-ed up.
- nyokodo 2y ago>Productivity has risen to the point that the world simply has too many people to meaningfully employ them all. China doesn't have a domestic or international consumer base large enough to buy everything it produces. For some years now Chinese growth has been fueled by a real estate bubble of truly historic proportions that has burst. Even in a healthy economy with a healthy demographic structure it takes time to recover from the depths of the business cycle, China is healthy in neither sense and this is an economic crash its unlikely to meaningfully recover from.
- _boffin_ 2y agoCan you provide some sources or readings on the correction and the ugliness you speak of.
- j_timberlake 2y agoIf the problem were that simple, the world could be drastically improved by just throwing more money at infrastructure jobs and getting more people employed, while also improving infra. So I doubt it's that simple. But AI is probably going to hit the labor market like a wrecking ball anyway, at which point it will be exactly like that.
- namaria 2y ago> Productivity has risen to the point that the world simply has too many people to meaningfully employ them all. This is only a problem because the increase in productivity is captured by corporations. If people were paid accordingly, they could autonomously decide to work fewer hours and everyone would be able to put in the 10-20h/week. Keynes foresaw it nearly 100 years ago.
- piyuv 2y agoPretty sure Keynes did not oversee human greed being this enormous
- mensetmanusman 2y agoHuman greed knows no bound, surprised it wasn’t factored.
- pjc50 2y agoMarx (and Adam Smith!) did. I'm sure you can find something in the writings of Keynes if you look.
- euroderf 2y agoDial the standard workweek back to 32 hours. Adjust the minimum wage accordingly. A wave of new automation. Dial the standard workweek back to 2x hours. Adjust the minimum wage accordingly. A wave of new automation. Lather, rinse, repeat. Expect it to converge towards a value, but a value that monotonically decreases over time.
- bankcust08385 2y agoCorporations are legal fictions. The large owners of megacorporations are the problem, along with corporate personhood.
- bankcust08385 2y agoI agree. Without intervention, most of all humanity will gradually slip into poverty and deprivation. Wealth and income redistribution will be essential but it will not happen voluntarily since the billionaires and the centimillionaires will refuse to reduce corruption or share to reduce suffering.
- tim333 2y agoMost people used to work in farming. Now that is done with about 1% of the population. The rest still find things to do. If history is any guide similar will happen.