4 ms·
> But watches provide some pretty useful health and emergency benefits For kids? How ever did anyone survive before 1990.
by WalterBright 2y ago
> But watches provide some pretty useful health and emergency benefits
For kids? How ever did anyone survive before 1990.
- xoa 2y ago>How ever did anyone survive before I really, really hate this mindless, lazy line of argument in general. It gets tossed out with absolutely everything, from the internet to vaccines to modern farming. The simple answer in many cases to "how did anyone survive before X" is "well, often they didn't". Life expectancies were in fact lower in the past. More people died, or were maimed, with no hope of treatment. Or sometimes it's "they did, but much less efficiently and we come to depend on each growth of the economy which at the foundation is literally about being able to do things more efficiently". Ease of communication, knowing what the weather is, all sorts of things mean less wasteful use of time and energy. Sometimes "they did, but perhaps less happily". A loved relative was in and accident, went to the hospital and you never got the chance to be involved when it mattered. And of course in some cases it's "new things have created downsides that create a need for other new things, the world has changed". Sometimes we can do something about that in the near term. Sometimes we cannot. Low effort responses like you made are discouraged on HN for good reason. Yeah, absolutely new negatives have come with the new positives and seeking to reduce the former matters. But productive discussion and activity tends to focus on specifics vs generalities. Reducing the benefits of real time communication devices to a binary "life/death" and then NOT grappling with modern trends in everything from natural disasters to school shootings to reduced bussing doesn't strike me as great Walter.
- WalterBright 2y agoI stand by my assertion. How many times in your 12 years in school was instant 24/7 communication for everyone in the school been of significant benefit, or would have been if they had it? It's zero in my case. Then look at the downsides, which are pervasive - inattention, disruption, distraction. If you still want it, put a landline phone in each classroom on the teacher's desk. The principal can also have a switch to turn it off in an emergency.
- xoa 2y ago>I stand by my assertion. How many times in your 12 years in school was instant 24/7 communication for everyone in the school been of significant benefit, or would have been if they had it? It's zero in my case. Yeah, there were no school shootings in my state in the 90s either. But since Columbine objective fact is there have been over 400 affecting almost 400k students [0], and the trend doesn't seem to be going down. Events like sudden wildfires going out of control in a real hurry are now also radically different then even 20 years ago. And yes, some of the scheduling and health features watches offer would have been very helpful to me in school thanks. The communication features of watches are pleasantly minimal and also almost necessarily public. They only work well 2-way with voice, which is not something one can do silently by definition and thus highly policeable in class. The information consumption capability is highly minimal. Watches also do not have cameras with all the associated issues. And it'd be possible to take the communication restrictions further with cellular restrictions in school and forcing everything through the school's firewall. >Then look at the downsides, which are pervasive - inattention, disruption, distraction. Out of genuine curiosity: can you show me some good studies on this with respect to watches, not phones? On the smart phone side yes, I've absolutely both seen studies and personally experienced the addictive and distracting aspects. But I have not seen anything like that with watches, and my personal experience is also that it's completely different in usage. I stand by my assertion: you threw out a form of argument that is lazy, shallow, and constantly misapplied. Even if in this specific case the balance of factors weighs against any smart devices at all (which I both extremely doubt and think will become extremely problematic for other reasons longer term), the form of argument "how did anyone survive before X" is so regularly bad faith, aggressively stupid, or both that it coming out instantly makes me more not less suspicious of whichever side the person stating it is supporting. ---- 0: https://www.washingtonpost.com/education/interactive/school-shootings-database/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/education/interactive/school-...
- WalterBright 2y agoWhy does a health monitor need to be in constant connection with the internet? If there's a problem, it can just beep at you. Yes, school shootings are a problem. But why does there need to be 30 cell phones in the classroom? The landline on the teacher's desk can be enough. Or even a button to turn off the jammer. For wildfire, call the principal who then hits the fire button. We had tornado drills in elementary school. No phones were required, it was a siren mounted on a pole. It worked fine. Who needs 1000 phones in the school?
- yawaramin 2y ago> The simple answer in many cases to "how did anyone survive before X" is "well, often they didn't" I would recommend rethinking the assertion that most kids in schools are going to die without a cellphone.
- AlbertCory 2y agoA 300-word answer isn't 20x more intelligent than a 15-word one. I think Walter said all that needs to be said, and more economically than you did.
- tsimionescu 2y agoWalter's comment could be applied exactly as well to an argument that there shouldn't be electricity in schools (after all, kids survived without electricity just fine for decades).
- eimrine 2y agoThe talk is about having a client for tiktok but with ability to phone - on your Math lesson. When the phone used to have no tiktok the situation is tolerable even if the phone rings occationally. Now the tiktok client successfully competes with teacher for kids' attention and some dumbheads are shouting - "Look, the tiktok client still can phone police/firefighters/parents! What else are you going to prohibit, maybe a paper?"
- vkou 2y agoIf 99.9% of what electricity was used for in a class for was a distraction, this might be a reasonable argument. It's not, though. But I'd wager that 99.9% of cellphone use during class is.
- watwut 2y agoThen they needed to make THAT argument. They did not, argument was lazy "it did not existed in the past, so" thing.
- AlbertCory 2y agoMaybe Walter thought you were smart enough to fill in the gaps and think for yourself. Guess he was wrong.
- somenameforme 2y agoTo look at life expectancy, you need to normalize for the fact that numerous things have shifted dramatically in society. For instance smoking rates have completely plummeted relative to the past, to say nothing of the fact that up until the 90s you could generally smoke everywhere, even on airplanes! Then there have also been major changes in typical occupations, reductions in youth driving, and so on. Given that life expectancy increases have been coming at a snail's pace, and on occasion reversing, I suspect if one normalized for these sort of non-medical shifts in society, we'd see that life expectancy is most likely decreasing, likely due to things like widespread obesity, mental illness, and other ailments which modern gadgets are significantly contributing to.
- filoleg 2y agoI mean, people have been surviving for far longer before electricity was discovered compared to after. What does that have to do with anything at all?
- WalterBright 2y agoI guess we'll find out when cellphones are banned from class.
- whatshisface 2y agoSometimes people just died, or whatever.
- chgs 2y agoYou never used a pay phone as a kid?
- kwhitefoot 2y agoI was born in 1955 in the UK and I almost never used a phone of any kind as a child.
- 082349872349872 2y agoI have a friend a bit younger than you born in rural ireland; when she was a child her phone number was 8.
- WalterBright 2y agoI used the two cans and a string phone as a kid. Only one channel on TV! I built an intercom from a kit when older, but it was useless as yelling worked better.
- defrost 2y agoGood grief, he's not that old ... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Walter_Bright https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Walter_Bright Maybe mentally append a '/s' to the comment you replied to.
- WalterBright 2y agoAmusingly, at Caltech the only phone in the dorm was a payphone down the hall. The only time I recall ever using it was to make flight reservations to visit my parents. My first cellphone was in 1994 or so. It took many years before I was acclimated to using it, and didn't get an internet phone until 2015. I was a very early adopter of computers, but pretty late with phones.
- lloeki 2y agoPublic payphones? Going into a bakery or a post office or any shop and politely asking to place a call from their landline to mom&pop's, having their number memorised, possibly placing a reverse charged call? "you are here" public maps/carrying a paper map? Learning how to use a compass+map or just sun and stars? Eating home-cooked meals and walking/biking around a lot to go from A to B? For better or worse, the world is both more of the same and very different from what it used to be. Direct comparisons are not really useful, and quips like "how did people drive without a gas gauge / survive without seatbelts" are missing a ton of context.
- WalterBright 2y agoI was referring to phones in the classroom.
- watwut 2y agoIt was accepted as a fact that kids got lost or in trouble and needed help from strangers. Or that parents had no idea where they are.