3 ms·
That formulation prioritizes avoiding harm to small minorities at the expense of maximizing the well being of the majority. Consider by contrast how East asian
by rayiner 2y ago
That formulation prioritizes avoiding harm to small minorities at the expense of maximizing the well being of the majority.
Consider by contrast how East asian countries approach public policy: the needs of the typical person are elevated above the needs of people with different or special circumstances. That’s why they can have nice things like public transportation and clean and safe cities.
- dyauspitr 2y agoYou need a communal society with enough ambient social pressure to keep people “typical” for that system to work.
- rexpop 2y agoSuch societies may find themselves implementing Procrustean policies meant to enforce conformity. One classic (red herring) image is "Harrison Bergeron," but actual transphobic attitudes are more pressing.
- rayiner 2y agoWhich is impossible to maintain under a Rawlsian viewpoint that prioritizes minorities. Consider the Asian social norm against being overweight and the attendant enforcement mechanisms. It benefits most people for whom social reinforcement can help them maintain a healthy weight. But it’s unpleasant for a minority. Rawlsian thinking tends to oppose such welfare-maximizing policies, by focusing the inquiry on that minority.
- dyauspitr 2y agoYou’re preaching to the choir. I’m all for a common culture and societal pressure to adhere to it. But as circumstances are, the preexisting common culture in the US is no longer viable as this country is now heavily heterogenous, both ethnically and ideologically. You can try extracting aspects from the past culture that are still relevant but that’s clearly not acceptable to a sizable part of the country as they hold the parts most unacceptable- latent bigotry and the other- as the most crucial aspect of the previous common culture.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoIs that kind of depends on the expected value in each situation. I think you can go either way depending on the magnitude of the benefit and expense. Also, there's the obvious slippery slope into utilitarianism and things like killing one person to save 10 with their organs.
- uhmpire 2y agoBlanket outlawing of utilitarianism is its own slippery slope. Just because some long dead philosophers, mostly affluent people who avoided real work and utilitarian choice, had time to sit and cobble together some syntax and semantics doesn’t mean it’s literally possible to live by their high minded babble And to the moral point; today the majority rely on as little labor as possible paid as little as possible to make their food and clothes; consuming the few willing to work for little for the benefit of the many is daily life for richer countries. Pretending our society is beyond such because our historical philosophy says it is pretentious wank