4 ms·
> We can replace the role that the SSN plays (authentication) with modern techniques like public-key cryptography. I think that would be a disaster. Have you m
by simonw 2y ago
> We can replace the role that the SSN plays (authentication) with modern techniques like public-key cryptography.
I think that would be a disaster. Have you met human beings? The idea that they could keep a private key safe and secure is not realistic at all.
[EDIT: As people in replies have pointed out, this works great provided there's a central government process for issuing a new card should you lose access to your previous one - so yeah, public-key cryptography can absolutely help here provided there's a central authority to help people recover access]
Same reason cryptocurrency could _NEVER_ become a mainstream way of handling finances - only the nerdiest of the super-nerds have the slightest chance of keeping a private key safe and consistently available.
Even the super-nerds aren't safe. The number of technically proficient people who've lost all of their cryptocurrency/NFTs/etc has illustrated that many times over at this point.
- atrettel 2y agoI agree that implementing it like how cryptocurrency works would be bad. I'm not in favor of that. But as I had said, I'm not arguing for any specific implementation. However, smart cards for IDs is one implementation that already exists [1], and it would be more like using a security key instead of just typing in your SSN. I think that would be more appropriate for people with a broad range of technical experiences, but as I had said, I'm not advocating for any particular implementation, just pointing out that the technology exists to at least attempt to solve the problem. What solution do you think would work here? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FIPS_201 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FIPS_201
- OptionOfT 2y agoIn Belgium everybody has an ID card which has a chip which can be used to sign anything. It's a private key that is only on the card. So it's totally possible. But there needs to be a will from the government AND a will from the people to allow the government to store data on their citizens (address etc).
- svieira 2y agoSo what happens when you break or loose the card? How do you establish your identity at that point?
- tuwtuwtuwtuw 2y agoI think the point is that this is a solved problem in most places. I always see people from US writing that modern authentication solutions wouldn't work, despite them being used for decades for example in many countries in Europe. Of course, all solutions comes with their own set of issues but preferring SSN over public/private keys for authentication is wild.
- vasco 2y agoIn Portugal at least you do it the same way you did it before the cards had a key. It's the same problem, how do you establish you're the guy that's in front of them trying to get a replacement for your "lost ID"? That's independent of the ID having a key. So whatever process you use for that now at the DMV or whatever.
- tuwtuwtuwtuw 2y agoAre you aware that most modern countries are already using things similar to public key cryptography for authentication? US is meanwhile stuck in the past with their faxes, checks and says it's impossible to move on.
- vasco 2y agoYou should read about most European countries ID cards. Some place to start could be the cryptography infrastructure the ID cards use, "Digital Mobile Key" also interesting.