7 ms·
No shortage of land in the US, but everyone wants to live in the same few places (for good reason), and those places have a lot of restrictions on what can be b
by xnx 2y ago
No shortage of land in the US, but everyone wants to live in the same few places (for good reason), and those places have a lot of restrictions on what can be built where.
It's satisfying to blame a big bad "them" for this, but the problem is "us". We all want our properties to increase in value so we collectively conspire to suppress supply that would make our properties less valuable.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- netbioserror 2y agoLand and homes also make for excellent inflation hedges; thus, property owners become advocates for money printing and suppressed interest rates.
- lapcat 2y ago> No shortage of land in the US, but everyone wants to live in the same few places It's not enough to have land, though. The land needs access to water and electricity, not to mention roads, or it's a nonstarter, especially if you want to build a bunch of homes on the land. And the new homeowners will need access to food and supplies, i.e., stores. You need an entire community.
- kaibee 2y agoThe neat thing about capitalism is that stores will be built to serve the community if there's a market for it. We don't need to centrally plan the whole community up front. We do need zoning laws that ALLOW those stores to be built though.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoThis is not borne out by the evidence. https://www.ruralhealthinfo.org/topics/food-and-hunger https://www.ruralhealthinfo.org/topics/food-and-hunger https://www.propublica.org/article/food-desert-grocery-store-cairo-illinois https://www.propublica.org/article/food-desert-grocery-store...
- kaibee 2y agoThose are about rural communities. It makes perfect sense that a very low-density community doesn't generate enough demand for a robust grocery store. The 2nd article mentions that the community used the newly built grocery store for a while, before going back mostly shopping at a Walmart 30 miles away. My guess is that those people were going to that Walmart anyway for this or that in many cases. So at that point, why drive to two locations, esp for most people in the rural area, that grocery store isn't actually that much more convenient, and can't compete on price with Walmart?
- toomuchtodo 2y agoYou said: > The neat thing about capitalism is that stores will be built to serve the community if there's a market for it. I am pointing out that this is not a given, magic that will just happen. Capitalism is not always efficient nor reliable, based on the evidence. > before going back mostly shopping at a Walmart 30 miles away. My guess is that those people were going to that Walmart anyway for this or that in many cases. So at that point, why drive to two locations, esp for most people in the rural area, that grocery store isn't actually that much more convenient, and can't compete on price with Walmart? https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/business/walmart-closings/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/business/walmart-clo... https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2016/02/05/what-happens-to-a-tiny-town-when-walmart-disappears/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2016/02/05/what-...
- kaibee 2y ago> I am pointing out that this is not a given, magic that will just happen. Capitalism is not always efficient nor reliable, based on the evidence. I said 'if there's a market for it'. The simple fact is that these rural communities are just not as economically viable as they used to be. Most rural communities exist around 'base input' types of industries that made money by exporting stuff extracted from the land. Farming, mining, logging, etc. The community existed because extracting those resources required a lot of labor, and that labor wanted to buy services after work. When you had 100 people who worked in the fields all day, they'd come back to town and patronize local bars, stores etc. However, farming, like mining, has continued to become less and less labor intensive because of better automation. There isn't 100 people coming back from the fields in most cases now. There's 1 dude who was driving a combine harvester all day. Or a planter, etc. And more recently, its one guy who was monitoring a dozen combine harvesters that were self-driving based on GPS. Editing in a reply to below comments bc depth limit. > This is why I'm very pro remote work for the broader economy. > It's much easier for remote workers who want to live in rural areas to patronize these local bars, stores, etc, when they're not already commuting to places with a much larger collection of services. I'm also pro-remote work, but even if every job that is do-able remote becomes remote, that won't revitalize every rural community. No one is moving to North Dakota just because they got a remote job. The US is just too big and the number of remote-able jobs is too small. Sure, some rural communities, with particularly nice outdoors, etc will be winners. But you need actual 'large' numbers of people to sustain those local bars/stores. A few software developers moving to a dying mining town is just not going to be enough patrons to sustain a bar, stores, schools, etc. Even if they all keep their 500k Google paychecks, they can still only drink so much beer at once. > In which case, that reminds me: > The neat thing about central planning is that it can invest in things-- like rural electrification-- which are cost prohibitive for a market-based solution, if/when that need arises. > So would you agree they are both neat in their own way? Yes, they are both neat in their own way. I like that the post office has to deliver mail to everyone. Central planning can react faster than the market, if the central planners have good foresight. But they can't see into the future either. If you have some rural mining community that could sustain a population of 5,000 in 1970, it made a lot of sense to electrify it. But then 40 years later, the mine is more productive than ever before, but only needs 20% of the labor because of advances in automation. It kinda sucks that you built an electric system sized for a population of 10,000, right? Cuz now you have a town of 5,000 where unemployment is extremely high. Though I'd argue that rural electrification at this point (or in the next few years) is probably best by a home-solar-battery combo.
- lapcat 2y ago> The neat thing about capitalism is that stores will be built to serve the community if there's a market for it. We don't need to centrally plan the whole community up front. There's a chicken-and-egg problem here, though. Would you buy a new home and move in with no groceries or other stores in the area yet? If there's an existing community, then yes, stores will be built eventually, but that can't just happen overnight, so how do homeowners survive in the meantime? That's why most new housing is built in the suburbs around existing cities. All of the amenities needed by homeowners are already nearby, or at least within reasonable driving distance. Starting a new community in the middle of nowhere would be extremely difficult, and would certainly cost a lot more money to the home builders, reducing profit.
- xnx 2y agoVery true. There are many areas in the US (Detroit for example) that have lost population over the past 50 years that wouldn't have to start from scratch with new development.
- kjkjadksj 2y agoThe homes from detroits population high did not sit vacant and maintained over the decades. They rotted apart and many were razed. Much of inner city detroit really would be like starting from scratch considering the amount of vacant greenfield land available.
- xnx 2y agoThe neighborhoods definitely aren't turnkey, but roads, pipes, and power lines give you a good head start.
- kjkjadksj 2y agoAssuming infrastructure serving vacant lots were maintained by a famously insolvent city budget is a big one to make. Sometimes replacement or retrofit are vastly more expensive than greenfield development.
- ghaff 2y agoThat's a bit of a strawman though. There are plenty of cities and towns that have infrastructure and have stores at some level that have much lower costs. (They may or may not have good local jobs.) It's not a choice between NYC/SF/etc. and the wilds of Wyoming.
- lapcat 2y agoI'm not sure what exactly you think is a straw man? When the OP said "everyone wants to live in the same few places", I didn't interpret that to mean specifically NYC/SF, because that's plainly false. I interpreted it to mean urban vs. rural/undeveloped areas in general. But the problem is that home builder cartels exist all across the country, and they own a lot of the desirable land around the urban areas. For example, in my own area of Madison, Wisconsin, we have a company Veridian Homes that owns giant tracts of land all around the outskirks of the Madison area. They're the dominant home builder here.
- ghaff 2y agoIt was in reference to: The land needs access to water and electricity, not to mention roads, or it's a nonstarter, especially if you want to build a bunch of homes on the land. (The comment may indeed be true--sort of by definition to at least some degree--for new construction, although getting that access can be pretty straightforward, to the degree anything involving construction is straightforward. It's more that housing prices are an issue in popular places where a lot of people want to live. And, yes, vibrant college towns fall into that category although not to the same degree as elite cities.)
- lapcat 2y agoFair enough, it would be possible to scale up smaller towns, much smaller than Madison. However, I'm not sure that's practical, at least to the extent required to meet the housing shortage, for several reasons. First, the reason you already mentioned: "They may or may not have good local jobs." Second, there may not be enough home builders available in smaller towns. The builders themselves have to come from somewhere, and they're likely to be somewhat scarce the smaller and more remote the town. I just don't think the conspiracy that the OP postulated, "We all want our properties to increase in value so we collectively conspire to suppress supply" is a very plausible explanation when applied in general to the entire country. For example, again in the Madison area, most of the home building is occurring not in the city proper but rather out in the suburbs and exurbs, which are independently governed. Indeed, in a fast-growing suburb, the property values can actually increase as homes are built and the town becomes a more desirable place to live.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoThe fix is to enshrine remote work for jobs that can be remote (labor regulation and whatnot), enabling labor mobility to where housing is affordable, but the ideological challenges prevent that. So, instead, we gnash teeth and say there is no solution while we slowly build more housing stock and hope that'll catch us up eventually. It will, eventually, as immigration slows, and the death rate exceeds the birth rate and household formation (see: Japan), but that will take time. To destroy housing values to increased affordability, you must destroy locality as a value factor.
- Aurornis 2y ago> The fix is to enshrine remote work for jobs that can be remote (labor regulation and whatnot), enabling labor mobility to where housing is affordable, Not really a fix. When people's location becomes free from their jobs, they don't move to remote locations where land is cheap. They move to cities they want to live in, or cities where they have friends and family. The subset of people who prefer to move to the middle of nowhere and prioritize the cheapest housing above all else is very small (and probably overrepresented online)
- toomuchtodo 2y agoCan you provide a citation with data demonstrating this? Here's mine: https://www.yardikube.com/blog/remote-workers-leading-the-migration-across-state-lines/ https://www.yardikube.com/blog/remote-workers-leading-the-mi... https://www.wcnc.com/article/money/charlotte-north-carolina-affordable-housing-remote-workers-relocate-for-cheaper-homes/275-0a5fdd5e-5626-4c3e-a8a4-8af1d37c3fa4 https://www.wcnc.com/article/money/charlotte-north-carolina-... https://www.fanniemae.com/media/48891/display https://www.fanniemae.com/media/48891/display https://www.americanexperiment.org/study-finds-that-remote-work-is-allowing-people-to-move-to-cheaper-rural-areas/ https://www.americanexperiment.org/study-finds-that-remote-w... https://web.archive.org/web/20230127175520/https://www.ruralmn.org/the-state-of-rural-2023/ https://web.archive.org/web/20230127175520/https://www.rural... (also, I said where housing is affordable, not the middle of nowhere)
- galdosdi 2y ago
- onemoresoop 2y agoWhy does everyone want to live in the same few places? Because all ways to make money and a living are there! Give people the option to work remotely and they can live wherever they want, and that is not in crowded expensive cities most of the time.
- mulmen 2y agoThere’s a lot more to life than a job. Most jobs can’t be done remotely. How do you convince a barista to move to New Billings? Is there anything to do there after work?
- bluGill 2y agoThere is a lot to do there, but it might not to be to your liking. If you don't like guns the fact that you can safely shoot off your deck is f no value. Meanwhile you get one musical in town per year and they expect you to be in it (that is not very high quality).
- bratwurst3000 2y agoi work remote and i live in an expensive city. why? because I was raised here and have many friends and there is much cultural events going on. work aint everything
- Aurornis 2y ago> Give people the option to work remotely and they can live wherever they want, and that is not in crowded expensive cities most of the time. COVID dramatically increased the opportunities for remote work. Yet housing prices in major cities went up, not down. Anecdotally, my friends who moved during COVID remote work all moved to cities they wanted to live in. I knew more people leaving mid-sized towns to move to Seattle, NYC, and the Bay Area than the opposite.
- stouset 2y agoWe have made an enormous shift in that direction post-COVID and it turns out that: [drumroll] people still largely prefer to live in cities when financially viable. The price tag of cities is itself evidence of this. San Francisco isn’t expensive in a vacuum. If there wasn’t demand for housing at these prices, they would fall. And yet people continue to willingly pay an enormous premium for the privilege of living here. I can walk across the street to get my groceries. I have at least fifty restaurants within walking distance. My doctor is four blocks away and a large hospital is six. I have access to a large park three blocks away. There is a streetcar that goes straight downtown one block away and three buses that go throughout the city are right at the end of my block. I can bike to virtually anywhere I want to go if walking is too far or transit is annoying. And all of this keeps us healthy. It’s no secret that obesity is approaching near universality in areas of the country where driving is the only option to reach basic amenities. It also correlates with reduced energy use and therefore to reduced greenhouse gas emissions. Making cities cheaper goes a lot further than trying to make cheap but fundamentally broken suburbs and exurbs less hostile. And part of that is precisely what this article highlights: the rentier class siphoning away the profits of workers while providing little to no value themselves. And I say this as a homeowner (and therefore landowner) myself.
- VancouverMan 2y agoIt's a similar situation in Canada, but with the added problem of horribly flawed immigration policies that have flooded the country with a huge number of foreigners each year. While this has been going on for decades now, it has really intensified over the last nine years. The equivalent of a large (by Canadian standards) city's worth of people is being added each year, but there is nowhere near that much residential construction taking place in total.
- doubled112 2y agoAs long as Canadians live 4 to a bed, the housing situation is keeping up. Maybe it can be like hot desking at the office. Just have to make sure you and your roommates work opposing shifts. https://www.tvo.org/article/ontarios-housing-crisis-is-becoming-literally-absurd https://www.tvo.org/article/ontarios-housing-crisis-is-becom...
- ekez 2y agoIf "we" all got together and reduced permitting costs, "our" homes would be much more valuable because a developer can build a highrise where the house is.
- dnissley 2y agoI feel like I need to make this point again and again: It's not about increasing the value of properties for most (after all, allowing apartments to be built in your neighborhood would increase the value of the remaining SFHs). It's about keeping the character of the neighborhood the same as it is now (SFH vibes), and all that comes with that ("family friendliness", etc).
- aorloff 2y agoEveryone wants to keep the character of their neighborhood. Forget that ! When you go to a dense city like Barcelona where every block is nearly 4 story high rise apartments, its wonderful. Change is beautiful, people enhance neighborhoods
- dnissley 2y agoI agree, and I think even the folks who are against that would actually end up enjoying it more. But people hate change, especially when it means changing something that has been that way for generations at this point. My main point though is that people who think this is about money are simply wrong. Trying to argue numbers with these folks will not move them an inch. It has everything to do with emotion.
- nineplay 2y ago> I agree, and I think even the folks who are against that would actually end up enjoying it more That's a pretty remarkable belief. Many of us happy suburbanites have lived in large dense cities in our younger days. We are not ignorant of the joys of city living, we've just changed priorities.
- dnissley 2y agoThe neighborhoods I have in mind here aren't "true suburbs" but rather "pre-war suburbs" that are already fairly dense. Think west SF, Fremont/Ballard in Seattle, etc.
- 2y ago
- 1986 2y agoDid you know that a third of the US population lives in a rental property?
- xnx 2y agoI didn't. Unfortunately, renters vote at a lower rate and don't vote with the same focus as property owners.
- nomel 2y agoYou missed a costly part of grabbing a chunk of land: utilities. Getting them onto your land, so you can live with modern creature comforts, some of them dictated by law, is often prohibitively expensive. You can DIY with the alternative being a well (hit or miss), a septic system, and setting up a solar/battery farm, which isn't cheap either.
- whartung 2y ago> You missed a costly part of grabbing a chunk of land: utilities. There is a 15 acre lot down the street. A good spot for another small housing development. But one issue with it is that it has legacy utility and power poles on the periphery. Anyone wanting to develop that space is obliged to route all of that underground, which easily add several M$ to the project. Eventually, someone will bite, buy the lot, and develop it. But it's going to be low on the list because all of that cost will notably bounce up the new home costs. Cheaper places to build elsewhere.
- bluGill 2y agoWhat is wrong with powar poles? They are reliable and work well.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- nomel 2y agoAbove ground is ugly, and less reliable, in terms of frequency (about half) and total duration (about 20% more, since underground takes around 1.6x longer per outage) [1]. But, underground is so expensive that they end up being a net social loss, at least in NY [2]. [1] https://pdi2.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/51-EdisonElectInst1.pdf https://pdi2.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/51-EdisonElectIn... [2] https://dps.ny.gov/system/files/documents/2023/09/final-report-ny-undergrounding-2023-06-27.pdf https://dps.ny.gov/system/files/documents/2023/09/final-repo...
- nineplay 2y agoProperty values are a small-to-none factor. I don't want more noise. I don't want more traffic. I don't want more students at my kid's schools, which are already at a 35/1 kid to teacher ratio. That's it for me. I think that's it for a lot of people, whether they live in cities or suburbs or far out in the country. Very few people want more crowding. The people who like living in dense cities already live there. Blaming greed and property values is just a distraction.
- chgs 2y agoPresumably double the density you also double the size of the school and double the teachers. If you don’t, the problem isn’t the density.
- nineplay 2y agoThere are a lot of problems, none of which are going to be addressed if the only focus is property values. A school was knocked down in my neighborhood to build a pricey apartment complex. The district and the developers made a bunch of promises about how current schools would be expanded and more resources would be available. Those were all lies, of course. Apartment complexes make money, public schools do not. Guess which one wins.
- jjav 2y ago> Presumably double the density you also double the size of the school and double the teachers. It's not that easy. If you doubled the density, maybe there is nowhere left to go for the school to expand, or the land is now so expensive there is no way for the town to afford expanding the school. My town is an example. The middle school had two quite large empty lots on two sides. Those lots have now multi-story apartment buildings in construction. Presumably those apartments will attract younger families who might have kids going to middle school. But if that school ever needs to expand, it is now boxed in by housing on all sides. Time will tell how it goes.
- mjmahone17 2y agoCouldn’t the school just build taller too?
- smcin 2y agoThis on the same day that the SF Bay Area pulled its $20 billion housing bond from the November ballot [0], after objectors claimed the published costings were inaccurate. (SJMercuryNews: "The total cost, including principal and interest on the bond, is estimated at $48.3 billion and would take more than 50 years to pay off.") Another relevant project is the Solano County ("California Forever") proposal [1], which is being dropped from the 2024 ballot but is still active (presumably for March 2026 ballot, when there will be gubernatorial primary and high turnout). Also, after 2024 CA Proposition 5 ("Lower Supermajority from 66.67% to 55% for local bond measures to fund housing projects and public infrastructure")[2] has been voted on. (It's also being challenged by the Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association.) We will be able to compare timelines/costs/delays between the two development proposals and get answers on whether costs/delays in CA homebuilding are primarily due to the homebuilder, the city/county, CA state, the development process in general, or nearby residents' objections. The Solano County proposal is more greenfield and seems to have more supporters and fewer existing homeowners to object, so this outcome should be interesting and informative. (Of course, it's a distinct possibility that both proposals get killed politically, which would also give us the answer that it's not really about costs or timelines, and that a vocal minority of existing homeowners/landowners can game the process to pretty much kill any proposal, regardless how antisocial that might be.) -- [0]: https://www.mercurynews.com/2024/08/13/20b-bay-area-housing-bond-could-be-cut-from-the-ballot/ https://www.mercurynews.com/2024/08/13/20b-bay-area-housing-... [1]: KQED Forum "What’s Next for California Forever’s Proposal to Build a New City in Solano County" https://www.kqed.org/forum/2010101906729/whats-next-for-california-forevers-proposal-to-build-a-new-city-in-solano-county https://www.kqed.org/forum/2010101906729/whats-next-for-cali... [2]: Ballotpedia: CA Prop 5 https://ballotpedia.org/California_Proposition_5,_Lower_Supermajority_Requirement_to_55%25_for_Local_Bond_Measures_to_Fund_Housing_and_Public_Infrastructure_Amendment_(2024) https://ballotpedia.org/California_Proposition_5,_Lower_Supe...
- davidw 2y ago> It's satisfying to blame a big bad "them" for this, but the problem is "us" Yep. People want a bogeyman so bad, but time after time, I show up to hearings, read about efforts to build housing and the problem is local NIMBYism: https://bendyimby.com/2024/04/16/the-hearing-and-the-housing-shortage/ https://bendyimby.com/2024/04/16/the-hearing-and-the-housing... My own take on the 'bogeyman' theories: https://bendyimby.com/2023/01/11/the-bogeyman/ https://bendyimby.com/2023/01/11/the-bogeyman/
- jauntywundrkind 2y agoOne thing DC had some well half a century ago was housing coops. Take a bunch of folks across a block of area & convince them to band together & build big. Create a housing coop that collectively owns the building, is the people who will live there. Right now every property owner is sort of in it for themselves. Figuring out ways to enable development while retaining ownership, without forcing owners to sell of their stake, while enfranchising future owners, worked really well. But it feels like we aren't trying to replicate this clear success. Opportunity comes at scale Figuring out how to make that scaling possibly accessible by residents (versus someone else getting to capture the value of redevelopment) requires some legal can do willingness we haven't been seeing.
- xnx 2y agoInteresting. I'm reading about co-ops, and I don't see much functional difference from condo associations.