3 ms·
Don't disrespect Alan Turing by reanimating him with AI
- faragon 2y agoWhy not? Doing that with historical figures is pretty much what happened in the Superman movie when having his parents as teachers. It can be done with respect and honorably, in my opinion.
- blargey 2y agoSuch movie scenes also imply the parents were directly involved in the creation of their own facsimiles (or just lived in a society where everyone has neural-clone babysitters as a matter of course), and the technology involved is assumed to be advanced enough to be indistinguishable from magic, not a GPT chatbot’s crude pantomime. Do you think that neither is relevant to doing such a thing with “respect and honor”?
- pants2 2y agoHas anyone asked the Alan Turing AI what he thinks about being reanimated as an AI?
- tslocum 2y agoGenerating likenesses of people without their consent, dead or alive, is immoral. Considering Alan isn't here today to provide consent, we must assume his answer would be "no."
- pulvinar 2y agoSince that immoral group would include many if not most of the best painters, sculptors, and playwrights, can we assume you forgot the '/s'?
- Dracophoenix 2y agoBy that standard, monuments and memorials are unethical as well.
- ramon156 2y agoMonuments are there to remember someone, ai is there to force the idea that the person is still there. Its awkward
- Dracophoenix 2y agoIt goes without saying that the dead are unable to consent to any and all posthumous representations of themselves. If it is unethical to represent the dead without explicit consent, the specific form and purpose of such a representation is irrelevant to the ethical conclusion one reaches. An AI would only be as much of an ethical violation as a monument. No more and no less.
- Ukv 2y agoSince it's done for educational purposes in collaboration with his family and Bletchley Park, I don't see much of an issue with this. A museum exhibit of a chatbot answering questions as Turing about his story seems far more respectful than an actor playing Einstein promoting some product in an ad.