4 ms·
He was predominantly stealing US intellectual property, films, TV shows and music and the like. And unlike say normal use of bittorrent, making a lot of money o
by tim333 2y ago
He was predominantly stealing US intellectual property, films, TV shows and music and the like. And unlike say normal use of bittorrent, making a lot of money off it. And being the largest player doing that. I'm not sure about the morals but you can certainly understand financially why they've gone after him.
- localfirst 2y agois US intellectual property a national security issue? I don't understand why they went to such extent pursuing a man for simply running a piracy site meanwhile US is losing influence and trust on geopolitical stage, shouldn't that be the bigger issue edit: im being rate limited so heres my response to comment below: I didn't say anybody was replacing US, merely they are losing credibility and prestige on world stage and this isn't recent and not slowing down. I don't think any country will be able to replace US and its freedom of maritime navigation anytime soon. China is in no position to project as its undergoing internal turmoil. Neither is Russia. BRICS also won't offer much. One potential non-zero chance scenario is the northern artic sea routes opening up due to rising temperatures melting ice bypassing the need to route through singapore and suez canal which would put Russia back on the power map. US is a hyperpower and there is no equal. Maybe a unified Korea with extended northern manchuria territories can fill the vacuum left by China and Russia in the region. I don't really see any other candidates.
- gameman144 2y agoOne of the reasons the US is viewed as such a good place to start a business is that the country will go to bat for their (favored) businesses internationally. National security is very far from the only scenario where the government will intervene in geopolitics, for better or worse.
- localfirst 2y ago[flagged]
- FredPret 2y agoGenuinely curious about this opinion from outside my bubble - not trying to start a flame war. If you say the US is losing influence, then who is taking their place in your view? Is China / the EU actually gaining influence?
- cgh 2y agoIn addition to copyright infringement, the charges are conspiracy, racketeering and money laundering, and presumably the evidence is strong. He has a long history of criminal activity, including embezzlement, selling personal information and trying to run a fake investment firm out of Hong Kong, after which he fled to New Zealand.
- csallen 2y agoMinor nitpick, but he was not stealing, he was infringing copyrights. To "steal" is to take another's rivalrous property without permission, such that you now possess it, but they no longer have it. To "infringe a copyright" is to make and distribute a copy of another person's work without their permission. Both illegal, but very different things. What targets of copyright infringement are losing is not their property, but the potential extra profit they could have made if they'd retained their monopoly on the ability to copy and distribute their work. Stealing is illegal because it deprives people of their property. Copyright infringement is illegal because (theoretically) it leads to a world where people are less incentivized to create things because they won't be able to profit as much.
- __MatrixMan__ 2y agoThis. The phrase "intellectual property" is an attempt to confuse a censorship strategy that's a few hundred years old with an entirely separate tradition that's been with us for millennia. They're very different, whatever words you use for them.
- Bluestein 2y agoReminds of a recent discussion seen here about 'identity theft'. Another blame-shifting concept ...
- adamomada 2y agoAnd then you have the people who say that language changes based on usage. Get enough people calling it property, theft, stealing, irregardless, etc. and then you can change the dictionary.
- __MatrixMan__ 2y agoWhich is why it's necessary to point out the mistake. If we don't act now, it'll eventually cease to be a mistake.
- 2y ago
- xdennis 2y ago> He was predominantly stealing US intellectual property, films, TV shows and music and the like. But they have no jurisdiction as he was not doing that IN the US. When the Pirate Bay guys were persecuted, the US got Sweden to convict them. They weren't extradited to the US.
- tim333 2y agoWell they've been arguing over that in various court for over ten years. They didn't just charge him with copyright infringement which itself would probably not be extraditable: >..charged in 2012 with engaging in a racketeering conspiracy, conspiring to commit copyright infringement, conspiring to commit money laundering and two counts of criminal copyright infringement. Often with US law enforcement where there's a will there's a way even if it doesn't strictly stick to normal legal practices. See also Assange, and if you read Howard Marks book Mr Nice there's another example of where they got him in an unconventional way. Plus of course a variety of drone assassinations.
- TylerE 2y agoBut he was, as many many others have pointed out, hosting files on US based servers
- WheatMillington 2y agoHe has US victims though. Fraudsters aren't absolved of responsibility in the USA just because they operate outside the border, and the same can be true of other crimes.