4 ms·

Ahh yes, for exact filtering it does need to be constant colour. I'm looking into seeing whether it can be done for gradients. However in practice, it works qui

Ahh yes, for exact filtering it does need to be constant colour. I'm looking into seeing whether it can be done for gradients. However in practice, it works quite well visually to compute the "average color of the polygon" for each piecewise section, and blend those together.

pixelpoet 2y ago
If you look at old papers by James Arvo, he has done analytic illumination from linearly varying lights, maybe this is helpful. Here for example his thesis: https://www.cs.cornell.edu/courses/cs667/2005sp/readings/ArvoThesis.pdf https://www.cs.cornell.edu/courses/cs667/2005sp/readings/Arv... There's also this work on analytic antialiasing by Michael Mccool: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/2524514_Analytic_Antialiasing_with_Prism_Splines https://www.researchgate.net/publication/2524514_Analytic_An...
- dahart 2y ago
  Arvo’s work is also using Green’s theorem, in much the same way this article is. Integrating the phong-exponent light reflections is a little bit insane though (and btw I’ve seen Arvo’s code for it.) The problem you run into with non-constant polygon colors is that you’d have to integrate the product of two different functions here - the polygon color and the filter function. For anything real-world, this is almost certainly going to result in an expression that is not analytically integrable.
  - pixelpoet 2y ago
    Yup, I've tried many years ago to follow this work (special cases for even and odd exponents!), with a mix of analytic and numerical integration. IMO linear/tent filter is sufficient. Also more recently there's the Linearly Transformed Cosine stuff, which is most of what people usually want in realtime graphics. Ideally you also want motion blur and probably some other effects, so IMO it just makes sense to use a 2D BVH and high efficiency Monte Carlo importance sampling methods.

pixelpoet 2y ago

If you look at old papers by James Arvo, he has done analytic illumination from linearly varying lights, maybe this is helpful. Here for example his thesis: https://www.cs.cornell.edu/courses/cs667/2005sp/readings/ArvoThesis.pdf https://www.cs.cornell.edu/courses/cs667/2005sp/readings/Arv... There's also this work on analytic antialiasing by Michael Mccool: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/2524514_Analytic_Antialiasing_with_Prism_Splines https://www.researchgate.net/publication/2524514_Analytic_An...

dahart 2y ago
Arvo’s work is also using Green’s theorem, in much the same way this article is. Integrating the phong-exponent light reflections is a little bit insane though (and btw I’ve seen Arvo’s code for it.) The problem you run into with non-constant polygon colors is that you’d have to integrate the product of two different functions here - the polygon color and the filter function. For anything real-world, this is almost certainly going to result in an expression that is not analytically integrable.
- pixelpoet 2y ago
  Yup, I've tried many years ago to follow this work (special cases for even and odd exponents!), with a mix of analytic and numerical integration. IMO linear/tent filter is sufficient. Also more recently there's the Linearly Transformed Cosine stuff, which is most of what people usually want in realtime graphics. Ideally you also want motion blur and probably some other effects, so IMO it just makes sense to use a 2D BVH and high efficiency Monte Carlo importance sampling methods.