3 ms·
> Firstly, the entire port of insurance is to spread risk. I think that definition is incomplete: Insurance is to spread risk equitably. That means accounting
by Terr_ 2y ago
> Firstly, the entire port of insurance is to spread risk.
I think that definition is incomplete: Insurance is to spread risk equitably.
That means accounting for disparate probabilities and disparate impacts. For example, consider "house burns down" insurance, where premiums depend on whether the house is/isn't near a wooded area, and whether it is a cheap/expensive house... And yes, also whether or not the homeowner has a passion for homemade fireworks.
> If the the market for insurance is "too efficient" at determining who is high-risk and who is not, then it is no longer fulfilling its social function.
While I agree that various dystopic outcomes are possible, the problem is not better knowledge about risks itself. Improved information about the dangers we're trying to avoid or fix is--all else being equal--always a good thing.
The real problems stem from those other no-so-equal factors like:
1. Imbalanced power relationships. (Strongly implicated in the rest of the list.)
2. Opaque decision-making that cannot be reviewed or appealed.
3. Information not being fairly discovered/shared. (Customer hides known higher risk, insurer hides lower-than-expected risks to squeeze out more profit, etc.)
4. Bad contracts which pull the rug out from under people because of how they handle changes in knowledge even when risks haven't actually changed. Imagine health-insurance which covers Giant Monsterification, but later a test reveals patient has Godzilla genes, and now the customer is dropped... Even though the originally-covered probability itself hasn't changed, only our knowledge about it.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> Insurance is to spread risk equitably. That means accounting for disparate probabilities Everyone defines equitably according to their whims. Does it mean the riskier pay more? Those can afford it pay more? The unsympathetic pay more? Et cetera
- fn-mote 2y agoI think that the real purpose of government is to negotiate these meanings. That it is difficult does not mean that we should not attempt it. And then you see the other factors mentioned up-comment… If the government does not work out this ambiguity, it gets worked out other ways - which is why we are having this discussion.
- Terr_ 2y agoWhile it's true that Solutions Are Hard, that doesn't change the fact insurance is absolutely not meant to spread risk blindly. Even early proto-insurance of seagoing merchants mutually carrying one-another's trade-goods on their various ships (in case one sank) still cared about how some cargoes were more valuable and some ships were more seaworthy. They didn't just roll dice to do it.