4 ms·
One button mouse was one of the worst inventions. Mice need at least 3 buttons to be useful. You sometimes need to select something and sometimes you need to l
by bluGill 2y ago
One button mouse was one of the worst inventions. Mice need at least 3 buttons to be useful. You sometimes need to select something and sometimes you need to launch it. Or you need to select in several different ways. Because of this miss-invention they had to invent the double-click and all the complexity of timing (try making double click for someone old an nearing senile and someone young and fast with the same timeouts - this is often impossible)
- kps 2y agoDouble-clicking is also undiscoverable. People had to be taught about it. Nothing natural or previously familiar works that way.
- layer8 2y agoTo be fair, people also had to be taught how to point with a mouse. The double-click also wasn't essential, you could perform all actions using the one-click menus. The double-click was introduced as a shortcut. From the Apple Lisa Owner's Guide: 8<–––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––– Shortcuts The File/Print menu contains all of the commands you need for creating, opening, closing, and storing your documents. Because you use these commands so frequently, the Office System includes a simple shortcut for performing these tasks: clicking the mouse button twice. To tear off a sheet of stationery, click twice rapidly on the stationery pad icon. To open an icon into a window, click twice rapidly on the icon. To close an open window, click twice rapidly on the window's title bar icon. Clicking twice to close a window can either set aside the object or save and put away the object, depending on where the object's shadows are. If there is a shadow on the desktop, clicking twice causes the object to be set aside. If the only shadow is in a folder or on a disk, clicking twice summons a dialog box, which asks you whether you want the object set aside or put away. 8<––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––
- bluGill 2y agoPointing with the mouse is discoverable though. If you start moving it - which odds are you will do sometime (even by accident) you will see the pointer moving and eventually figure it out. You are very unlikely to discover the double click by accident.
- layer8 2y agoI think it’s a spectrum. Unless the double-click delay is ultra short, I’m pretty sure you would discover it sooner or later. My point was that you couldn’t expect someone to learn how to use a computer without any training or instructions, so if you need that anyway, you can also include less discoverable features in it. There is a trade-off between feature sets that are useful if you know them and super discoverable feature sets, in the sense that the reason some feature is more efficient can also make it less discoverable.
- justsomehnguy 2y ago"I'd ran of the mouse pad" and pointing at the screen are not the anecdotes.
- marssaxman 2y agoThe original Macintosh came with interactive tutorial software demonstrating the use of the mouse and giving you practice manipulating it. The double-click was part of this instruction.
- garaetjjte 2y agoLess familiar users are often also confused whether something requires double-click or not, double-clicking web links for example. What's worse is that is often not immediately noticeable, leading to opening same program multiple times or breaking some submission form.
- II2II 2y agoI don't know what the ideal number of mouse buttons, but agree that it is more than one. The odd thing is it's appearance in the Macintosh: a computer where the user was supposed to orient most of their actions around the mouse. That said, I'm pretty sure the double click came about because certain operations were costly. There is no particular reason why would couldn't use a single click to launch and application or load a document, except an accidental click would force the user to wait for the process to complete (and it could take an unreasonably long period of time on older systems). Assigning that function to a secondary button would potentially make the problem worse since the user would have to keep the functions straight while learning the system, while accidentally clicking the wrong button would be more frequent than accidentally clicking a button.
- bluGill 2y agoApple wanted to advertise you couldn't press the wrong button, which meant they couldn't have more than one button.
- layer8 2y agoYou could still press it at the wrong time. ;)
- bluGill 2y agoAt the wrong time, for the wrong amount of time, in the wrong place... Lots of ways to go wrong, but they can all be hidden in advertising.
- DemocracyFTW2 2y agoIn the case the right thing to do would be a mouse with no buttons, wouldn't it? No buttons, no pain I say.
- chongli 2y agoI used a (OS 7/8/9) Mac for years with a one button mouse. I was very productive with it! I remember seeing Windows 95 with its right-click context menus but I wasn’t very interested at the time. I was happy using keyboard shortcuts and the like. I believe Steve Jobs was pretty adamant about keeping the one button mouse on the Mac for years and it was absolutely the right call. The Mac was way easier to use back then!
- moffkalast 2y agoIt's the epitome of design over function. Destroying UX entirely so the mouse can look a tiny bit more sleek. Nothing more Apple than that I guess.
- musicale 2y agoAs other commenters have noted, it was from actual user testing, and from the experience of the Xerox alumni. Definitely the right call in 1983. Today of course Apple uses trackpads with "zero" buttons (though the trackpad is clickable in various ways) and a lot of non-obvious (though generally well-designed) gestures like two-finger scrolling, pinch-to-zoom/rotate, etc.
- AlbertCory 2y agoThe Alto used a three-button mouse. It was Charles Irby and Dave Smith who decided it would be two for the Star. It was a bitter debate, but they won. When it was three, every Alto program had its own set of conventions for them. There was no way that could have been unified for a multi-purpose computer.
- wodenokoto 2y ago> One button mouse was one of the worst inventions. Mice need at least 3 buttons to be useful. I think the way the article lays out the invention shows that it was a good idea at the time. Apple sticking to a single button mouse was a bad idea. But it wasn't like Tesler saw three buttons and said "If I remove two, I'm a genius". I don't know what you do with your third button, but I have never used it. It's not a core interaction in any interface I've seen. On my windows machine it does all sorts of unexpected things from starting a scroll mode, dragging items (very rarely) to closing tabs, to nothing on most things. It's not useful. Now the back and forth buttons are super handy, but I wouldn't say they are essential to a mouse.
- juliendorra 2y agoAll lab GUIs starting from Engelbart’s AUGMENT had 3-button mouses, including the Xerox Alto. The researchers and engineers using the Alto found that the mouse buttons were confusing, even this small group couldn’t remember the combinations in each application, and it lead to many inconsistencies between apps. Each button had a very precise function, and they were as much modal shortcuts than direct manipulation buttons. Even Xerox tried to reduce it to one button for the Star (their first commercial GUI computer), but from their own published account they couldn’t find a way and the Star shipped with a 2-button mouse. Remember, at the time most people targeted by Apple (or other computer manufacturers) had never used a computer, and the people who did use a computer never used a mouse! (Except for the PARC researchers and some other researchers, so maybe 2000 people worldwide) It’s people coming from Xerox to Apple who were the most interested in having a one button mouse! They knew the 3-button mouse would confuse users and was entirely unnecessary for most users (as it is today, the secondary click being reduced to just a convenient shortcut, nothing more) A previous comment about the 2-button Star and how these buttons were actually used: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31750283 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31750283