14 ms·
Final thoughts on Windows 8: A design disaster
- donutdan4114 14y agoagreed
- Karunamon 14y agoIn my (limited) experience, ZDNet has always been very friendly of Microsoft. The fact that even they are throwing around words like "disaster" doesn't bode well in my mind.
- simonsarris 14y ago> I’m going to avoid commenting on Metro on touch-based systems for now because Windows 8 is too far off in the future to know what the hardware is going to be like. Instead, I’m going to limit my discussion to using the operating system on desktop and notebook systems. I think he roundly missed the point. Yes you scan over the screen and it might be hard to find the things you want on day one. That's how it was with our iPhone and Androids too on the first day we got them. You all know what happens. People rearrange to their taste or memorize the locations of the less-than-five applications that they commonly use. It's not as if the "where's waldo" game goes on indefinitely. I think he's being intentionally obtuse about this. Windows is trying to unify their UI among the XBox, Phones, Tablets and Desktops and he wants to focus on the one where it will be less useful than the others by complaining about a problem that literally every smartphone user has already solved by day three. Typing the name of the app you want is clumsy, you say? More clumsy than eyeballing a list that gets rather large? http://i.imgur.com/Z0pCc.png http://i.imgur.com/Z0pCc.png If you know what you want, typing is vastly easier than scanning a long startmenu list of items.
- jrockway 14y agoI disagree that he missed the point. People use Windows because they already use Windows. If a new version of Windows is as hard to learn as OS X or Linux, then there's not much point in continuing to use Windows. (The same goes for Office. People use Word and Excel because they know how to use Word and Excel. Otherwise, they'd be saving themselves the license fee and be using Libre Office or Google Docs.)
- rlu 14y agoYour Office point kind of loses traction since I'd say the Office 2007 was a bigger change from Office 2003 than Windows 8 is to Windows 7. Honestly Windows 8 doesn't change how people use computers that much. Most people use the start menu to ~search~ for a program. I.E. they hit start and begin typing. You can do the same exact thing with the Start screen. Aside from the start screen, Windows continues to work in basically the same way it always has.
- Avshalom 14y ago>Most people use the start menu to ~search~ for a program. Is this true? I mean it might be but it seems like something MS would have numbers on.
- jrockway 14y agoIf only there was an OS where you typed what you wanted in an omnibox and it would just work...
- blackspider 14y agoAre you talking about Alfred on Mac OS X?
- cdcarter 14y agoI'm gonna guess he's talking about ChromeOS.
- paupino_masano 14y agoI LOVE Alfred - it beats Spotlight hands down! The best equivalent I've used for windows is Launchy. Honestly Alfred has changed the way I use my Macbook :)
- luxpir 14y agoI wonder if Microsoft's numbers (which we're assuming they have and use) aren't skewed by the usage patterns that they create, with users taking the path of least resistance for the given options, which are themselves sometimes paths of a-fair-amount-of resistance. For instance, I frequently switch windows in Win7 with Alt+Tab, but also dip into the task bar quite often to click the Word icon, then identify the correct Word document open, then move the mouse to the document... neither of which are particularly efficient. The only approximate solution I can think of would be having a touchscreen above my F-keys to select apps with. I can imagine MS have no data on how well that would work.
- old-gregg 14y agoBut what stops you from re-arranging and placing the most often used application shortcuts on your desktop in Windows 95? And indeed, most users do just that. The reviewer correctly points out that this new UI doesn't really add anything, only takes things away. Shortcuts+search have been around for a while. Actually I have no opinion on Windows 8 because I have not seen it myself, but this review fits both Gnome Shell and Unity very well: it's like they all suddenly joined the iphone-as-a-desktop cult. Typing the application titles does not work for me. Because for frequently used apps I already have hotkeys or sidebar icons, but I never remember the names of rarely used apps: should I be typing "Monitor settings" or "Display" or "Desktop" or whatever, if I need to change the background or a screen resolution? Lastly, is that really the biggest problem with the modern desktops: finding apps? Seriously, of all things that could possibly be made better, why are they all trying to re-invent how we're launching applications?
- simonsarris 14y ago> but I never remember the names of rarely used apps: should I be typing "Monitor settings" or "Display" or "Desktop" or whatever, if I need to change the background or a screen resolution? Windows Vista and up automatically help you with this. Even typing things like "DPI" or "wheel" into control panel come up with a list of all possible relevant actions that could be taken, as opposed to just different panel screens. Here are a few examples of that in action: http://i.imgur.com/c9uN1.png http://i.imgur.com/c9uN1.png http://i.imgur.com/hZStY.png http://i.imgur.com/hZStY.png http://i.imgur.com/dQR9U.png http://i.imgur.com/dQR9U.png > why are they all trying to re-invent how we're launching applications? My comment said why! It's not a re-invention, just a unification of the look and feel with the rest of Microsoft's ecosystem (xbox, phones, tablets, PCs will all have the same "start" screens).
- sesqu 14y agoI hate the wizardly control panel, incidentally. Just the other day, I was trying to remove a device. After maybe five minutes I decided it's not possible, until some time later accidentally finding the right button to press. It's very much not clear to me anymore what I can do, or how.
- fpgeek 14y agoFrom the article: "I’ve been following Windows 8 closely over the past few months, spending a lot of time not only with the official releases but also with a number of leaked builds, and I’ve had the chance to install the operating system on a variety of hardware platforms, both old and new." "You may think that after a while you will become immune to these annoyances the more you use Windows 8. I don’t know. All I can say is that I haven’t come to that point yet, and the depressing thing is that I don’t think I will." I don't know about you, but if I'd felt this way about the usability of anything (desktop, smartphone, whatever) after a few months, I'd have chucked it and moved on to something else (or gone back to whatever I'd been using before). Exactly how long should he keep beating his head against the wall until he's allowed to complain?
- suby 14y agoI've been using Windows 8 since they released the consumer preview. I hated it with a passion at first, but I wanted to see if it was just because it was different, or just because it was bad, so I kept using it. You definitely can get past most of the annoyances without too much trouble. For example, there's a start screen when you first load up the computer, a screen that comes before the screen where you type in your password. You have to hold down left click and flick your mouse up to get rid of it, which is annoying on a laptop without a mouse, which is what I'm using it on. That annoyed me for a good week or two before I figured out that you can press a key to get by that screen without the mouse gesture. There are still some things that make me curse, though. Anytime metro goes full screen because I hovered my mouse near the top left of my screen (I'll occasionally try to click on the options in firefox and go to metro instead), any time it reminds me that I can use an annoying full screen metro app to play videos when I open videos with VLC, anytime the charm bar appears (I've never used that thing once). I also wish there was an easier way to go to my computer, because that's what I use the start menu for 50% of the time, and now I have to right click where the start menu was and spend 10 seconds looking for 'windows explorer' on a small menu every time I want to do this. It's just a lot of little annoyances. I can live with it, but I really do hope that Windows 8 crashes and burns.
- mark_integerdsv 14y ago
- sliverstorm 14y agoTyping the name of the app you want is clumsy, you say? It's a good thing nobody told me that, 'cause I've been using the search box in Win7's start menu heavily for years and I would never go back now.
- FixThisPOS 14y agoIt's a shitty solution, often cited by apologists when excusing the shitty Start button. The idea that you're going to memorize the name of every application on your computer is a ridiculous strawman. And if you're going to have to TYPE the name of the program, why use a GUI at all? You're basically calling for a command-line interface. Fine. But don't defend shitty GUI design with it.
- protolif 14y agoThey've unified their UI by making it suck everywhere. I'm still upset over the Xbox UI change. It's just terrible.
- CamperBob2 14y agoThat's how it was with our iPhone and Androids too on the first day we got them Well, no, not really... not in the iPhone's case.
- guynamedloren 14y agoOh really? You knew exactly where each app icon was located the moment you got your iPhone? And the settings, notifications, and everything else? There was zero learning curve? Come on. Sick of this Apple superiority fanboy bullshit.
- CamperBob2 14y agoUm, yes. When I wanted to find the Settings menu on my new iPhone, it wasn't too much of a leap of faith to try pressing the icon labeled "Settings." The idea that you have to left-click and drag a certain unmarked area of the screen in Metro to reach the control panel is light-years distant from the iPhone/iPad UX. A good interface is one that is either highly intuitive, or highly discoverable. I haven't used Windows 8 yet, but from what I'm reading in this thread and elsewhere, it is neither. Don't shoot the messenger.
- lovskogen 14y agoI'm not sure if I remember good enough, but I do think the first iPhone didn't have any folders or second screens of apps – just one.
- freehunter 14y agoAnd a fresh install of Windows 8 comes with only one screen of apps, no scrolling required. It only starts to scroll when you install more than the one screen can display. So, moot point.
- CamperBob2 14y agoHow do you access the Control Panel under the Metro interface?
- FixThisPOS 14y agoMemorizing where stuff is? What if you install new programs fairly often? This is a lame workaround. What the article fails to state is whether you can create groups of applications on the desktop. This would pretty much eliminate the problem. The Start button was always a shitty idea, which violated Microsoft's own guidelines for cascading menus (no more than three levels). And it's a lot worse in Windows 7, with no way to organize your programs into groups that cascade (which you could in XP). The best solution was the first: folders of applications on the desktop, originally called Program Manager groups in Windows 3.1. I want my graphics apps together, my music apps together, my office-type apps together. This basic idea has been somehow "lost" by both Microsoft and software vendors, who think nothing of littering your system with shit without ASKING WHERE you want it to go. Talk about offensive. "There are too many hidden and invisible user interface elements in Windows 8." This is a tidal wave of incompetence that afflicts not just Microsoft but Apple as well. In a growing number of UIs, the user is apparently supposed to sweep the cursor across every pixel on the screen, looking for Easter eggs. Except they're not Easter eggs; they're critical functions. And they're not even taking up extra space when they're visible. Sheer stupidity.
- malkia 14y agoI think he talks about something else. When I installed Win8, and then cygwin, and all other tools that I use - then the Metro screen became full with lots of icons that you can't read the whole names easily, and all of them were the same. I don't even see some of these names in the Start Menu (or maybe i did not check, because I don't go for example to the menu for them). So the problem is that it flattens out the whole tree structure, and while I think this is good idea (I like the OSX dock), it's good idea only if you have few important things there. If it's get too cluttered easily, then it's not.
- gurkendoktor 14y ago> Yes you scan over the screen and it might be hard to find the things you want on day one. That's how it was with our iPhone and Androids too on the first day we got them. Most of my friends who use Windows haven't even bothered learning how to use a smartphone. Those who like to play around with gadgets have long left Microsoft land. There certainly are Windows power users out there, but most of this thread seems to skip over the rest: those who use Windows because they grew up on it, or because they've actually attended paid courses on how to use it. There's no way they will do it a second time. I think Windows 7 will become the new XP.
- barrkel 14y agoYou know what they say about foolish consistency. Unification of UI makes sense where modalities are similar. But touch vs keyboard vs mouse are very different modalities. The first demands a few large areas with gestures; the second demands something very much like a terminal; the third, much more densely packed areas without gestures (because large mouse moves are far more imprecise). I have Windows 7. But I never use the start menu's search functionality, because I have a terminal; if I want to start an app by typing, I'll do it from the terminal. That way, I get completion for application arguments, I can write scripts to shorten more complicated launch sequences, etc. That's because the terminal (+ shell + friends) is set up for typing; a search box is laughably primitive in comparison. Meanwhile, my start menu doesn't look anything like yours. I'm running Classic Start Menu, with programs classified by function: Development, Work, Games, etc., just containing the main icon. I use these menu items when I'm being goal directed, but more importantly, it saves me the effort of having to remember any names at all. Menus are optimized for scanning lists of text; in this way, they're far superior to ribbons when looking for an unfamiliar command.
- bztzt 14y ago? If I want to start Google Chrome, I can open the start menu, type "go" or "ch", wait half a second to see that it's the first result, and hit return. To do this from the terminal I need to switch to a terminal, know the name of the executable (not just the display name of the program), know what directory it's in (or make sure to put it in my PATH), etc. I don't agree with your characterizations. The mouse allows density but doesn't demand it - both more and less dense layouts have pros and cons for mouse and are appropriate in different contexts. A terminal is good for input but limiting for output - I would like to see a command shell that took a text command language, but produced graphical output.
- barrkel 14y agoThe only time I want to launch Chrome (it's not my main browser) is if I want to visit Facebook (which is blocked every which way in my main browser). Now, if I wanted to make visiting Facebook quick, I'd create a shell script called 'fb' which would start Chrome with facebook.com as the argument. But I don't, so I haven't. Switching to a terminal? I'm always in a terminal. I have 4 open on my desktop right now, not including the virtual terminals hosted in screen sessions. I'm pretty much never more than an Alt-Tab away from Cygwin in mintty. Less dense layouts don't work well with the mouse, in my experience - I'm talking about screen-sized layouts, the kind you see on phones and tablets, only scaled up to multiple 30" monitors[1]. Big mouse moves can cause you to lose track of the mouse altogether for a second. Graphical output? I'm not really sure what you're getting at. What kind of graphical output would you want, apart from starting graphical applications based on command-line arguments or piped output? I've written many of both. Most of the time all you want is to view a graph, picture or video. All are trivial to integrate to the command line with appropriate glue. [1] This is actually a bigger concern of mine over Windows 8. I'm normally multitasking across 6+ apps at all times: my custom notetaking app, vnc, several terminals, browser, documentation and two email clients. It's why I have multiple big monitors. Only being able to multitask with two applications at a time sounds like a bad joke.
- periferral 14y agodisagree with you on all point here. Yes you can arrange the icons on your phone the way you like it and yes you can do this on your laptop too. But when I dock my laptop, the screen resolution changes and now I have to find something. On the desktop, I use launchy. A simple keyboard shortcut, type and run. Simple. Overall I agree with most of the authors point. I do mainly agree on the point that users should have an option to have their standard desktop back as the default screen rather than metro.
- T-Winsnes 14y agoOn a desktop, I use windows. Hit windows key, type and run. Simple :) I'm sure launchy has more functionality, but both the windows7 start menu and metro lets you press the windows key and type in partial names to open an application. I find it a lot quicker than using the mouse, and it's already built in.
- jpswade 14y ago> These Ribbon toolbars are packed with small user elements and are fiddly to use with a mouse, and even more fiddly — at times bordering on impossible to use — when driven with a finger. He contradicts himself, I stopped reading.
- phaemon 14y agoWhere is the contradiction? He says they're difficult to use with a mouse and even more difficult to use on a touchscreen. Makes sense to me.
- jpswade 14y ago> I’m going to avoid commenting on Metro on touch-based systems for now because Windows 8 is too far off in the future to know what the hardware is going to be like. Instead, I’m going to limit my discussion to using the operating system on desktop and notebook systems.
- bconway 14y agoYes you scan over the screen and it might be hard to find the things you want on day one. That's how it was with our iPhone and Androids too on the first day we got them. When the iPhone was released, there was a single home screen. Everything that was available to you was visible from the start. What you see is what you get.
- FigBug 14y agoI don't know if Windows 8 is good or bad, but I do know the perception of it is bad. Perception is reality. If Microsoft doesn't get control of Windows 8 image ASAP then it's going to bomb.
- phene 14y agoWhen was the last time Microsoft had control of the image of any of its products?
- nhebb 14y agoThe difference this time is that many of the bad reviews are coming from historically pro-Windows sources.
- FigBug 14y agoIt's been a long time, but now there is more viable competition as well as less need to upgrade from older versions. I think Microsoft would be far better off doing more frequent OS updates with smaller changes.
- Tyrant505 14y agoThis is clearly a result of pressure from investors. Osx,iOS/android and chrome/*nix are all rapidly advancing.
- waivej 14y agoI remember Microsoft being called a "perception engine" by my boss around 1998.
- ams6110 14y agoIt sounds like it's going to be the "Ribbon" debacle part deux. The debut of the Ribbon UI in Office 2007 was the tipping point where I started to look at other platforms and other productivity suites. It made no sense at all to me to switch from literally decades of convention in the UI to something that to this day leaves me frustrated every time I use it (probably because it's not often). The Ribbon is why I now use a Mac, and don't use Outlook or any Office products. Windows 8/Metro is going to be another such pivotal moment. It's so different, I wonder how many people are going to say "wow, maybe I ought to look at a Mac / Linux if I have to relearn everything anyway."
- AlexDanger 14y agoI really like the Ribbon. Just like everyone else I found it a pain to begin with but it didnt take long to adjust and now I much prefer it to digging through menus. The customisation options are also really great. Is there any research or evidence to suggest that the Ribbon is a UI failure? Office 2012 will use the Ribbon (restyled to look all metro-y).
- fellowniusmonk 14y agoPretty sure the ribbon is a brilliant piece of well researched UI work. Definitely a case of people just not wanting to break from the familiar.
- makecheck 14y agoThe Ribbon is too big. It often looks stupidly redundant (section titles matching action button titles, like Find/Find and Exit/Exit). Icons are overused; it shouldn't be a sin to let "only" a word be the label for something. Mostly it looks like somebody emptied all the drawers onto the top of my desk, forcing me to stare at a pile of junk all day long even though 90% of the time all I need from the pile is my pen.
- stdgy 14y agoI agree that the Ribbon is too big. It's certainly not something I want occupying my screen whenever I'm using explorer. Though, when I'm searching for options, I am fine with the Ribbon's presentation. It's fairly intuitive. At least as intuitive as the traditional drop down menu system, though that's probably not saying much. Fortunately, I believe it can be minimized[1]. I just hope that the minimization carries over between sessions. 1: http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2012/02/dont-panic-windows-8-and-the-ribbonification-of-explorer/2/ http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2012/02/dont-p...
- prophetjohn 14y agoI can't imagine how typing the name of the app you want to open is a design failure. I use Windows 7 and OS X Lion about equally and Alfred on OS X and the Start search box on Windows 7 are the only way that I find apps that I want to open. It's largely the same way with finding files I want. It's my preferred way navigate the operating system.
- glesica 14y agoI agree with you. In fact before I discovered that feature on a Mac I was absolutely baffled trying to figure out how people used Macs for real work. On the other hand, I do a decent amount of desktop support in my job and I have yet to find a user who knew it was possible to hit the Windows key and start typing. There's a huge difference in usage patterns between the "power users" and "everyone else".
- Tyrant505 14y agoI too have used windows since v.3 and didn't know about this... One of the reason's I love OSX is using quicksilver.
- nikatwork 14y agotry Launchy for Windows, it's no Quicksilver but it does a good job.
- emehrkay 14y agoFirst thing that I did when I got a mac was drag the applications folder to the dock and make it a list view. Instant start (menu on the side of the screen. I still use it from time to time, sometimes you just need to see the app icon. But command + space changed the way I compute. I understand why type searching was given focus in Unity and now Win 8.
- lovskogen 14y agoThe Dock. Is it baffling how people can do real work via the Dock? I myself use QuickSilver, but I don't ponder over how people do real work without it.
- anaheim 14y agoDammit, this is going to lead to a whole new set of questions from confused family members. "How do I get to Start > Programs > [Some app which was made for usage on Windows XP]? I can't find the Start button, this new Windows is no good. grumble"
- kristofferR 14y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v4boTbv9_nU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v4boTbv9_nU
- peterkelly 14y agoThis video is truly amazing
- stdgy 14y agoThere's nothing particularly amazing about watching a man try to navigate a system he hasn't been taught how to navigate. Most of these kinds of experiments tend to end the same way, unless the system includes metaphors the users are already well accustomed to using. I don't think there's any question Microsoft will include an extensive tutorial in Windows 8's final release. If they don't, we can safely laugh at them. As it is, though, this video is rubbish. I could make a similar video filming my Grandmother trying to use Windows 7(She only knows how to use a specific type of Web TV, sans mouse). I guarantee you we'll see similar results. Windows has a massive install base. One of Microsoft's most important tasks will be to train their current users to make the transition to this new UI. It's not a small feat. But this video completely sidesteps the most important part in the process, and instead asks a man to use a novel, manufactured system with nothing but his natural inclinations. On those grounds, I think he does quite well. But the video is rubbish.
- peterkelly 14y agoThere's another video at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XeeOkHjV7nM http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XeeOkHjV7nM where he is asked to use a mac for the first time in his life. The guy has apparently used XP for many years and is a die-hard windows fan. Watch how quickly he is able to pick it up (with zero instruction) in comparison to Win8. The Win8 start screen isn't hard to get to - if you know how. I'll have no trouble with it, you'll have no trouble with it, and anyone who is given a tutorial or basic training will have no trouble with it. But I'll bet there's going to be millions of users who find themselves in the same situation as the guy in the video, and it's going to be a nightmare for any company who tries to deploy this to all their users. For me the big take-away is this: Important user interface elements should be visible on screen.
- rlu 14y agoOnce the new form factors come out I think Windows 8 will do very, very well. But we'll see!
- aggronn 14y agoIt sounds to me like he loves windows 8, but doesn't like the metro UI. Literally, despite how he repeatedly said "Windows 8 is a totally failure", his only complaint was with the ribbons. Everything else was about metro. What does he even do in metro? Why does he keep returning to it? I've been working in windows 8 for months, and I'm only on the start screen after my computer boots up. I can't help but wonder if he actually hates windows 8 as much as he sounds like he does, or if he's using link bait for page views. The only noteworthy comment he made was this one: > The biggest problem with Windows 8 is that it wasn’t born out of a need or demand. Too bad that has little to do with what the rest of the article is actually about.
- rlu 14y agoExactly. I don't understand what everyone is moaning about. How often do people sit on their computers, open the start menu and just stay there? Never. That means you don't have to do so in Windows 8 with the start screen either. Except the Start Screen does provide more functionality than the start menu but that's a discussion for another day. In Windows 8 your work flow is all in all almost identical to your work flow in Windows 7. You can still pin your most used programs to the taskbar meaning you can largely avoid even opening the start screen for launching apps since 99% of the time you can just click the ones you've pinned to the taskbar. Also, multi-monitor support in win8 is so much better than on win7. There are plenty of non-metro feature additions or improvements in win8 that make using it a better experience.
- petitmiam 14y agoI'm glad to hear this. I felt like I was using Windows 8 "wrong" because I was throwing away the start screen after boot and not coming back to it.
- rlu 14y agoI think the power of windows 8 comes from the new form factors that will become common place. Imagine having a laptop where the screen detaches and becomes a tablet. Imagine carrying that around with you to do "tablet-y" things. You'll obviously use the start screen and metro apps. You can still use "classic Windows" but the majority of your time will likely be in metro since it is so much more convenient. But then, you get home and decide you need to get some real work done so you plop that "tablet" back into the laptop and you have a full fledged laptop again. You can even hook it up into a multi monitor setup or whatever you want. Now get to work! I think that will be really cool. One computer for both fun and work.
- stcredzero 14y agoWindows 8 wasn’t born out of a need or demand; it was born out of a desire on Microsoft’s part to exert its will on the PC industry and decide to shape it in a direction — touch and tablets — that allows it to compete against, and remain relevant in the face of Apple’s iPad. Early relational DB pioneer Michael Stonebraker once said: A company produces software architecture that resembles its org chart. Maybe this is indicative on how well Microsoft can execute at this point. (Though, the overall trend seems positive for them.)
- gruseom 14y agoThat's Conway's Law. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conway%27s_law http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conway%27s_law
- forbes 14y agoI've been using Windows since 3.11 and when I first booted up Windows 8 I clicked the Windows Explorer button in 'Metro' and was taken to the 'Classic' desktop. No Start menu. It took me a good fifteen minutes of clicking around to discover how to get back to Metro so I could launch any program. In short it made a programmer feel like an idiot. I can't imagine how many grandads are going to be furious with it if they upgrade. I have no idea why removing the Start menu is a good idea. I use OS X, Ubuntu (headless servers) and Windows 7 daily and I will definitely wait until Windows 9 before I upgrade my Windows VM. They are definitely sticking to the 'every second release sucks' cycle, like Star Trek.
- bztzt 14y ago"I have no idea why removing the Start menu is a good idea." Because it wasn't removed, it was changed and given a new presentation. The alternative would have been to have two redundant start menus.
- pbz 14y agoEven keeping the icon where the old one was which when clicked would take you to the new "start menu" would have helped...
- bztzt 14y agoThat was the original design (seen in the first public preview).
- objclxt 14y agoI think that's probably an indication that the whole "It's not a replacement for the Start Menu, it is the Start Menu" school of thought is a bit flawed.
- suby 14y agoThey've removed all visual cues that let you know what things do. You'd have no way of knowing that clicking the bottom left takes you to metro if someone or something doesn't tell you. If you click on the bottom right corner, you minimize all windows -- There's a visual cue for this in windows 7. The button still exists, but they've removed this visual cue in Windows 8, and I have no idea why. I'm really baffled by it.
- redcircle 14y agoI'm excited about Metro. I've hated every one of my Windows experiences to date. So I'm in a different boat from most people, who are probably upset about the changes, which will require learning something new with dubious benefits. But for me, I might actually find Windows useable for the first time (where the payoff of using it exceeds the effort to use it).
- Ygg2 14y agoInteresting, you might be an outlier. What UI experience did you enjoy then?
- nemo1618 14y agoI think more people would be fine with Windows 8 if people stopped telling them that they should hate it. Same for Vista; personally, I never encountered problems with drivers/sluggishness that people told me were bound to happen. It wasn't a spectacular upgrade from XP but I think most people avoided it because people were very outspoken about how supposedly awful it was.
- malkia 14y agoWe had slowdowns, graphically, since most of the people moved to 7 it's all good. Not sure exactly what, but it feels better. 7 feels very solid, like XP and 2000. (Man, I still miss Windows 2000).
- fpgeek 14y agoOh, if only the problems were just drivers and sluggishness (both of which my wife saw). Nevertheless, she stuck with it for almost 9 months until Vista, while trying to repair a routine unclean shutdown, managed to render itself completely unbootable. Given that we had to start over anyway, I ended up buying an OEM copy of XP Home for her. She was shocked at how well her laptop actually worked (since we'd bought it with Vista in the first place).
- einhverfr 14y agoWith Vista nobody told my wife she should hate it but the version that came pre-installed on her laptop never worked right and so she told me to return the laptop or put something on it that worked, so I installed Linux. The problem with Windows 8 seems to be a general issue going on with UI design generally. If you look at Unity and GNOME-3 for example, these also break settled user expectations. It's like there is a rush to tell the users they are stupid and don't know what a usable UI is. I don't get that.
- einhverfr 14y agoI kept reading this and going "wow, he's describing GNOME 3!"
- thetabyte 14y agoIt comes down to this: Microsoft doesn't care about the desktop market. They don't have to. People will keep buying Windows. It doesn't matter how bad the experience gets, the average consumer will still buy it, and the manufacturers will still ship it. Not to mention the desktop market isn't growing. The tablet market is a different story. This is a young market with lots of potential and people are still making decisions. Steve Ballmer is a businessman. He knows desktop windows can be as bad as he wants, and nothing will change. But if Windows 8 works well on tablets, Microsoft might have a new revenue stream. From a business perspective, the desktop Windows experience does not matter, and so it will be designed for the tablet.
- fpgeek 14y ago> He knows desktop windows can be as bad as he wants, and nothing will change. If that's the plan, he's in for a rude shock. Given the Vista experience, Microsoft has probably room for a mulligan. They'll bleed a few users, but it will be a flesh wound. Most people who really care won't have trouble skipping a release cycle like they did before (plenty of them haven't upgraded to Windows 7 after all). But if two versions in a row suck, if there's no light at the end of the tunnel... people will have plenty of places to go, and they will.
- nchlswu 14y agoOS X's yearly release cycle highlights a key problem that Windows 8 highlights. Making changes that are anything more than miniscule can happen over a long period of time that users can adapt to. Microsoft is stuck trying to cater to two fundamentally different interaction paradigms in one gigantic release, which is very difficult. I think if anything, the author's article highlights some common perceptions many consumers will hold with Windows 8. While I haven't used Win8, a lot of the authors complaints seem like he wasn't willing to embrace something new and wasn't willing to learn. They don't seem like design failures per se; but if 8 wasn't designed well enough to appease these types of criticism, then I guess it is a design failure
- damian2000 14y agoThere’s a palpable fear that Windows 8 will stumble out of the door. If push comes to shove, you'd think MS could easily make the Windows 7 desktop the "default" look and feel, and let you turn on the Win 8 look via a setting. But then again, isn't the whole Windows 7 desktop just one click away anyway? This whole article seems like its vastly exaggerating the issue. There's a good article here comparing Win8 to Apple's first release of OS X (with its built in MacOS 9 classic mode) ... http://www.osnews.com/story/25691/Windows_8_s_desktop_mode_Microsoft_s_Classic_ http://www.osnews.com/story/25691/Windows_8_s_desktop_mode_M...
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- cageface 14y agoI just can’t shake the feeling that Windows 8 would be better off as two separate operating systems. Bingo. Apple succeeded in mobile because they were forced to break entirely new ground. Frankensteining Metro and the old desktop UIs together makes about as much sense as WIMPing the XBox.
- freehunter 14y agoThe desktop is a fallback. Same as 16-bit mode, low graphics mode, XP mode, or the Classic Mac emulator in early versions of OSX. It's not going to be in Windows RT, and it won't be in Windows 9. Microsoft can't just up and cut all support for programs designed for the previous versions of their OS.
- pohl 14y agoMicrosoft can't just up and cut all support for programs designed for the previous versions of their OS. Why not? Apple managed just fine.
- freehunter 14y agoApple really didn't have any legacy support or enterprise clients to speak of. Apple also included a Classic Mac emulator in early versions of OSX to allow programs to keep running while developers created new ones, similar to the classic Desktop mode.
- pohl 14y agoWhen iOS was introduced, Apple had existing OSX customers. Microsoft does not have so many tablet enterprise clients that have to drag the desktop metaphor along just to appease them. Their enterprise clients didn't have to dictate what the XBox was. Tablets could be just as free of legacy as it.
- freehunter 14y agoARM tablets won't have the legacy desktop. Only x86 installs will have that, because that's where the legacy support is needed.
- josteink 14y agoI'm probably not the norm here, but after installing Windows 8, getting the apps I care about pinned on the desktop taskbar I really, really like Windows 8. It mostly feels like a cleaned up version of Windows 7, and it is much, much snappier. Whatever you do happens now. Even when you wake it up from cold hibernation it boots in less than 10 seconds. When it's only suspended it's ready just like that. Instantly. It's as close to instant as my laptop has ever been. All the animations are silk smooth. Everything is fluid. This thing has been optimized to hell. There can be no doubt that Windows 8 contains a multitude of technological improvements. Unfortunately for Microsoft, they seem to insist on literally taking the Windows out of Windows and forcing Metro on everyone. Even those who don't want it. Every now and then (like when connecting to a new network) you have (Metro) infobars sliding in from the side and you can just tell that they come from a different world somehow. They don't belong in your desktop. And that makes the entire experience feel a bit less coherent. But all in all, I may be the exception, but I love Windows 8 so far. But to Microsoft's dismay, I love it not because of Metro, but despite it. They've done this before though. Remember the Ribbon? I used to hate it and now I can't live without it. We'll see if Metro fares as good, although deep down inside, I doubt it.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- megaman821 14y agoI am with you. I am wondering when exactly these desktop power users will even see Metro. Nearly all the apps I use day-to-day are pinned to my task-bar.
- jinushaun 14y agoI haven't run the Consumer Preview yet, but in the Developer Preview, I kept getting kicked out of Desktop and into Metro when requesting a lot tasks that were initiated from the Desktop. The fullscreen transition was very jarring when I expected to stay in Desktop.
- joelthelion 14y ago>And if nothing else, I want to like Windows 8 because I know that I’ll be spending a lot of time using it over the coming years. That's a pretty stupid thing to say. If you don't like windows, there are plenty of alternatives, except maybe for very nichy work.
- lmm 14y agoNot for those of us with conventional jobs.
- stefanve 14y agoI hope MS will up there release schedule just like Apple and Ubuntu. When OSX first landed most people didn't like it at all. But every year it was a bit better and at least since 10.4 one of the best if not the best desktop OS. Same thing go's for Ubuntu, the first incarnation of Unity was not good . But 12.04 is a really usable OS and for me (since I don't use OSX specific software) perfectly fine replacement for OSX. I'm really excited to see where they are going with it. So if MS is serious about there new desktop they should release a new version at least once a year. Perhaps they will need a LTS strategy for the Enterprise starting with windows 7. So by the time windows 8.4 comes a long Metro is matured and most workers will know how to use is.
- zvrba 14y agoWho the hell reads these "professional" reviews? And why aren't people able to make their own opinion? It must be a dream-job (for some at least), get paid for playing prohpet and writing shit about other's (yet unfinished) products. Personally, I bought my laptop a few years ago with XP preinstalled and Vista CDs alongside. I installed Vista out of curiosity, mostly because people almost unanimously said it was crap, and, wouldn't you believe it, I liked it. I got a rock-solid, capable OS that was way ahead of the clunkiness that I remembered from the XP days and way better than crappines I was starting to experience with Linux. So a message to all you schadenfreude-review writers: go to f*ing hell.
- Mordor 14y agoWell, this is just another Visa - hardly a huge problem while Windows 7 is still available. Just wait for Windows 9.
- jakeonthemove 14y agoI really hope they let users disable Metro UI - while it seemed pretty at first, having to switch to a full screen Start Menu 5-10 times to open all the programs I need is a bit tiring - the old Start Menu was much more inconspicuous. There are plenty of things to love about 8, but Metro just screws everything up, it seems.
- amatheus 14y agoThe thing I keep thinking when I hear about windows 8 is: how should a new windows application be developed? I think it's very confusing. If I were to start an application now, would I do it for desktop or windows RT? If I create for desktop then it will look bad with windows 8, with all the start screen swapping.
- krschultz 14y agoIt's hard for me to say much about how the UX feels without having used it. However, one thing sticks out to me as a concrete example of Microsoft's failings. "Another annoyance with the Metro Start Screen is that all roads lead to it. Almost everything you do ends up throwing you into the Start Screen. I find it utterly crazy that I can go from clicking on a tile on the Start Screen and then be unceremoniously dumped into things like a Classic Control Panel applet or Windows Explorer. Then, to do the next thing, you’re back to the Start Screen again." Microsoft effectively has unlimited resources (cash and people). There is no excuse for not updating all of the applications to match the new UI toolkit. This sounds exactly like happened with Vista. They updated the OS, but not the 1st party applications. Windows 7 updated many of them (Paint, Movie Maker, etc), but even then not 100%. I guess the issue was that the 'Ribbon UI' was an Office team invention, not a Windows team invention, but as a user I don't really care about the office politics behind it. Now they're adding a Metro layer and they made the same mistake? It makes the OS so inconsistent. They can't do much about it for 3rd party apps, but the 1st party apps should be consistent. The cost of rewriting the presentation layer across all of those utilities has to be a small amount compared to the overall budget.
- debacle 14y agoI disagree completely. I tried the RC a few months ago, and it was abhorrent, but the image from just a few weeks ago was very usable. I somewhat dislike the 'chrome' of the UI (I think it's hard to determine what is a button and what is just flair), but I've been running in 'Windows Classic' mode since XP so I may be an outlier. They made that tile menu more transparent, to the point where you don't have to ever see it again if you don't want to, and many of the components that were Vista-y in the older RC have been polished for the newer image. I'm not going to go out of my way to upgrade to Windows 8 like I did for Windows 7, but I also wont be downgrading to Windows 7 like I did with Vista (to XP).
- flebber 14y agoClearly the author is to old in body or mind or both. Yes I agree us old folk get stuck in our ways. But it's my kids that are going to love it, they already try and touch the monitor and TV like it was a smartphone, my 6 year old operates an iPhone perfectly. Yes an article about old people worried about new ways isn't surprising at all heard the same tired tunes with regards unity which after a few release is starting to humm and now feels intuitive. You can wait for windows9 all you like it will just be a more refined 8.