9 ms·
John Rawls, liberalism and what it means to live a good life
- BMc2020 2y agoConsider Rawls’s most famous concept: the original position. Perhaps the most influential thought experiment of contemporary philosophy, it goes like this: imagine you are with a group of people who are tasked to select principles of justice to regulate the fundamental institutions of society. The plot twist, however, is you don’t know anything about yourself. You agree to step behind a ‘veil of ignorance’ and pretend that you don’t know your sex, gender, class, race, religion, able-bodiedness or anything that might distinguish you from others. Someone else put it a little more concisely: Work to create the world you would want to be born into if you didn't know in advance who you were going to be.
- AlbertCory 2y ago[flagged]
- nchmy 2y agoNo one said anything about exact same outcome as everyone else. You've just projected that from behind your deeply ignorant veil.
- AlbertCory 2y agoRawls' "thought experiment" is always employed by people who already agree with him about liberalism, to "prove" that everyone would agree with him if he rigs the experiment. (And by the way, if you want to see ignorance, look in the mirror.)
- harimau777 2y agoThe idea is to establish principles of justice without knowing what your position is in society; not that the society forces the same outcome. Take your example of athleticism. You probably wouldn't want a society based on the principle "society values people according to their athleticism" because you don't know if you will be athletic or not. However, you might want a society based on the principle "society values whatever traits someone brings to the table" because then the athletic person can be valued for their athleticism and the non-athletic person can be valued for some other trait.
- AlbertCory 2y agoThe idea is nonsense, as I said. No, I wouldn't want a society based on the principle "society values people according to their athleticism." As I said, you are begging the question and removing the agency from this hypothetical justice-seeking person. I might want a society that lets me excel, create a business, and make money, if I turn out to be good at that. Rawls' "experiment" is simply forcing everyone to be like him.
- dctoedt 2y ago> The idea of "yourself" having no knowledge of yourself is an absurdity. But your knowledge of "yourself" is likely to be flawed, and/or to evolve as time goes on. As Mark Twain famously said, "It ain't what you don't know that gets you into trouble. It's what you know for sure that just ain't so."
- AlbertCory 2y ago> your knowledge of "yourself" is likely to be flawed I see. So your knowledge of other people is better than their knowledge of themselves? And you get to make choices for them? I don't even know what the point of that last quote is supposed to be. Yes, he did say that. So what?
- dctoedt 2y ago> * So your knowledge of other people is better than their knowledge of themselves? And you get to make choices for them?* I don’t understand: Neither of your statements follows from mine. Oh, and sometimes — not always by any means, but sometimes — others do know us better than we know ourselves.
- gotoeleven 2y agoIf your answers would be different with than they would be without this knowledge then please don't vote. Isn't this like table stakes for being a thoughtful person who isn't a sociopath? The most influential thought experiment in contemporary philosophy is to not act like a toddler?
- jjmarr 2y agoI watched something based on this in my debate club, so this isn't my own original thought. There's a strong argument that the knowledge someone has from being disadvantaged contributes to their views on justice. The original position also incentivizes ignoring the rights of small groups of people since you likely aren't going to be a part of one. One also gets into issues like reparations for past injustices. Those benefit a small group of people at the cost of the many (hard to justify with the original position), but can still be a form of justice since we want to balance past wrongs.
- senderista 2y agoRight, the veil of ignorance AFAICT (Rawls may have addressed this somewhere) sidesteps the question of probability. Shouldn't you weight the interests of a group proportionally to the likelihood that you would have been born into such a group, i.e. by their relative population?
- The_Colonel 2y agoThat kinda depends on your subjective risk aversion/tolerance. I think the veil of ignorance is a great thought experiment everyone should think about, but there shouldn't be any prescribed way how to think about it.
- harimau777 2y agoWhile that's technically valid, it feels like it's going against the spirit of the "original position". That is to say, it seems to me that the original position isn't intended to literally say "run an optimization on the probability density function in order to maximize your expected happiness". Instead, it seems to me that it's intended to illustrate the idea that whatever rules society operates under need to work regardless of what your starting point in society is. Stated another way, while that argument is probably a valid way to "win" a competitive debate, it doesn't strike me as particularly useful for exploring the concept that Rawls is presenting.
- dsubburam 2y agoI like Kant's formulation of this sentiment better, his categorical imperative: "Act only according to that maxim whereby you can at the same time will that it should become a universal law." i.e., act according to a principle that makes sense for everyone else also to follow. If you jump the subway turnstile to avoid payment, what happens if everyone does likewise?
- gradschoolfail 2y agoVery parallel with the maxim (which, i confess, havent fully figured out, yet, but I find somewhat amusing) (P. C. Hodgell) "That which can be destroyed by the truth should be."
- AlbertCory 2y agoThis is not the same thing at all, and Kant was not a socialist.
- zaik 2y agoRules that are fair for everyone regardless of sex, gender, class, race, religion, able-bodiedness etc? Must be socialism.
- The_Colonel 2y agoBoth a communist and a capitalist will (likely) agree with your statement, it's just that each will understand the word "fair" differently.
- AlbertCory 2y agoRawls' "thought experiment" is used to prove that all people would choose socialism. It's an explicitly political use of begging the question, as I said. Kant was a moral philosopher. There is a difference. And there's a reason why Locke, Hume, Rousseau, and Kant never came up with Rawl's "veil of ignorance": because it is itself ignorant.
- 2y ago
- zetazzed 2y agoControversially, Rawls asserts that you clearly want to maximize the worst outcome in this case (the "maximin" principle). Economists strongly disagree as it doesn't take into account probability. If you have the potential to live in Junkland, where life is moderately unhappy for everyone, or in Omelas, which is utopia for 1,000,000 individuals and pure torture for 1, Rawls asserts that you should obviously choose Mediocreland. But if you are randomly assigned a place in Omelas, you have really great odds of coming out quite well. The book includes some contortions to ensure this outcome. It has always been surprising to me that the original position argument had so much impact when it seems like a very odd starting point to me. But I like probability and statistics, so maybe I'm weird.
- actionfromafar 2y agoI am not quite well in Omelas. Don’t think I can ever fully be.
- lofenfew 2y ago> Economists strongly disagree What do economists have to do with it, seeing as its a philosophical position, and not one that attempts to predict the economy (badly)? Mathematically, we can deal with it by taking the pth power of whichever metric of utility per individual, then maximizing the expected value. When p->inf, then we maximize E(utility^p) by maximizing the maximal utility. When p->0, we maximize E(utility^p) by maximizing minimal utility, ie rawls position.
- Vecr 2y agoWhy would a rational actor want to do that though? Show me a single decision theory that does reasonably well in game theory simulations (I mean R-CDT/UDT tier), that also supports maximin, and I'll write a 1000 word article in the praise of John Rawls.
- reubenmorais 2y agoWhich principles would you choose in order to construct Omelia? Who gets to be tortured? How do you make sure they don't have enough friends and family suffering about their predicament to skew off your statistics? How come one million prosperous individuals can't get together to lift one out of misery? I think one finds oneself very quickly having to come up with bizarre arbitrary (and unjust) rules to try and build such a statistical monstrosity.
- passion__desire 2y agoYou can divide the cake into two pieces anyhow but I will choose first.
- Vecr 2y agoYou can't run the divide-and-choose algorithm from the original position, because you can't have one person design society and the other put them into it. Might make a good short story though.
- passion__desire 2y agoIn both stories, the idea is to keep all parties honest in the transaction.
- katzinsky 2y agoSo what do you do when it turns out there are large groups of people who just can't socialize well in an environment like that where other groups are a majority? Liberalism doesn't answer this nicely because of the belief that everyone is more or less fungible.
- rayiner 2y agoThat formulation prioritizes avoiding harm to small minorities at the expense of maximizing the well being of the majority. Consider by contrast how East asian countries approach public policy: the needs of the typical person are elevated above the needs of people with different or special circumstances. That’s why they can have nice things like public transportation and clean and safe cities.
- dyauspitr 2y agoYou need a communal society with enough ambient social pressure to keep people “typical” for that system to work.
- rexpop 2y agoSuch societies may find themselves implementing Procrustean policies meant to enforce conformity. One classic (red herring) image is "Harrison Bergeron," but actual transphobic attitudes are more pressing.
- rayiner 2y agoWhich is impossible to maintain under a Rawlsian viewpoint that prioritizes minorities. Consider the Asian social norm against being overweight and the attendant enforcement mechanisms. It benefits most people for whom social reinforcement can help them maintain a healthy weight. But it’s unpleasant for a minority. Rawlsian thinking tends to oppose such welfare-maximizing policies, by focusing the inquiry on that minority.
- dyauspitr 2y agoYou’re preaching to the choir. I’m all for a common culture and societal pressure to adhere to it. But as circumstances are, the preexisting common culture in the US is no longer viable as this country is now heavily heterogenous, both ethnically and ideologically. You can try extracting aspects from the past culture that are still relevant but that’s clearly not acceptable to a sizable part of the country as they hold the parts most unacceptable- latent bigotry and the other- as the most crucial aspect of the previous common culture.
- throwaway22032 2y agoI don't believe that your concise form follows from the original form. Furthermore I think that this specific misunderstanding is a huge conflict point in politics, and contributes significantly to things like the left-right divide. The fundamental difference being that one can realise that, statistically, they have a significant risk of being in a "losing group", whilst still thinking that designing a society with such "losing groups" results in a better system overall. The stripped back "spherical cow" form of it would be as follows: imagine a society in which you can be born as one of two people. A person requires 80 potatoes in order to survive. One of those people is capable of farming a hundred potatoes per week, which is enough to feed one person but not two (if shared, both will die). The other of those people is capable of farming only fifty potatoes per week, which is enough to feed no-one, and if shared is still not sufficient as a total of 160 potatoes is required in order to feed both. The optimal way to design that society then is to allow the second person to starve and the first person to live alone, even though in this thought experiment there is perhaps a 50% likelihood that you "spawn" as the person who will be put to death, because the alternative is that you die regardless. Extrapolating from there you can have other examples - say that 99% of people are green, and 1% blue, but green people are deathly afraid of blue people to the extent that they will develop anxiety and depression if the blue people are around. The best society is clearly then one where the two groups are segregated and do not interact, even if that might suck if you're born as a blue person "cut off from the world", because otherwise it sucks regardless. Succinctly - it basically begs the question - it assumes that equality and fairness is somehow obvious and a priori but it's really not at all.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- kstenerud 2y ago> From what broad tradition do you acquire your sense of what is good, normal and worthwhile in life, and – if I can put it this way – your general vibe too? When I’ve asked my non-religious friends, colleagues and students this question, they’re almost always stumped. Their impulse is to say one of three things: ‘from my experience’, ‘from friends and family’ or ‘from human nature’. But to this I reply, as politely as possible, that those are not suitable answers. Personal experience, friends and family and human nature are situated and formed within wider social, political and cultural contexts. So I ask again: ‘What society-or-civilisation-sized thing can you point to as the source of your values? I’m talking about the kind of thing that, were you Christian, you’d just say: “Ah, the Bible,” or “Oh, my Church.’’’ Simple: Our constitution, our legal framework that (mostly) protects us from corruptive forces, our ability to trust that sellers can't sell us poison and lie to us about it, our ability to enter into transactions with total strangers without worry, our free elections, our freedom of expression, freedom of association, freedom of movement, freedom to be who we are. People are stumped because they're not looking at it for what it is. There's no mysticism wrapped around our secular societies like there are around religions, so people tend to not notice it. But if you look at it - REALLY look at it - it's nothing short of miraculous what we've achieved. Life before we had these things was VERY, VERY different from the peace and prosperity we've enjoyed for almost a hundred years. And it's unfortunate that people have become so entitled and myopic that they've lost sight of it to the point where they actually favor strongmen as heads of governments... Don't it always seem to go, that you don't know what you've got till it's gone.
- sjducb 2y ago[flagged]
- postpawl 2y agoThe trust placed in the US’s constitutional and legal frameworks to safeguard transactions is commendable but often doesn't reflect the full picture. While these systems are designed to prevent overt harm, they frequently fail to protect against subtler forms of exploitation prevalent in many capitalist enterprises. For instance, industries like fast food and tobacco not only legally sell products known to harm health, but they also heavily market these to vulnerable populations, maximizing profit at the expense of public well-being. This issue isn't just about individual interactions or the inherent honesty of our society; it's about systemic structures that prioritize profit over people. The reality is that our economic model often allows, and sometimes encourages, practices that are detrimental to consumer interests but beneficial to corporate bottom lines.
- StanislavPetrov 2y agoThere is a lot to unpack in this article. >If you, like me, are unchurched and don’t draw your values from a religion, then where do you get them from? From what broad tradition do you acquire your sense of what is good, normal and worthwhile in life, and – if I can put it this way – your general vibe too? >When I’ve asked my non-religious friends, colleagues and students this question, they’re almost always stumped. Their impulse is to say one of three things: ‘from my experience’, ‘from friends and family’ or ‘from human nature’. I'm non-religious and I'd say none of these three things. I derive my value system from empathy and (from what I strive to be) logical consistency. > ‘What society-or-civilisation-sized thing can you point to as the source of your values? I’m talking about the kind of thing that, were you Christian, you’d just say: “Ah, the Bible,” or “Oh, my Church.’’’ None, but why should a society-or-civilisation-sized thing be any more valid as a source for your values than anything else? There is no intrinsic wisdom in society-and-civilisation-sized things (quite the opposite could be argued). Ultimately the author's conclusion is basically that you need a religion in order to have a value system, and that liberalism is a sort of quasi-religion that can offer that. In fact, it is entirely possible to have a coherent value system that is not based on a religion, quasi-religion or mass-movement of any kind.
- thinkingemote 2y agoThere's a current growing body of understanding that what we think of as valuable is formed by religious thinking. I would argue that what we think of as "empathy" is itself culturally constructed. These ideas are real but they are formed and shaped by the culture. The basic idea is that human values and rights are not actually self evident. A kind of cultural Christianity where the values have formed the sub structure of our western lives, institutions and thinking, so much that we can get rid of the actual religion but the values and impact it has had remains. Richard Dawkins recognises this today and calls himself a cultural Christian. We need to look at history, other religions and cultures to see what other value systems there are, and to see what a value system really means. Anthropology really helps with this. One example would be to look at how people treat outsiders or foreigners. I imagine a modern atheist seeking to change the world would have to recognise what cultural constructivism means, recognise that value systems are constructed and negotiated, understand that the meaning and value of things are a process of narrative and probably end up creating something like Christianity as a result!
- crawfordcomeaux 2y agoI derive my values from systems theory, for sure not liberalism. Every complex adaptive system has needs for coming into existence, maintaining that existence, and adapting with the environment. When two complex adaptive systems interact, a third one with new capabilities emerges with the two as components. This emergent system has needs for its existence, maintenance, and adaptability. Most/all of life is complex adaptive systems interacting. So there exists needs we all have on the specific level of each body, as well as collective needs emerging from our interactions. One of those needs, for the sake of maintenance, is the moderation of meeting our needs. In order to learn to moderate our needs, we need to oversatisfy and undersatisfy them so we can learn what it feels like to do so and when. So our needs are nondual, in the sense that we need to fast/feast on each. And then there's the needs related to maintaining our external environments. If we choose to live and serve life, we need to learn to moderate the needs of the environments we live in.
- latentnumber 2y agoWhen do you choose to moderate? Why is moderation an assumption for maintenance if you are maximizing over an individual anyway?
- akoboldfrying 2y ago[flagged]
- dang 2y ago"Please don't pick the most provocative thing in an article or post to complain about in the thread. Find something interesting to respond to instead." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- akoboldfrying 2y agoFair enough, that's a sensible rule.
- why_is_it_good 2y ago_in which it is implied capitalizing B in black is both provocative, and that this kind of provocation is not interesting_
- krapp 2y agoIt is clearly provocative, as it obviously provoked the commenter, and it isn't interesting. A simple Google search can provide the rationale for it, and focusing on something so trivial is unlikely to provide more thought-provoking, intellectually stimulating discussion than the actual article.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- harimau777 2y agoAs I understand it, that capitalism generally implies that "white" is not being used specifically to mean something like "the name of a group of a specific group of people from a given region/culture", instead it is being used to mean the default American culture that provides the frame of reference against which our society tends to measure other cultures. So for example, "Black" would be capitalized because it is a specific group separate from the default of "white" while "Anglo Saxon" would be capitalized because it is a specific subgroup within "white". This probably isn't a perfect analogy, but it might be somewhat similar to not capitalizing "earth science" but capitalizing "Lunar Science". It's assumed that if you don't specify then the default is that the science you are talking about is on Earth.
- even_639765 2y agoThe counter thought experiment to Rawl's is: imagine two worlds, one in which the obvious implications of Rawls's thought experiment were made law and one in which they weren't. Fast forward 20 generations. Discover that the Rawlsian world is an economic shambles of inequality and ethnic warfare while the other exceeds our most techno- optimistic dreams. What went wrong? The point of the experiment is to show only that by rejecting the the possibility that such a thing could occur, you're exposing your implicit belief that you know the causal connections between equity, economics, technological advancement and human happiness, just like Rawls believed he did. But you don't know that system. Rawls's thought experiment's real success is to smuggle into the conversation an exceedingly vast set of knowledge claims about how complex systems in the real world must behave. It's a thought-terminating thought experiment.
- _heimdall 2y ago> Then, as now, the word ‘liberal’ (with its roots in the Latin liber and liberalis) combines two meanings: freedom (liberty) and generosity (liberality). The essay goes into much more detail on liberal ideas, but what's more interesting to me is how many different political models liberalism can actually fit into. The author goes into some detail on liberal socialism. On the other end you can also have liberal anarchism though. I've heard the term "voluntarism" being used to describe an anarchist approach where people choose to help their communities, though the rebranding mainly seems to be because "anarchy" is viewed with a lot of stigma today.
- Kbelicius 2y ago> The author goes into some detail on liberal socialism. On the other end you can also have liberal anarchism though. What do you mean by "on the other end"? AFAIK anarchism is a type of socialism.
- _heimdall 2y agoSocialism requires a very large government vacuuming up resources and distributing them to society as the government determines is most fair and equal. Anarchism has no government. There may be overlaps in people's motivations and how communities of people interact, but the difference in scale, or existence of, the government is a pretty big difference to me.
- Kbelicius 2y ago> Socialism requires a very large government vacuuming up resources and distributing them to society as the government determines is most fair and equal. I've not read any socialist literature in a long time but a quick glance at wikipedia confirms what I remember; Government isn't a requirement for socialism. That doesn't mean that there isn't "state socialism", there is, but there is also stateless e.g. anarchism.
- _heimdall 2y ago