3 ms·
Do we imagine that such progress is achieved through the kind of Luddite thinking that leads people to value "hackability" over never-before-achieved levels of
by mindcrime 14y ago
Do we imagine that such progress is achieved through the kind of Luddite thinking that leads people to value "hackability" over never-before-achieved levels of precision and portability?
OK, that makes no sense whatsoever. I don't think the OP really knows what he's talking about on this bit. "Luddite thinking" is what leads to a desire for upgradability and hackability? Really? WTF?
If anything, it's exactly the opposite. Hackers are the ones who like to take things apart, explore them, explore their boundaries and find ways to push them beyond their boundaries and do things they weren't meant to do. If you can somehow make that into an analogy for Luddite thinking... well... your analogy is flat wrong.
- chavesn 14y agoBeing brief in the quote you've replied to meant that I poorly communicated what I actually meant. The analogy was meant to communicate the harm of hanging on to methods of the past longer than necessary. Consumer hacking in terms of computer hardware is in decline. I absolutely value hacking in any new technologies, I believe it to be essential to progress (totally agree with your comment on pushing the boundaries). But when it's time for things to progress again, I don't want to be caught arguing against those methods for the sake of my own need to tinker. My chief complaint with Wiens is that he argues for consumers as a mass market to "draw a line" in support of user-repairability. I don't see that as forward-thinking at all.