5 ms·
> How can a society function when the rejection of knowledge becomes a political act? It cannot. Living in a "post-truth" society is just a sanitized way of s
by JohnFen 2y ago
> How can a society function when the rejection of knowledge becomes a political act?
It cannot.
Living in a "post-truth" society is just a sanitized way of saying living in a society without truth. Such a society must inevitably collapse.
- blueflow 2y ago> Such a society must inevitably collapse. No evidence for that.
- JohnFen 2y agoI think that there is, but in true post-truth form, that's not relevant to my statement. I was stating an opinion.
- blueflow 2y agoAnd I'm saying that countries like North Korea, unfortunately, don't collapse.
- JohnFen 2y agoNorth Korea and such nations aren't post-truth at all, though. They have little-t truths that most of their people believe in. That's what I'm talking about. I'm not talking about capital-T Truth (of the objective sort).
- s1artibartfast 2y agoI would argue that North Korea has already collapsed, and we are looking at the results.
- rob74 2y agoWell, North Korea doesn't have "post-truth". It has good (or bad) old propaganda and brainwashing, but "post-truth" for me implies a plurality of (increasingly polarized) opinions. So "post-truth" can only happen in democratic societies, and is actually used by non-democratic states (Russia, North Korea, China...) to destabilize them.
- evgwugegwhwgeg 2y agoRejection of beliefs not knowledge. There is a significant difference between the two.
- ben_w 2y ago20 years ago, I studied philosphy. Can you define "knowledge"? We had the tripartite definition, a "justified true belief", and the argument against it exemplified by a person looking at a fluffy white creature in a field and justifiably saying that they know there is a sheep in this field, but unbeknownst to them what they're looking at is a komondor and though there is a sheep elsewhere in the field it is not visible from where they are. I think there is only belief, that we can have degrees of certainty about our beliefs but there is no way to transition to P(1) or P(0), and no specific probability other than 0 and 1 where we can reliably say that we "know" something to be true or false.
- evgwugegwhwgeg 2y agoKnowledge is seeing a white pattern in visual field. Belief is labeling the pattern and calling it a sheep. Belief is also the labeling the pattern a Komondor. Belief is thinking there is a person seeing the sheep.
- ben_w 2y ago> Knowledge is seeing a white pattern in visual field. That definition classifies every dream I have dreamed, every video I've seen, every game I've played, as "knowledge". If anything, it is an easier thing to dismiss than the examples you give as "beliefs". See "naive realism": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naïve_realism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naïve_realism
- evgwugegwhwgeg 2y agoCan beliefs exist without sensory inputs? Also isn't dismissal also just another belief?
- bee_rider 2y agoMost societies collapse eventually. Societies built on lies can go on for quite a while, there are tests, a war for example, that can finish them off. But even then, they might stumble along.
- silverquiet 2y agoI don't think there is such a thing as truth; at least not for anything that matters to human meaning. The truth is we're just apes living on a planet that we're unable to stop ourselves from destroying; a tiny, ultimately meaningless rock that will be gone one day in a universe that won't even notice, let alone care. That truth is very hard to accept (I never really have) and so we create other stories to give us meaning, but these stories are too arbitrary and subjective for us to collectively agree upon.
- hoorayimhelping 2y ago>I don't think there is such a thing as truth This is a self-defeating statement. It's false on its face. If there is no such thing as truth, then this statement can't be true because it would mean there is at least one truth.
- gadflyinyoureye 2y agoNot really. It’s a hyperbolic statement. It needs to be understood as such. Normally this falls into the realm of moral truth. Or perhaps in a broader sense existential truth. For example: rape is wrong is not an absolute truth. It’s just like your opinion man. In an entirely materialistic system morality is not universal. It merely the taste of whatever society wants at a time. Morality is ultimately might makes right. If you can enforce your morality through force, your morality wins. If the pro-rape camp could enforce their view, within a few generations we’d all say that the anti-rape camp was on the wrong side of history.
- throaway814 2y ago[flagged]
- throaway814 2y ago[flagged]
- dgfitz 2y ago> I don't think there is such a thing as truth; at least not for anything that matters to human meaning. 1+1 = 2, the earth is ~80% water, water freezes at 0degC. What to you mean there aren't truths? Do you mean people form opinions that are wrong? Sure. After sitting back at looking at it, it seems like the big problem is: there are small circles of power that make decisions for the rest of their population under the guise of "best interest of the people" when in reality we all know this isn't true. So these small groups make the little people distracted with things that are very hot-button topics that affect a very small majority of people, by making appeals to emotion on both sides. The small folks eat this up, rip a huge divide, and the small circle people sit back and laugh.
- sgu999 2y ago> Such a society must inevitably collapse. What are the examples of that? It's closer to a phase transition than an actual collapse at the kind of scale we're talking about here. I'm not disagreeing with your sentiment, though.
- AnimalMuppet 2y agoWell, a technological society that loses the idea of truth as it relates to science and technology must inevitably collapse in its level of technology. You can't maintain functioning tech on a "nothing is true" basis, because you cannot tell what will work from what won't.
- complianceowl 2y ago"truth doesn't exist" -- except for that truth statement you just made? If no truth can exist, then why are you making a truth statement? Truth does exist. And the ultimate truth is Christ. Yes, those words ring as ignorance to most, but just like we are forced to reckon with gravity and the laws of physics, we all will one day reckon with the ultimate truth. But it is not my job to compel anyone to believe this. I just find it fascinating that non-believers will believe in magic, ghosts, simulations, aliens, evolution, but that a Creator that exists outside of time, space, and matter created this universe? Nah, that's ignorant religious thinking.
- JohnFen 2y ago> "truth doesn't exist" -- except for that truth statement you just made? I never said that truth doesn't exist.
- bloopernova 2y agoI think "post-truth" is a symptom of unequal power. The rich and/or powerful can push their version of truth with little or no consequences for them. Unfortunately for them, there's a tendency for those in power to start believing the yes-men: For example, in World War 2, the Japanese authoritarian regime took over newspapers and newsreels. Any time they would lose a battle, or have to withdraw, that would be stated as a victory. By the end of 1942, they had stated that the Imperial Japanese Navy had sunk "11 aircraft carriers, 11 battleships, 46 cruisers, 48 destroyers, and 93 submarines" (December 8th, 1942) The Japenese people could look at maps, and see that the "glorious victories" were somehow occurring further and further west, closer to home each time. But they had no power, no way to challenge the newspapers and announcements from Navy and Army HQs. And the constant propaganda had warped the perspectives of everyone, including progressives and liberals, so they fell in line too. A large part of Japan's defeat was because they fought an opponent capable of out-producing and out-training them. They had started to believe their own bullshit about being a superior race, about being simply better than the Americans, and as you said, collapse was inevitable. Before the atomic bombs convinced Hirohito to accept unconditional surrender, Japan was close to famine. If the war had lasted into 1946, millions of Japanese people would have died of starvation.