3 ms·

These days, Windows caught up very well with PowerShell. Actually more UNIX-y than UNIX in some respects.

pxc 2y ago
I love PowerShell, but I've yet to meet someone who 'lives in' PowerShell the way so many 'live in' Bash and the various GNU CLI utilities, which I think inhibits familiarity of the kind most convenient for whipping up quick scripts like that. That said, PowerShell is much more a 'real programming language' than the shell languages that came before it. PowerShell scripts are a lot more maintainable that scripts written for those other shells. And there are some really powerful things built on top of shell (like DSC, for example) that don't to my knowledge have analogues written directly in other shell languages. Plus PowerShell has an actual package management story, code signing capabilities, and other modern niceties. But for me and I suspect most others, it falls down as an interactive environment for rwasons of performance and verbosity, and Windows environments themselves are unfortunately still harder to automate or inspect programmatically because most applications don't provide or document PowerShell-friendly interfaces. So I don't think it's surprising that despite all of PowerShell's incredible advancemwnts, you rarely meet Windows users who have invested in it as much as the average longtime Unix user invests in their respective CLI utilities. But for, say, game developers who say 'Unix is not my environment; I'm not sure I wanna bother with all of that CLI and scripting stuff', they do nowadays have an alternative in that arena which is outstanding in a lot of positive ways. I don't anyone would regret deeply learning PowerShell, either. Hell, my team at work is all Unix guys. I probably have the most experience PowerShell experience of any of us, which is way less than my GNU command line environment experience. But if someone with deep PowerShell experience joined our team, I'd absolutely encourage them to use PowerShell on Linux wherever we write scripts, and be happy to learn whatever I needed to to keep up. PowerShell is a nice enough language that I think it's very reasonable to bring it with you to other operating systems as well.

pxc 2y ago

I love PowerShell, but I've yet to meet someone who 'lives in' PowerShell the way so many 'live in' Bash and the various GNU CLI utilities, which I think inhibits familiarity of the kind most convenient for whipping up quick scripts like that. That said, PowerShell is much more a 'real programming language' than the shell languages that came before it. PowerShell scripts are a lot more maintainable that scripts written for those other shells. And there are some really powerful things built on top of shell (like DSC, for example) that don't to my knowledge have analogues written directly in other shell languages. Plus PowerShell has an actual package management story, code signing capabilities, and other modern niceties. But for me and I suspect most others, it falls down as an interactive environment for rwasons of performance and verbosity, and Windows environments themselves are unfortunately still harder to automate or inspect programmatically because most applications don't provide or document PowerShell-friendly interfaces. So I don't think it's surprising that despite all of PowerShell's incredible advancemwnts, you rarely meet Windows users who have invested in it as much as the average longtime Unix user invests in their respective CLI utilities. But for, say, game developers who say 'Unix is not my environment; I'm not sure I wanna bother with all of that CLI and scripting stuff', they do nowadays have an alternative in that arena which is outstanding in a lot of positive ways. I don't anyone would regret deeply learning PowerShell, either. Hell, my team at work is all Unix guys. I probably have the most experience PowerShell experience of any of us, which is way less than my GNU command line environment experience. But if someone with deep PowerShell experience joined our team, I'd absolutely encourage them to use PowerShell on Linux wherever we write scripts, and be happy to learn whatever I needed to to keep up. PowerShell is a nice enough language that I think it's very reasonable to bring it with you to other operating systems as well.