3 ms·
> It's clear OpenAI is a hype company Every other industry: "My new invention is safe, I swear" Public reaction: "You're biased, it's dangerous!" Almost the
by ben_w 2y ago
> It's clear OpenAI is a hype company
Every other industry: "My new invention is safe, I swear"
Public reaction: "You're biased, it's dangerous!"
Almost the entire AI industry, including people who resign to speak more openly about the risks: "This may kill literally everyone, none of us knows what we're doing or what 'safe' even means"
Public reaction: "You're biased, it's safe, just saying that to look cool!"
- sampo 2y ago20 to 30 years ago, activists firebombed university research labs (e.g. Michigan State University, University of Washington, Michigan Technological University [1]) because they believed genetically engineered plants are dangerous. Today, we don't have such serious activism against AI. So you are right, the public doesn't think AI is a danger. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earth_Liberation_Front#Notable_attacks:_1998%E2%80%932009 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earth_Liberation_Front#Notable...
- eddiewithzato 2y agoreminds me, I would’ve rather seen VCs fund more genetic engineering startups. Imagine the good it could do, from stem cells to nanobots to “hacking” human DNA itself. But I know the business model there can’t compete with software. So it will never reach the funding it needs.
- VieEnCode 2y agoI found this guy's take on the AI safety scene to be quite insightful. In summary, he feels the focus on sci-fi type existential risk to be a deliberate distraction from the AI industry's current and real legal and ethical harms: e.g. scraping copyrighted content for training without paying or attributing creators, not protecting those affected by the misuse of tools to create deepfake porn, the crashes and deaths attributed to Tesla's self-driving mode, AI resume screening bots messing up etc. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YsLf4lAG0xQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YsLf4lAG0xQ
- hoseja 2y agoOnly the last one is in any way actually bad and even then it should be in the interest of the company using it to fix it promptly.
- hifromwork 2y agoDeaths in car crashes and copyright laundering by big corporations are not bad in any way at all?
- ben_w 2y agoI would say that car crashes are bad, even though they already happen and the motivation behind AI is to reduce them by being less bad than a human. I think it is a mistake to trust 1st party statistics on the quality of the AI, the lack of licence for level 5 suggests the US government is unsatisfied with the quality as well, but in principle this should be a benefit. When it actually works. Copyright is an appalling mess, has been my whole life. But no, the economic threat to small copyright holders, individual artists and musicians, is already present by virtue of a globalised economy massively increasing competition combined with the fact the resulting artefacts can be trivially reproduced. What AI does here needs consideration, but I have yet to be convinced by an argument that what it does in this case is bad. All these things will likely see a return to/increase in patronage, at least for those arts where the point is to show off your wealth/taste; the alternative being where people just want nice stuff, for which mass production has led to the same argument since Jaquard was finding his looms smashed by artisans who feared for their income.
- DennisP 2y agoIt's possible for current harms and future risks to both be real. It's also possible for human civilization to address more than one problem at a time. "You care about X but that's just a distraction from the thing I care about which is Y" is not really a good argument. I could just as well say that copyright concerns are just a distraction from the risk that AI could kill us all. And it seems to me that if the AI industry wanted to distract us from harms, they would give us optimistic scenarios. "Sure these are problems but it will be worth it because AI will give us utopia." That would be an argument for pushing forward with AI. Instead we're getting "oh, you may think we have problems now but that's nothing, a few years from now it's going to kill us all." Um, ok, I guess full steam ahead then? If this is a marketing campaign, it's the worst one in history.
- gwervc 2y ago> This may kill literally everyone It's indeed hard to take seriously such gross exaggeration. Even the deadliest plagues didn't kill everyone, so advocating this is a likely outcome of creating spam generators is laughable. This is more likely a strategy, common in academia, of aggrandizing results (here risks) so that more eyeballs, attention and money is diverted towards the field and its proponents.
- DennisP 2y agoIt's quite common for new species to kill off old species. We ourselves have obliterated many species that we outcompeted for resources.
- eltoxo 2y agoAs if software is the same thing as a new biological species. I am just so bored of reading bullshit like this. If you really believe this then you need to level up your level of education and learning. It is not good.
- ben_w 2y ago> As if software is the same thing as a new biological species. The other poster didn't claim they were. They don't need to be. They don't even need to be given control of robotic bodies, though they already are. What they do need to be, is competing for the same resources. And there's plenty of examples of corporations doing things that are bad for humans in the long-term because they are good for short-term shareholder value. And filing SLAPP suits against any activist trying to stop them.
- khafra 2y ago> If you really believe this then you need to level up your level of education and learning. It is not good. How does your level of education and learning compare to Nobel Prize winner Dr. Geoffrey Hinton (father of deep learning, 10%-50% chance that AI will kill everyone), Dr. Dan Hendrycks (GELU inventor, >80%), Dr. Jan Leike (DeepMind, OpenAI, 10%-90%), Dr. Paul Christiano (OpenAI, Time 100 2023, UK Frontier Taskforce advisory board, 46%), etc.?