4 ms·
Even if practices so far have been unconstitutionally broad and sloppy, are there any scenarios where such a warrant for that kind of data could be valid? For
by Terr_ 2y ago
Even if practices so far have been unconstitutionally broad and sloppy, are there any scenarios where such a warrant for that kind of data could be valid?
For example, a small cottage in the woods is burned down with gasoline on a night the owner is absent. The police want to find the arsonist by asking for phones that connected to that tower that night, and there happen to be only 3 results, two of which are known neighbors. Still too broad?
In other words, should some of this hinge on the varying size/specificity of the result-set, rather than the query-parameters in isolation?
- wordpad25 2y agoI think maybe they will still use it, it's just not admissable as evidence in court
- hwillis 2y agohttps://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/fruit_of_the_poisonous_tree https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/fruit_of_the_poisonous_tree > Fruit of the poisonous trees is a doctrine that extends the exclusionary rule to make evidence inadmissible in court if it was derived from evidence that was illegally obtained.
- ceejayoz 2y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parallel_construction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parallel_construction Another officer will get an "anonymous tip".
- FireBeyond 2y ago"Our Confidential Informant, Fuzzy Dunlop". Two cops on The Wire do this, and basically register a tennis ball, hence the name, as their CI - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9GJa1_u-VLE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9GJa1_u-VLE
- hwillis 2y agoSearch warrants are usually public record after they are unsealed. If they aren't included in evidence its a Brady violation and if caught the case is essentially dead. If the defense sees that the search warrant was given or executed first, they probably have a very strong argument that all the evidence is tainted. Parallel construction doesn't work very well when proof of tainted evidence is publicly available.
- andrewla 2y agoGP is probably referring to the practice of "Evidence Laundering" which has been deployed from time to time by law enforcement. Still dubious that this would be used that way just because telecoms would be aware of this potential for misuse and would not give the data up without a subpeona or warrant, which under this ruling would not be allowed.
- cryptonector 2y agoGovernment: we want a geofence warrant for ... Court: no Government: how much $ for this data? Telco/bigtechco: ah, now we're talking
- cryptonector 2y agoBack reconstruction enters the chat
- hwillis 2y agoA suspect runs into a garage with several unlocked cars, including yours. The suspect had drugs when he went into the garage and didn't when he came out. The drugs may be in any of the cars or none of them. You would not get a search warrant in that case unless your car was the only one in the garage. The police don't know if there is three or even one phone connected to the tower in that time, and they should not get a warrant.
- tantalor 2y agoHow far can probable cause stretch? Can I say, "well it's probably in one of those 3 cars" so then I can get a warrant? After the Boston Marathon bombing, they searched a 20-block area for the suspect (and found him). Was that legal?
- HeatrayEnjoyer 2y agoWasn't it a voluntary search?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- vngzs 2y agoThere's actually a Slate article covering this topic[0]. First, consent was given for certain homes. However, the article also notes that under "exigent circumstances" warrantless searches are permitted: > In exigent circumstances, or emergency situations, police can conduct warrantless searches to protect public safety. This exception to the Fourth Amendment’s probable cause requirement normally addresses situations of “hot pursuit,” in which an escaping suspect is tracked to a private home. But it might also apply to the events unfolding in Boston if further harm or injury might be supposed to occur in the time it takes to secure a warrant. A bomber believed to be armed and planning more violence would almost certainly meet such prerequisites. [0]: https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2013/04/boston-bomber-manhunt-is-the-watertown-door-to-door-search-by-police-for-dzhokhar-tsarnaev-legal.html https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2013/04/boston-bomber-ma...
- nvy 2y ago
- andrewla 2y agoFrom this decision is it doubtful that a judge would grant the warrant under any circumstances -- the knowledge, for example, that there are only three results, is only available after the warrant is executed. Since no warrant would be so granted, the data that only three results are found would never be discovered. A judge could always choose to grant the warrant, but with full knowledge that any evidence uncovered will likely be inadmissible. Even if a judge grants such a warrant, it would likely be contested by the service provider (Google), and another judge would need to sign off on it, and likely an appelate court would have to deny certiorari in order. And even if it was allowed, at trial all of this would again be litigated with a fresh set of judges, and once again have to navigate up the apellate courts, and would most likely impair or cripple the prosecution of a case where it was used. There might be exigent circumstances where the public needs outweigh the prosecutorial damage -- preventing an imminent bombing or something, but for routine criminal matters the geofence warrant is all but dead.
- saghm 2y ago> There might be exigent circumstances where the public needs outweigh the prosecutorial damage -- preventing an imminent bombing or something, but for routine criminal matters the geofence warrant is all but dead. Is there a strong reason to assume one way or another about whether this will get reviewed by the Supreme Court (and if so, whether it would be upheld)? My understanding is that the Fifth Circuit has become a bit notorious in recent years for its rulings being a bit out of the norm and reviewed disproportionately by the Supreme Court, but I don't know enough about whether this decision might be one of those.
- abduhl 2y agoI don’t think that this is a fair characterization of what it means for a circuit to have one of its decisions be heard by the Supreme Court. It makes it seem like being “reviewed” by the Supreme Court is a proxy for “out of the norm,” and that’s not the test for Supreme Court review. Many times a case will be heard out of a circuit where that circuit applies the same logic as the majority of other circuits, so the claim that there is a strong correlation between the circuit and adherence to the majority view seems extraordinary on its face. Recall that the Supreme Court generally gets to decide what cases it hears and what it’s said about the cases it wants to hear is at https://www.law.cornell.edu/rules/supct/rule_10 https://www.law.cornell.edu/rules/supct/rule_10. It basically boils down to cases where there is a conflict between any two chains of appeals (federal circuits and states). But the Supreme Court is lazy (or smart), so when there is a conflict they usually want to see how other judges think and to see if a majority vote will arise. The cases that get granted are therefore normally just from one of the last circuits to adopt a view (often one of the previously espoused views from the other circuits), and I would need to see the data to believe that there is a bias with respect to whether they adhere to the majority view (if it exists).