3 ms·
2) Lobbying in the US. Corporations can "donate" to politicians and essentially buy their positions on copyright and enforcement matters. I often hear people i
by rmc 14y ago
2) Lobbying in the US. Corporations can "donate" to politicians and essentially buy their positions on copyright and enforcement matters.
I often hear people in the US complain about this, and sometimes make reference to US Supreme Court rulings that allowed companies to donate as much as they want, and these activists want this laws repealed.
You note that political corruption is not unique to the USA right? You know bribery and donations can take many forms even if you remove 'corporate personhood'? Lots of countries have a problem with corrupt politicians.
- Yver 14y agoAnd your point is?
- rmc 14y agoMy point is that its not totally the law's fault. Changing the law without changing the culture will not totally solve the problem.
- koide 14y agoAnd how corruption being worldwide makes it less of a problem?
- rmc 14y agoIt doesn't make it less of a problem. But it shows how the specific laws in the USA are not the root cause of the problem. Change the culture, don't just overturn Citizens United.
- koide 14y agoLaws are (among other things) a reflection of culture. You can change the law and trigger culture changes.
- mokus 14y agoAs was shown during prohibition in the US. The challenge isn't changing the culture by legislation, that's easy. The challenge is changing it in a particular desired way.
- stellar678 14y agoOf course political corruption is not unique to the USA. Really, we have a much better situation than many parts of the world. What's different though, is that the US law will often serve as a sort of template or "social proof" when it comes to something like extending copyright. The next step is enshrining it into treaties or law in other nations.
- DanBC 14y agoBut American laws are important because America claims jurisdiction over .com, .org, and others. And people who do something that is not a crime in their country but is a crime in America, even if they are not in America and their servers are not in America and their users are not in America can be deported (or face severe actions) in their home country; or can have the US forever closed off as a destination. The UK has a few problems, but we're remarkably free of corruption. Most of ours is stupid people offering "access" to a government official in return for a donation to a party, or not declaring expenses correctly. Certainly nothing like the transparent buying of influence available in other countries.
- rmc 14y agoThe UK has a few problems, but we're remarkably free of corruption. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leveson_Inquiry http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leveson_Inquiry
- DanBC 14y agoYes, that would be one of the few problems. Looking at the results of leveson we see a lot of sleazy illegal behaviour from journalists, and we see too-close relationships between politicians and press, but we do not see people paying bundles of cash to influence policy.
- rmc 14y agoWho knows how deep the rabbit hole goes. And if a newspaper says "Promote this policy and our newspapers will help you win the election" ("it's the sun wot won it"), then that's hardly any different from a big pile of cash.