3 ms·
Great analysis and I really want to believe in this but I am a sceptic and this: Interested in learning how a cohort analysis can help your business grow? Get
by ThomPete 14y ago
Great analysis and I really want to believe in this but I am a sceptic and this:
Interested in learning how a cohort analysis can help your business grow? Get in touch – I work with select clients to help identify growth and retention opportunities, and build features to realize those opportunities.
Kind of killed it for me. Now I am not sure whether I should trust the results.
- patio11 14y agoDo you routinely distrust code written by people who take money for coding, on the grounds that it might have been written with an eye to securing work?
- jayzee 14y agoSurely you see the difference between the two cases?
- ThomPete 14y agoI am not sure what that comparison is supposed to prove? Care to elaborate? I have no doubt kareemm is a fantastic at his job. I have simply seen to many cases where a case study is used to create sales. Again nothing wrong with that. It just kind of makes me sceptic when I see fantastic results combined with a a sales message. Thats just me.
- daemon13 14y agoExcept that we probably don't have many gym owners here :-)
- kwekly 14y agoThat's a bit dishonest -- the scepticism is direct at the results, not the process itself. I routinely distrust the gushing claims by paid TV advertising actors about how the Magic Bullet changed their entire life. That hardly implies I think the product is trash, but the alleged results are obviously designed sucker less discerning consumers. And the general answer your question is yes, as far as I'm aware, employers routinely seek references to back up the claims made by potential hires.
- kareemm 14y agoAt the end of the day my results will be different from yours. I'd say the best way to see if a cohort analysis can help you is to try it for yourself. Happy to answer any questions I can for ya - gratis - if you do try it out. Email in profile.
- ThomPete 14y agokareemm I am sorry cause I can't answer this without sounding like a naysayer and I normally hate that. It's just when you have been around on the net as many of us have for so long you just realize that normally if something is too good to be true it probably is. For the record. I think there is nothing wrong with you trying to get work that way I don't find it wrong or anything. I just went from wow to oh he wants to sell me something. Occupational hazard I guess :)
- ThomPete 14y agoI don't mind being downvoted for being wrong. So where am I wrong?
- kanamekun 14y agoPersonally, I didn't mind your initial post about being skeptical — that thought occurred to me too. But then you posted several more times about your skepticism without going to kareem's page to double check your skepticism, which I thought was unfair. On his site he makes it pretty clear what he does and how his consulting work fits into that: http://blog.reemer.com/about http://blog.reemer.com/about Plus the guy blogs pretty regularly. My personal sense is that someone who writes an article sharing his process and results for free deserves the benefit of the doubt — and at least a few clicks around their website to check it out — before posting in a way that suggests that his integrity may be suspect.
- ThomPete 14y agoI am not sure I understand. I never questioned his integrity. In fact I think I went to great length to say that it was not him but that post.
- ricardobeat 14y agoI was just confused. So this is the owner of SocialWOD and a 'cohort analysis consultant'? After reading that I thought it was a guest post or something.
- kareemm 14y agoI'm bootstrapping SocialWOD by consulting with tech companies.
- shadowmint 14y agoI agree, felt the same way when I hit that at the end. In his defence though, to be fair, this article says: 1) What the problem was. 2) What he did. 3) What he found out. 4) What actions he took as a result that lead to the improvement. That's a lot more than you get from other conversion experts I've seen (usually the write ups I see stop at (2) or (3) and you're left with the pay-for-more-info). Seeing exactly what actions were taken for each of the things they found makes me err on the side of, yeah, this was a cool post, not just a sales plug. It's really good to see this sort of stuff turning up on HN.
- ThomPete 14y agoYeah I agree. I probably should just have kept my mouth shut but I was just so disappointed when I saw that last line. I was in fact trying to go after the ball not the man.